2007 Belgian federal election


Federal elections were held in Belgium on 10 June 2007. Voters went to the polls in order to elect new members for the Chamber of Representatives and Senate.

2007 Belgian federal election

 2003 10 June 2007 (2007-06-10) 2010 

All 150 seats in the Chamber of Representatives
76 seats needed for a majority
40 of 71 seats in the Senate
Turnout91.08%
Party Leader % Seats ±
Chamber of Representatives
CD&VN-VA Yves Leterme 18.51% 30 +8
MR Didier Reynders 12.52% 23 -1
VB Frank Vanhecke 11.99% 17 -1
Open Vld Guy Verhofstadt 11.83% 18 -7
PS Elio Di Rupo 10.86% 20 -5
sp.aspirit Johan Vande Lanotte 10.26% 14 -9
cdH Joëlle Milquet 6.06% 10 +2
Ecolo Jean-Michel Javaux
Isabelle Durant
5.10% 8 +4
Lijst Dedecker Jean-Marie Dedecker 4.03% 5 New
Groen Vera Dua 3.98% 4 +4
FN Daniel Féret 1.97% 1 0
Senate
CD&VN-VA Yves Leterme 19.42% 9 +3
Open Vld Guy Verhofstadt 12.40% 5 -2
MR Didier Reynders 12.31% 6 +1
VB Frank Vanhecke 11.89% 5 0
PS Elio Di Rupo 10.24% 4 -2
sp.aspirit Johan Vande Lanotte 10.04% 4 -3
cdH Joëlle Milquet 5.90% 2 0
Ecolo Jean-Michel Javaux
Isabelle Durant
5.82% 2 +1
Groen Vera Dua 3.64% 1 +1
Lijst Dedecker Jean-Marie Dedecker 3.38% 5 New
FN Daniel Féret 2.27% 1 0
This lists parties that won seats. See the complete results below.
Colours denote the party receiving a plurality of votes per electoral canton * CD&V and N-VA were in a Cartel during the 2007 election; results shown for CD&V were for both parties during the 2007 election.
Federal Government before Federal Government after
Verhofstadt II Government Verhofstadt III Government
(interim)
Voters in Leuven on 10 June 2007
2007–2011 Belgian political crisis

Timeline
See also

Eligible voters were Belgian citizens 18 years and older. There was a legal electoral threshold of 5% for political parties to meet to receive representation, but in several election districts the real electoral threshold is higher than the legal, due to the small number of seats to be elected in the particular district. The 150 members of the Chamber of Representatives were elected from 11 electoral districts. The 40 Senate members were elected from the Dutch (25) and Francophone (15) electoral colleges.

Of the Flemish parties, the alliance of Christian Democratic and Flemish party (CD&V) and the New-Flemish Alliance (N-VA) received an increased share of the vote from the previous election, held in 2003. The CD&V/N-VA list was headed by Yves Leterme, and became the largest political formation in Belgium, thus leading the coalition talks for a new government.[1] Vlaams Belang received more votes than in the previous election, but lost one seat. Groen! was able to return to parliament and newcomers Lijst Dedecker surprised most by immediately grabbing six seats, including one in the Senate. Prime minister Guy Verhofstadt's "purple coalition," consisting of his Open Flemish Liberals and Democrats (Open Vld) alliance list and Socialist Party – Different (sp.a/spirit), was punished in the election, with the sp.a/spirit alliance losing somewhat more than Verhofstadt's Open Vld alliance. The day after the election, Verhofstadt handed in the resignation of his government to King Albert II.[2][3] SP.A leader Johan Vande Lanotte resigned from his leadership position as well that day.[4]

The Francophone situation did not mirror its Flemish counterpart. While Verhofstadt's Open Vld struggled, its Francophone sister party Mouvement Réformateur managed to defeat the long-dominant Parti Socialiste (PS), although the PS remained strong in Hainaut and Liège. The Humanist Democratic Centre brought in a positive result as well, but the biggest gains were for the environmentalist party Ecolo.

