Candidates

• David Dinkins, incumbent mayor since 1990
• Roy Innis, national director of the Congress on Racial Equality
• Eric Ruano-Melendez^[7]

Campaign

After Stein withdrew, the primary largely became an afterthought; Innis and Ruano-Melendez were unfamiliar to most voters, and the mayoral primary became an afterthought relative to the Comptroller and Public Advocate races, where Giuliani allies (Herman Badillo and Susan Alter, respectively) who had already secured the Republican and Liberal endorsements ran against established Democrats in hopes of establishing a cross-party fusion ticket.^[7] The looming presence of Giuliani also led Dinkins to focus on the general election before the primary had concluded.^[7]

Innis, who had expressed conservative positions on the issues and criticized Dinkins for his handling of the Crown Heights riots, nevertheless chose to run as a Democrat, arguing, "the Democratic Party is the only game in town. It's unfortunate that we have a corrupt one-party, one ideology system in New York City, and I'd like to change that. But being a Democrat doesn't mean you have to be a fool."^{[citation needed]} During his own campaign, Innis also appeared at fundraising events for the Republican candidate Rudolph Giuliani.^{[citation needed]}

Dinkins did criticize Innis directly for giving Idi Amin lifetime membership in CORE and defending Amin's admiration of Adolf Hitler by stating he did not believe Hitler was unkind to "black folks".^[7] Innis responded that the attacks by Dinkins were "McCarthyism".^[7]

Results

Innis received just 25% of the vote but carried the borough of Staten Island.

Giuliani cited the result as a sign of Dinkins's vulnerability, saying, "The Mayor was devastated today. Less than 20 percent of the electorate even turned out to vote -- it's actually considerably better than we thought. This is a Democratic Mayor who can't even get his own people out to vote."^[8]

Candidates

• Rudy Giuliani, former U.S. Attorney and candidate in 1989 (Republican, Liberal)
• David Dinkins, incumbent mayor (Democratic)
• George J. Marlin (Conservative)

Campaign

As in his unsuccessful 1989 campaign, Giuliani also ran on the Liberal Party ballot, while the Conservative Party line was held by activist George Marlin.^[11]

Citing broken windows theory, Giuliani promised to focus the police department on shutting down petty crimes and nuisances as a way of restoring the quality of life:

It's the street tax paid to drunks and panhandlers. It's the squeegee men shaking down the motorist waiting at a light. It's the trash storms, the swirling mass of garbage left by peddlers and panhandlers, and open-air drug bazaars on unclean streets.^[12]

Dinkins and Giuliani never debated during the campaign, unable to agree on how to approach a debate.^[11] Dinkins wanted to share the debate stage with third-party candidates, while Giuliani did not.^[13]

Dinkins was endorsed by The New York Times and Newsday,^[14] while Giuliani was endorsed by the New York Post and, in a key switch from 1989, the New York Daily News.^[15]

On election day, Giuliani's campaign hired off-duty cops, firefighters, and corrections officers to monitor polling places in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and The Bronx for cases of voter fraud.^[16] Despite objections from the Dinkins campaign, who claimed that the effort would intimidate Democratic voters, Police Commissioner Ray Kelly assigned an additional 52 police captains and 3,500 officers to monitor the city's polling places.^[6]

In April 2023, Giuliani admitted to using a "dirty trick" in an effort to suppress voting by the city's Hispanic population.^[17] Giuliani claimed he spent $2,000,000 on a "Voter Integrity Committee", which distributed literature in the predominantly Hispanic neighborhood of East Harlem which told voters to bring their green cards and claimed that the Immigration and Naturalization Service was conducting deportations.^[17] Giuliani says that when then-Attorney General Janet Reno questioned the tactic, he responded by saying "What civil rights did we violate? They don't have civil rights! All we did was prevent people who can't vote from voting. Maybe we tricked them, but tricking is not a crime."^[17] He also stated that "in those days, we didn't have crazy prosecutors. Nowadays, they'll probably prosecute you for it … and that's the way we kept down the Hispanic vote."^[17]

Results

Dinkins earned 48.3 percent of the vote, down from 51 percent in 1989.^[1] Although he was a moderate with a substantial history of building coalitions and supporting Jewish causes,^[18] one factor in Dinkins' loss was his perceived indifference to the plight of the Jewish community during the Crown Heights riot. Another was a strong turnout for Giuliani in Staten Island; a referendum on Staten Island's secession from New York City was placed on the ballot that year by Governor Mario Cuomo and the New York State Legislature. Dinkins defeated Giuliani handily in Manhattan, the Bronx, and narrowly won Brooklyn.

However, Giuliani's margin in the other two boroughs was large enough to win the election. Giuliani won by a margin of 53,367 votes. He became the first Republican elected Mayor of New York City since John Lindsay in 1965.^[19]