American Idol

After graduating from high school, Starr went on frequent bus excursions into Hollywood from her nearby hometown, and on one of these, she met a girl who suggested that the two of them audition for American Idol's first season together.^[2] Starr's performance of "Lean on Me" (by Bill Withers) was the first successful audition ever shown on the series.^[13] In his 2003 autobiography, I Don't Mean to Be Rude, But..., Simon Cowell wrote that Starr was "cripplingly shy" at the audition, but that Paula Abdul "saw some potential for stardom in her, and decided to mentor her."^[14]

Starr, who auditioned as Tiffany Montgomery,^[15] adopted her stage name by Hollywood Week.^[16] Placed into Group 1 for the Top 30 semi-finals, her song choice for that round of an old jazz standard, "The Frim-Fram Sauce", puzzled Cowell and Randy Jackson,^[17] although the following night Cowell deemed Starr "a dark horse" and predicted that she could excel in the competition with better singing material.^[18] After she was voted through to the Top 10,^[18][19] Starr opened the first round of the finals, singing "If You Really Love Me" by Stevie Wonder; this marked the first live performance in the history of American Idol.^[20] Starr was well-received by the judges for that performance but was voted off the series two weeks later in seventh place.^[20][21]

The second of Starr's live performances, "You Really Got Me" by The Kinks, was panned by the judges and resulted in a Bottom 2 placement for that week.^[22] While Starr's final performance of the competition, "Last Dance" by Donna Summer, was praised by the judges as an improvement over the previous week, it prompted Cowell to reflect on Starr's disparate song choices throughout the competition and express confusion over what kind of artist Starr wanted to be.^[23] The judges felt that Starr struggled with aspects of her performances throughout every round of the finals but communicated a shared belief in Starr's potential.^[20][22][23] Upon Starr's elimination from the competition, Cowell gave Starr an offer to call him anytime for help with pursuing a music career.^[21]

Post-American Idol music career

Starr blamed her stalled music career on a two-year restrictive recording contract with RCA. Under this contract, she refused to record an album claiming producers wanted to turn her into an Avril Lavigne type singer. After an intense three year legal battle she was released from contract in 2005.^[24]

Upon release from her contract, Starr went on to host TRL on VH1.^{[citation needed]} In January 2005, People reported that Starr was "shopping a demo record that steers clear of Idol's sugary pop tones" and had "recently released" an iTunes exclusive single, "My Religion", which she co-wrote.^[25] According to a 2007 article by the Boston Herald, "My Religion" was released in 2005,^[26] though an earlier article by NCBuy.com reported that "My Religion" was released in September 2004.^[27] Although it was reported by the Boston Herald in 2008 and by Rolling Stone in 2011 that "My Religion" peaked at #1 on the Billboard Digital Songs chart,^[28][29] Billboard's own records indicate that the song did not actually chart.^[30][31]

Singles

Compilation appearances

As featured artist

Other songs