The overall outcome of the elections was that the liberal fraction (MR, Open Vld) became the largest group in parliament with, followed by the Christian Democrats (CD&V, cdH) and N-VA with 40 seats. The electoral alliance between the Flemish CD&V and N-VA parties became the biggest single parliamentary grouping (25 seats for CD&V and 5 for N-VA).

Background


The previous general election in 2003 had resulted in a coalition between the socialist parties sp.a/spirit (Flemish) and the Parti Socialiste (Francophone), and the centrist liberal-democratic parties VLD/Vivant (Flemish) and MR (Francophone), with Guy Verhofstadt of the VLD to retaining his position of Prime Minister of Belgium until 2007.

Parties


Only parties who fielded candidates for the Belgian Senate are listed.

Flemish parties (Dutch speaking)

These Flemish parties field candidates in the regions of Flanders and the partially bilingual electoral district Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde.

CD&V/N-VA

The Christian Democratic and Flemish party (CD&V) is a Christian Democratic party that has formed an alliance with the Flemish nationalist party New-Flemish Alliance (N-VA). Most polls in the run-up to the election suggested that the alliance would win the election and become the largest political force in Flanders. It is led by Yves Leterme, current prime minister of the Flemish Region and Community.

Having become the largest political party in the Belgian Chamber after the 2007 election, the alliance will become the fulcrum of the coalition talks for a new government. Commentators suggest that coalition talks will be difficult, as most Francophone parties see the alliance as being overly Flemish-dominated.

VB

It was the first time that the Flemish Interest (Vlaams Belang, VB) had taken part in federal elections under its new name. Ostracized by all other political parties because of its views on foreigners and immigration, the VB is unlikely to take part in a new government. The VB's lists also included members of the right-liberal Flemish Liberal Independent Tolerant and Transparent party (VLOTT) of Hugo Coveliers.

sp.a-spirit

The Socialistische Partij Anders is a social-democratic party and has formed a cartel list with the Flemish regionalist and left liberal party Spirit. Like their coalition partner VLD, they lost heavily in the election, which prompted sp.a party leader Johan Vande Lanotte to step down. Vande Lanotte made it also clear that the alliance will not take part in a federal government whose sole concern is state reform.

Open VLD

Open Flemish Liberals and Democrats (Open Vld) is the alliance list of the Flemish Liberals and Democrats (VLD) of prime minister Guy Verhofstadt, and the small liberal political parties Vivant (left-liberal) and Liberal Appeal (Liberaal Appèl) (right-liberal).

The VLD has seen some infighting in the last years, resulting in two prominent members leaving the party, Hugo Coveliers (VLOTT) and Jean-Marie Dedecker (Lijst Dedecker). After the 2006 municipal elections, the party had tried to revamp itself with the newly named Open Vld cartel, under direction of noted political strategist Noël Slangen.

Groen!

Groen! is an ecological party, and the successor of Agalev. It hoped to make a return to the federal legislature after being wiped out in the 2003 general election. They managed to return to the Belgian parliament with four House seats and one senate seat, but their result of 6.3% was below expectations.[5]

LDD

List Dedecker (Lijst Dedecker) is a liberal offshoot of the Flemish Liberals and Democrats, founded by Belgian Senator Jean-Marie Dedecker and Boudewijn Bouckaert, chairman of the Nova Civitas think tank. The party surprised some who doubted it would clear the 5% electoral threshold by receiving 6.3% of the Flemish vote.

PVDA+

The Workers Party of Belgium (Partij van de Arbeid van België) is a radical left wing party, of Maoist origin. Its lists also contain independent candidates. The PVDA almost doubled their votes, from 0.5% to 0.9%.

