1990 East German general election


General elections were held in East Germany on 18 March 1990. It was the only free and fair parliamentary election in the history of the country, the first multi-party elections held in Eastern Germany since March 1933, and the first free and fair election held in that part of Germany since November 1932.

1990 East German general election

 1986 18 March 1990 (1990-03-18) 1990 (reunification) 

All 400 seats in the Volkskammer
201 seats needed for a majority
Turnout11,604,418 (93.38%)
Party Leader % Seats
Alliance for Germany[lower-alpha 1] Lothar de Maizière 48.0% 192
SPD Ibrahim Böhme 21.9% 88
PDS Hans Modrow 16.4% 66
BFD Rainer Ortleb 5.3% 21
Alliance 90 Jens Reich 2.9% 12
DBD Günther Maleuda 2.2% 9
Green PartyUFV Carlo Jordan 2.0% 8
NDPD Wolfgang Rauls 0.4% 2
DFD Eva Rohmann 0.3% 1
United Left Thomas Klein 0.2% 1
This lists parties that won seats. See the complete results below.
Results of the election by Kreis
Prime Minister before Prime Minister after
Hans Modrow
PDS
Lothar de Maizière
CDU

The Alliance for Germany, led by the East German branch of the Christian Democratic Union, won 192 seats and emerged as the largest bloc in the 400-seat Volkskammer, having run on a platform of speedy reunification with West Germany. The East German branch of the Social Democratic Party, which had been dissolved in 1946 and refounded only six months before the elections, finished second with 88 seats. The former Socialist Unity Party of Germany, renamed the Party of Democratic Socialism, running in a free election for the first time, finished third with 66 seats.

The Alliance was just short of the 201 seats needed to govern alone.[1] Lothar de Maizière of the CDU invited the SPD to join his Alliance partners – the German Social Union (DSU) and Democratic Awakening (DA) – in a grand coalition. The SPD was initially cool to de Maizière's offer, in part because of the presence of the right-wing DSU in de Maizière's grouping; the SPD had originally been willing to govern alongside all parties other than the PDS and DSU.[2] However, they ultimately agreed. The government, which was able to amend the constitution thanks to its two-thirds majority, subsequently organised and ratified the reunification of Germany, resulting in the dissolution of the German Democratic Republic on 3 October 1990.

Background


The Peaceful Revolution of 1989 resulted in the Socialist Unity Party of Germany giving up its monopoly on power, and permitting opposition parties to operate for the first time. They began to form in large numbers throughout November and December 1989. Opposition groups formed the East German Round Table, which was joined by representatives of the SED to negotiate reforms; at its first meeting on 7 December 1989, the Round Table agreed that free elections to the Volkskammer would be held on 6 May 1990.[3]

Electoral system


On 20 February 1990, the Volkskammer passed a new electoral law, reducing it in size to 400 members elected via party-list proportional representation, with no electoral threshold. Joint lists between parties were allowed, and a number of parties formed alliances for the election, including the Association of Free Democrats, Alliance 90, and an alliance between the Green Party and Independent Women's Association. Seats were calculated nationally using the largest remainder method, and distributed in multi-member constituencies corresponding to the fifteen Bezirke.[4]

Election campaign


The election campaign was short and presented the parties with major organizational challenges. The election, originally scheduled for May, was brought forward to March 18 after negotiations between representatives of the Round Table and government of Hans Modrow on 28 January. This meant that the campaign was only seven weeks long.

Only the PDS had party machinery immediately operational as well as the extensive financial resources required for a full-scale campaign. The newly founded parties and groups, by contrast, were often still entangled in debates about their platform and only had minimal operational infrastructure. Civil rights activists had managed to secure offices in many places; thus, both the new groups and old parties were often lacking less in physical infrastructure and more in political and campaign experience. This gap was closed through a massive commitment by the Western parties, which supported their partner parties in the GDR, and were thus able to compensate for the organizational advantage held by the PDS.[5] The CDU, for example, formed "district partnerships": each Eastern CDU district association was supported by a Western CDU district association. Many Western party members took vacations to the East to aid their party in the campaign.