CAP

The Committee for Another Policy (Comité voor een Andere Politiek) is a bilingual left wing political movement, consisting of trade union militants, and political militants of communist, Trotskyist and socialist origin. It was formed in 2006 as a reaction to the more centrist course of the SP.a. Former SP.a-representative Jef Sleeckx is one of the co-founders. These elections were the first the movement participated in. They got 0.4% of the votes in Flanders.

Francophone parties (French speaking)

These Francophone parties fielded candidates in the Walloon Region and in the electoral district Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde.

PS

The Parti Socialiste (PS) is a social-democratic party that took part in the Verhofstadt I Government and the Verhofstadt II Government. It is unlikely that the PS will deliver Belgium's next prime minister, the last Francophone prime minister was Paul Vanden Boeynants in 1978-79. Largest competitor of the PS is the Mouvement Réformateur (MR), which just recently broke with the PS in Charleroi, after PS aldermen were charged with corruption.

MR

The Mouvement Réformateur is a liberal party. It is a fusion of the Liberal Reformist Party (PRL), the French-linguistic party Democratic Front of Francophones (FDF) and a breakaway fraction of the Christian democratic Citizens' Movement for Change (MCC). It had taken part in the federal government of Guy Verhofstadt, which included MR leader Didier Reynders as finance minister.

The MR clearly won the elections in the French-speaking Walloon region, and the bilingual Brussels-Capital Region, ousting the previously dominant Parti Socialiste. The MR campaigned on three major fronts: the need for an alternative to the PS, entangled in various scandals of corruption and accused of poor governance leading to unemployment and anachronistic political systems; the need for a new fiscal reform; lowering taxes and government grip on the economy; and finally friendliness and cooperation with its Flemish counterpart, Open VLD.

cdH

The Centre Démocrate Humaniste is a Christian democratic party. They made a small advance (0.4%) in these elections and finished with 15.8% of the votes.

Ecolo

Ecolo is a Green party. It made the largest gains of the 2007 election among Francophone parties and went from 7.5% to 12.8%.

FN

The Front National is a Franco-nationalist political movement known for its tough stances on immigration. They gained 5.6% of the vote, the same as in 2003.

CAP

The Committee for Another Policy (Comité pour une Autre Politique) was a bilingual left wing political movement, consisting of trade union militants, and political militants of communist, Trotskyist and socialist origin. It was formed in 2006 as a reaction to the more centrist course of the PS and the SP.a. Former FGTB-chairman Georges Debunne was one of the co-founders. These elections were the first the movement participated in. The party got 0.2% of the votes in Hainaut and Liège, the two provinces where its candidates stood.

Issues


Good governance

CD&V used the theme of good governance as a breaking point against sp.a and VLD. The party claimed that unlike in the Flemish Government, where CD&V leader Leterme heads a tripartite government, with CD&V, VLD and sp.a, the federal government lacked good governance. sp.a and VLD tried to counter this charge with similar examples in the Flemish Government of practices which CD&V accused them of.

Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde and constitutionality

With the federal elections looming, the problem of the electoral district of Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde (B-H-V) re-emerged. Because the federal government failed to comply with a ruling of the Court of Arbitration which declared the provincial electoral districts compared to the two remaining arrondisemental ones in the former province of Brabant unconstitutional. According to the ruling of the Court of Arbitration the current situation would make federal elections impossible after 24 June 2007, so the new government will have to solve the situation. Several mayors in the Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde area have threatened and actually have refused to compile the lists of electors. The governor took over their task.

Professor and constitutional expert Paul Van Orshoven from the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven declared that the elections would be unconstitutional. According to Van Orshoven there were two problems:

  • As the previous election was held on Sunday 18 May 2003, the final date to hold elections (four years from the previous) would be Sunday, 13 May 2007.
  • The Court of Arbitration gave the government the time to fix the B-H-V problem until the next elections. That hasn't happened, which means that the election results could be declared void.

Corruption in the Walloon Region

During the campaign new irregularities and corruption in PS-lead Charleroi emerged. The MR started using this as an example of why things in Wallonia under PS management were bad. The campaign became hostile and personal attacks between various MR, cdH and PS leaders dominated the campaign.

Armenian genocide

In the run-up to the election, Johan Vande Lanotte, leader of the Socialist Party – Different, refused to acknowledge the Turkish genocide on its Armenian minority in the midst of a controversy about the strong allegiance to Turkey expressed in Turkish at a meeting by a Turkish-Belgian CD&V Senate candidate, Ergün Top,[6][7] but also in the aftermath of a similar problem aroused during the campaign for the Dutch general election a few months earlier. The position of Yves Leterme (CD&V) on this issue was unclear at first, but he later confided to the Flemish parliament that he does acknowledge the Armenian genocide.[8][9]

In 1998, the Belgian Senate had already passed a resolution acknowledging the Armenian genocide, including the support of SP (later sp.a) and CVP (later CD&V) senators.[10][11]

Opinion polls


The polls conducted by the Stemmenkampioen site of Het Laatste Nieuws and the Vrije Universiteit Brussel , yield the following overall result for Flanders, compared to the 2003 Senate elections. De Standaard and the VRT conducted a similar poll in November 2006, in March 2007 (the first poll in which Lijst Dedecker, a Flemish party founded in January 2007, was measured) and in May 2007.

Flanders

Polling firm Fieldwork date Sample
size
Margin
of error
CD&VN-VA VB sp.aspirit Open Vld Groen! LDD Others / None Lead
De Standaart/VRT 8 Jun 2007 29.9% 21.4% 19.4% 17.7% 7.7% 3.8% 0.3% 8.5%
ULB/Le Soir/RTBf 17–30 May 2007 3,070 ± 2.2% 29.7% 21.6% 19.7% 17.3% 7.4% 8.1%
De Standaart/VRT 17 Apr–11 May 2007 4,206 29.9% 20.7% 20.4% 17.3% 8.4% 2.1% 1.1% 9.2%
ULB/Le Soir/RTBf 29 Apr 2007 870 ± 2.2% 29.6% 21.9% 20.3% 16.6% 6.7% 2.8% 7.7%
De Standaart/VRT 16 Mar 2007 30.4% 20.8% 20.7% 16.9% 7.6% 3.2% 9.6%
Het Laatste Nieuws Jan 2007 812 30% 20% 17% 15% 5% 10%
De Standaart/VRT 31 Oct–16 Nov 2006 1,076 32.7% 21.9% 19.7% 17.3% 7.6% 10.8%

Wallonia

Polling firm Fieldwork date Sample
size
Margin
of error
PS MR cdH Ecolo FN Others / None Lead
ULB/Le Soir/RTBf 17–30 May 2007 3,070 ± 2.2% 31.4% 26.5% 19.2% 9.7% 8.1% 4.9%
ULB/Le Soir/RTBf 29 Apr 2007 3,390 ± 2.2% 33.4% 24.5% 19.0% 9.6% 8.2% 8.9%

Brussels

Polling firm Fieldwork date Sample
size
Margin
of error
MR PS cdH Ecolo Others / None Lead
ULB/Le Soir/RTBf 17–30 May 2007 3,070 ± 2.2% 27.4% 25.0% 15.3% 10.5% 2.4%
ULB/Le Soir/RTBf 29 Apr 2007 880 ± 2.2% 27.9% 25.9% 2.0%

Results


This graph shows the Belgian Chamber of Representatives 2007 election results (colour) compared to those of 2003 (grey).
This graph shows the Dutch-speaking Belgian Senate 2007 election results (colour) compared to those of 2003 (grey).
This chart shows the Belgian Chamber of Representatives 2007 election results (right) compared to those of 2003 (left). The bold line shows the majority coalition.