Ahead of the election, the Bavarian Christian Social Union in West Germany allied itself with the Eastern German Social Union. The Free Democratic Party endorsed the hastily-assembled Association of Free Democrats, which included the Liberal Democratic Party of Germany (LDPD) and the minor Free Democratic Party of the GDR. The Alliance for Germany, which included the CDU, DSU, and Democratic Awakening (DA), was also created as an emergency solution. These two alliances, forged six weeks before the election, had to organize their election campaigns in an extremely short time.[6]

The SPD appeared to have favourable starting conditions. As a newly-founded party, it had no ties to the SED, but a high profile and ample resources thanks to its Western counterpart. Most of East Germany's territory had also been a stronghold of the SPD during the Weimar Republic. Meanwhile, the CDU was deprived of a natural base by the lack of any significant Catholic population in the country, with the sole exception of Eichsfeld on the Thuringian border. Additionally, several older parties, including the CDU, LDPD, and NDPD, were former "block parties" which were subordinate to the SED until 1989. This association created considerable doubt about their ability to credibly portray themselves as parties of change. Election forecasts predicted a clear victory for the Social Democrats: in a survey published at the beginning of February, the SPD was favoured by 54 percent of voters, followed by the PDS with 12 percent and the CDU with 11 percent.[5]

Oskar Lafontaine, who had been elected as the Western SPD's Chancellor candidate for the next federal election, was sceptical about reunification and pessimistic about the SPD's chances of victory in either country. At the SPD's party conference in Berlin in December 1989, he warned of "national drunkenness" reunification could inspire, and described membership of a united Germany in NATO as "historical nonsense". Meanwhile, West German CDU leader and Chancellor Helmut Kohl made unification the primary goal for his party in both the East and West. To promote this position, almost 400 events were held during the campaign featuring around 80 top politicians from the CDU and CSU; the Alliance for Germany held around 1,400 election events in total. At one such event on 20 February 1990 in Erfurt, 150,000 people gathered to see Kohl; 200,000 attended when he spoke in Chemnitz.[7]

Three days before the election, the lead candidate of Democratic Awakening, Wolfgang Schnur, was exposed as a Stasi collaborator by Der Spiegel.

Party programs

The Alliance for Germany presented its election program under the title "Never again socialism" („Nie wieder Sozialismus“). Its key points included German reunification using the Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany as an all-German constitution, the establishment of rights to private property and unrestricted freedom of trade, the abolition of all barriers to access for investors from the West, and the immediate introduction of the Deutsche Mark with an exchange rate of 1:1 to the East German mark. It also promised the establishment of a social security network, an environmental program, and secure energy supply, and the harmonisation of law with the Federal Republic; in particular the abolition of criminal offences related to political activity. Other points were the promotion of monument protection, education reform, the preservation of day nurseries, the re-establishment of the federal states (Länder) and freedom of the press.[8]

At the first party conference of the revived SPD, held in Leipzig from 22 to 25 February 1990, the basic party program was adopted, as was its election program. The core was the demand for an ecologically-oriented social market economy.[9]

The PDS election program was entitled "Democratic Freedom for All - Social Security for Everyone". The PDS described itself as a left-wing/socialist party campaigning for a humane working world, and striving for a socially and ecologically-oriented market economy that pursues social security for all, especially the socially disadvantaged, based on merit. In addition, it demanded radical disarmament in both the East and West, solidarity between people, and responsible management of nature. It stated that the GDR's social values and achievements should be preserved, stating these to include the right to work, the system of children's institutions, the involvement of cooperative and public property in the economy, and anti-fascism and internationalism. Central to its platform were demands to maintain the status quo with regard to the continued employment of the former SED members and land reform undertaken by the SED. Instead of unification with the West, the PDS advocated the creation of a confederal structure between the two countries while preserving statehood, and sought a gradual transition to a neutral and demilitarized German confederation within the framework of European unity.[10]

Criticism

There was criticism of the preparations for the elections and the environment in which they took place. Writer Michael Schneider criticised what he saw as massive interference by Western politicians in the GDR election campaign, which he characterised as dominated by Western personalities and party volunteers, and funded partly by taxpayer money from the West.[11]

Civil rights activist and founding member of the New Forum, Jens Reich, raised similar concerns. In 2009, 20 years after the Peaceful Revolution, he commented on the development of democracy in the GDR: "The Bonn hippopotamus came in such a mass that you were simply helpless. The entire apparatus of the West was simply brought to the East in the election campaign. We had nothing to oppose. These were western elections exported to the GDR."[12]

Opinion polling


In 2005, Forschungsgruppe Wahlen researcher Matthias Jung, who was involved in organising opinion polling for the election, spoke of the difficulties of the task. He attributed this to the unpredictable behaviour of the electorate as well as the total lack of infrastructure and methods for gauging public opinion, which forced the institute to build an entirely new polling model. Despite beginning work at the end of 1989, FW only released one poll before the election, which Jung claimed accurately predicted the CDU victory.[13] This may refer to a FW poll showing that 35% of voters believed an Alliance for Germany-led government would be most capable of solving the country's problems, while only 27% believed an SPD-led government would; 29% believed a grand coalition would be most capable.[14] This was in stark contrast to other polls, conducted without reliable methods, all of which forecast a landslide SPD victory.