Chamber of Representatives

PartyVotes%+/–Seats+/–
CD&VNew Flemish Alliance1,234,95018.51+2.2030+8
Mouvement Réformateur835,07312.52+1.1223–1
Vlaams Belang799,84411.99+0.4017–1
Open Vlaamse Liberalen en Democraten789,44511.83–3.5318–7
Parti Socialiste724,78710.86–2.1620–5
Socialistische Partij AndersSpirit684,39010.26–4.6514–9
Centre démocrate humaniste404,0776.06+0.5910+2
Ecolo340,3785.10+2.048+4
Lijst Dedecker268,6484.03New5New
Groen!265,8283.98+1.514+4
National Front131,3851.97–0.0110
Workers' Party of Belgium56,1670.84+0.5300
Rassemblement Wallonie France26,2400.39+0.0000
Committee for Another Policy20,0830.30New0New
Communist Party of Belgium19,3290.29+0.1900
Chrétiens démocrates fédéraux11,9610.18–0.4000
Front Nouveau de Belgique9,0100.14+0.0400
Wallon8,6880.13New0New
Belgian Union8,6070.13+0.0900
National Force6,6600.10New0New
Vivant5,7420.09–0.3500
Parti jeunes musulmans4,3730.07New0New
Parti Wallon3,1390.05New0New
Vrijheid, Intimiteit, Thuis, Arbeid en Liefde1,7800.03+0.0100
Nieuwe Partij – Fervent Nationaal1,6050.02New0New
Vélorution1,4530.02New0New
Union pour un mouvement populaire – Belgique1,4080.02New0New
MP Éducation1,3620.02New0New
Trefle9200.01New0New
Front des Bruxellois9010.01New0New
Belgique Positif8800.01New0New
Unie8560.01New0New
Pluralis7570.01New0New
Droit et libertés des citoyens4640.01New0New
Groupe social des citoyens démocrates1700.00New0New
Total6,671,360100.001500
Valid votes6,671,36094.87
Invalid/blank votes360,7175.13
Total votes7,032,077100.00
Registered voters/turnout7,720,79691.08
Source: IBZ

The newly constituted Chamber met for the first time on Thursday 28 June 2007, when the Representatives took the oath of office.

Senate

PartyVotes%+/–Seats+/–
CD&VNew Flemish Alliance1,287,38919.42+3.659+3
Open Vlaamse Liberalen en Democraten821,98012.40–2.985–2
Mouvement Réformateur815,75512.31+0.166+1
Vlaams Belang787,78211.89+0.5750
Parti Socialiste678,81210.24–2.604–2
Socialistische Partij AndersSpirit665,34210.04–5.434–3
Centre démocrate humaniste390,8525.90+0.3620
Ecolo385,4665.82+2.632+1
Groen!241,1513.64+1.181+1
Lijst Dedecker223,9923.38New1New
National Front150,4612.27+0.0210
Workers' Party of Belgium54,8070.83+0.0100
Rassemblement Wallonie France32,0940.48+0.0600
Committee for Another Policy21,2150.32New0New
Communist Party of Belgium19,6320.30New0New
National Force14,8660.22New0New
Chrétiens démocrates fédéraux13,3190.20–0.3900
NEE12,1150.18New0New
Stijn11,0970.17New0New
Total6,628,127100.00400
Valid votes6,628,12794.25
Invalid/blank votes404,2575.75
Total votes7,032,384100.00
Registered voters/turnout7,720,79691.08
Source: IBZ

21 Community Senators and 10 Coopted Senators were also be appointed. The definite distribution is not known. On Thursday 28 June 2007, the directly-elected Senators took the oath of office. One week later, on 5 July 2007, the Community Senators took the oath, and two weeks later, on 12 July 2007, the Coopted Senators took the oath. On that day, the Senate was fully constituted.[12][13]

Government formation


Due to differences in view with regards to constitutional reform between the Flemish and Francophone parties, the negotiations to form a new government proceeded with much difficulty.