Firm Date Sample Abs. CDU DSU DA SPD PDS LDPD FDP NDPD B90 Grüne DBD VL Und. Lead
Election result 18 March 1990 N/A 6.6 40.8 6.3 0.9 21.9 16.4 5.3 0.4 2.9 2.0 2.2 0.2 18.9
Infratest[15] 12 March 1990  ? 20 5 1 44 10 2 2 1 1 3 24
Central Institute for Youth Research Leipzig 8 March 1990 "almost 1,200" 16 21 7 2 34 17 4 2 1 2[lower-alpha 2] 3 3 13
Society for Social Research and Statistical Analysis 2 March 1990 984 9 24 53 11 3 3 3 29
Central Institute for Youth Research Leipzig 6 February 1990 1,000 11 54 12 4 3[lower-alpha 3] 44
Academy of Social Sciences 30–31 December 1989  ? 7.3 7.9 2.0 5.4 34 2.6 2.0 5.8[lower-alpha 4] 1.0 1.6 0.7 28.2 26.1
Stern[16] 17–19 November 1989  ? 12 10 14 15 22[lower-alpha 5] 24 7

Results


Maps showing the distribution of party votes per circle.
The map in the bottom right shows the largest party in each district (several circles make a district).
Distribution of seats in the election.
Party Votes  % Seats +/–
Alliance for Germany Christian Democratic Union4,710,59840.8163+111
German Social Union727,7306.325New
Democratic Awakening106,1460.94New
Total5,544,47448.0192New
Social Democratic Party2,525,53421.988New
Party of Democratic Socialism1,892,38116.466–39
Association of Free Democrats608,9355.321–31
Alliance 90336,0742.912New
Democratic Farmers' Party251,2262.29–43
Green PartyIndependent Women's Association226,9322.08New
National Democratic Party44,2920.42–50
Democratic Women's League38,1920.31–31
United Left20,3420.21New
Other parties52,7730.50–133
Invalid/blank votes33,263
Total11,604,418100400–100
Registered voters/turnout12,426,44393.4
Source: Pridham & Vanhanen,[17] Nohlen & Stöver,[18] IPU[19]
Popular Vote
CDU
40.82%
SPD
21.88%
PDS
16.40%
DSU
6.31%
BFD
5.28%
B90
2.91%
DBD
2.18%
GRÜNE/UFV
1.97%
DA
0.92%
NDPD
0.38%
DFD
0.33%
VL
0.18%
Other
0.46%
Volkskammer seats
CDU
40.75%
SPD
22.00%
PDS
16.50%
DSU
6.25%
BFD
5.25%
B90
3.00%
DBD
2.25%
GRÜNE/UFV
2.00%
DA
1.00%
NDPD
0.50%
DFD
0.25%
VL
0.25%

Aftermath


The newly elected Volkskammer was constituted on 5 April 1990, and elected Sabine Bergmann-Pohl of the CDU as its president. As the State Council of the GDR was dissolved at the same time, she became East Germany's interim head of state. Four days later, after protracted negotiations, Lothar de Maizière announced the formation of a grand coalition between the Alliance for Germany, SPD, and BFD. On 12 April 1990, he was elected Prime Minister of the GDR by the Volkskammer with 265 votes in favour, 108 against, and 9 abstentions. The new cabinet was also confirmed. The partners in the coalition commanded a two-thirds supermajority in the Volkskammer, enough to pass amendments to the constitution.[20][21]

The new parliament quickly passed several pieces of major legislation, including a new law regarding local government on 17 May, a law ratifying the monetary, economic, and social union with the Federal Republic of Germany on 18 May (which became effective on 1 July), and constitutional amendments on 17 June. On 21 June, the Volkskammer formed a special committee, chaired by Joachim Gauck, to control the dissolution of the Ministry for State Security (Stasi).[22]