On 13 June 2007, King Albert II appointed MR leader Didier Reynders informateur,[14][15] (someone who assesses the possibilities for government coalitions). Prior to his appointment, in his position as party leader, Reynders had indicated his preference for a coalition of Christian Democratic parties CD&V (Flanders) and cdH (Wallonia) and liberal parties MR (Wallonia) and Open VLD (Flanders).[16] Reynders presented his final report to the King on 4 July 2007. Following the report, King Albert II appointed former Prime Minister Jean-Luc Dehaene as mediator to prepare the ground for the formateur and to look into the possibility of a state reform.[17]

The King then appointed Yves Leterme of the CD&V as formateur (giving him the task of forming a coalition). Negotiations were temporarily halted on 17 August to give the King the possibility to mediate. Upon the further failure of the negotiations, on 23 August Leterme resigned as formateur.[18] As no acceptable mediator could be found, on 27 August, the King took the unusual step to consult 13 Ministers of State to find way out of the political crisis. At the end of August, the King appointed Herman Van Rompuy (also CD&V and President of the Belgian Chamber of Representatives since July) as explorateur (scout). Following Rompuy's report, Leterme was again appointed formateur on 15 September. After two months of further negotiations, Leterme was still unable to form a coalition and resigned as formateur for a second time on 1 December.[19]

See also


References


  1. "Belgian PM concedes defeat". CNN.com. 2007-06-11. Retrieved 2007-06-15. [dead link]
  2. "Belgian premier to hand in resignation". CNN.com. 2007-06-11. Retrieved 2007-06-15. [dead link]
  3. "King accepts PM's resignation". Vrtnieuws.net. 2007-06-11. Retrieved 2007-06-15.
  4. "Socialists opt for opposition". Vrtnieuws.net. 2007-06-11. Retrieved 2007-06-15.
  5. "Vera Dua: "This is a new start"". Vrtnieuws.net. 2007-06-10. Retrieved 2007-06-15.
  6. Mehmet Koksal, Ergün Top : "En cas de guerre, je me battrai contre la Belgique si nécessaire", Humeur allochtone, 3 June 2007
  7. Mehmet Koksal, Futur soldat turc Ergün Top fera "face à la Belgique" en cas de guerre, Humeur allochtone, 6 June 2007
  8. "Vande Lanotte won't use "genocide"". 2007-06-07. Archived from the original on 2007-09-29. Retrieved 2007-06-07.
  9. "Leterme erkent Armeense genocide". De Standaard (in Dutch). 2007-06-06. Archived from the original on 9 June 2007. Retrieved 2007-06-07.
  10. "Voorstel van resolutie betreffende de genocide in 1915 van de in Turkije levende Armeniërs" (in Dutch). Belgian Senate.
  11. "Proposition de résolution relative au génocide des Arméniens de Turquie en 1915" (in French). Belgian Senate.
  12. "Convocation of the Senate" (in Dutch). Belgian Senate. Retrieved 2007-06-11.
  13. "Convocation of the Senate" (in French). Belgian Senate. Archived from the original on 16 July 2007. Retrieved 2007-06-11.
  14. "King picks Mr Reynders as "informateur"". Vrtnieuws.net. 2007-06-13. Retrieved 2007-06-15.
  15. "King appoints coalition adviser". CNN.com. 2007-06-13. Retrieved 2007-06-15.[dead link]
  16. "Eind juni klaar met informatieopdracht" (in Dutch). VRT Nieuws. 2007-06-13. Retrieved 2007-06-13.
  17. "The Belgian plumber is back". Vrtnieuws.net. 2007-07-05. Retrieved 2007-07-06.
  18. "Leterme stapt op" (in Dutch). Knack.be. 2007-08-23. Archived from the original on 26 August 2007. Retrieved 2007-08-23.
  19. "Belgium coalition talks collapse". BBC. 2007-12-01. Archived from the original on 2 December 2007. Retrieved 2007-12-01.