On 20 September 1990, the Volkskammer voted 299–80 to accept the Treaty on the Final Settlement with Respect to Germany, which had earlier been approved in a 442–47 vote by the West German Bundestag. The treaty stipulated that East Germany would unify its territory with Federal Republic of Germany via Article 23 of the Basic Law, meaning that East Germany, after 40 years of existence, would cease to exist, and the Volkskammer along with it. Its last legislative period therefore only lasted four and a half months. The treaty took effect on 3 October 1990. On the same day, 144 of the 400 former Volkskammer deputies became members of the Bundestag: 63 from the CDU, 33 from the SPD, 24 from the PDS, 9 from the BFD, 8 from the DSU, and 7 from Alliance 90 and the Green Party. Their tenure came to an end two months later with the first all-German federal election on 2 December 1990.[23]

Notes


  1. Aggregate of results for the CDU, DSU, and DA.
  2. New Forum 1%, Democracy Now 1%.
  3. New Forum 3%.
  4. New Forum 5.8%.
  5. New Forum 22%.

References


  1. Kamm, Henry (1990-03-19). "Conservatives Backed By Kohl Top East German Vote Solidly, But Appear To Need Coalition". The New York Times.
  2. Kamm, Henry (1990-03-20). "German Losers Reject Victor's Invitation". The New York Times.
  3. "Goals of the Central Round Table (December 7, 1989)". germanhistorydocs.ghi-dc.org.
  4. "People's Chamber Election Law" (PDF). 20 February 1990.
  5. "Volkskammer Election 1990". bpb.de. 19 March 2009.
  6. Kai Diekmann, Ralf Georg Reuth: Helmut Kohl: "I wanted Germany's unity". 3rd edition. Propylaea, Berlin 1996, ISBN 3-549-05597-8, p. 288 ff.
  7. Kai Diekmann, Ralf Georg Reuth: Helmut Kohl: "I wanted Germany's unity". 3rd edition. Propylaea, Berlin 1996, ISBN 3-549-05597-8, p. 316.
  8. ""Nie wieder Sozialismus" – Election appeal and program of the Alliance for Germany for the Volkskammer election in the GDR on 18 March 1990" (PDF). Alliance for Germany.
  9. For the Leipzig policy program see: Dieter Dowe, Kurt Klotzbach (ed.): Programmatic documents of German social democracy (= Politics in paperback. 2). 3rd, revised and updated edition. J. H. W. Dietz Nachf., Bonn 1990, ISBN 3-8012-0100-7, pp. 447-490.
  10. "First free election to the People's Chamber, surrounding area of Berlin, January to March 1990: PDS poster "Election Program"". wir-waren-so-frei.de.
  11. Michael Schneider: The aborted revolution. From the state company to the DM colony (= Elefanten-Press. 371). Verlag Elefanten-Press, Berlin 1990, ISBN 3-88520-371-5, p. 114 ff.
  12. "Civil rights activist Jens Reich: "Politics is not my job."". focus.de. 4 November 2009.
  13. ""The party strategists should not forget the People's Chamber election"". Forschungsgruppe Wahlen. 18 March 2005.
  14. "Unity expectations". Konrad Adenauer Foundation.
  15. Schindler, Peter: Data manual on the history of the German Bundestag: 1949 to 1999, volume 3, p. 3808
  16. Stern Issue No. 48/23 November 1989 - Germany intoxicated
  17. Geoffrey Pridham, Tatu Vanhanen. Democratization in Eastern Europe Routledge, 1994. ISBN 0-415-11063-7 pp. 135
  18. Nohlen, D & Stöver, P (2010) Elections in Europe: A data handbook, p779 ISBN 978-3-8329-5609-7
  19. "German Democratic Republic: Parliamentary elections Volkskammer, 1990". IPU.
  20. "History of German parliamentarianism: 1949–89: Volkskammer of the GDR (East-Germany)". German Bundestag. 2008-11-19. Archived from the original on 2009-02-09. Retrieved 2008-11-19.
  21. Schmemann, Serge (1990-04-09). "East Germans Form 'Grand Coalition'". The New York Times.
  22. BStU annual review 1989/90. In: BStU.Bund.de; Resolution decision in the 9th session of the 10th People's Chamber of May 31, 1990, see video and and Decision (PDF) at the German Bundestag.
  23. "Politics in Germany: The Online Edition". University of California, Irvine. 2008-11-19.