Team selection

Cork named the same team that defeated Tyrone in the semi-final.^[11] A doubt, however, remained over the fitness of Ray Carey who injured his shoulder during a training session.^[11] Eight members of the 2007 final team featured.^[11] Cork also announced they had renewed their sponsorship deal with O₂ days before the final.^[25][26] Going into the final, Cork had scored a goal in all of their fourteen Championship matches since 2007's qualifier game against Louth, also scoring eight goals in five matches against Kerry over a two-season period.^[27][28] Anthony Lynch and Nicholas Murphy were the remaining players from the 1999 final loss to Meath.^[29] Ray Carey was declared unfit on matchday and was replaced with Kieran O'Connor.^[2]

Kerry's Colm Cooper was originally described as "very doubtful" for the final.^[30] However, he, alongside Paul Galvin, were later declared fit,^[12][31][32] with Kerry officials dismissing claims about Cooper's fitness as one of several "false stories" to have come out of the county in 2009.^[33] Kieran Donaghy, who had recovered from a foot injury, was expected to appear amongst the substitutes.^[12][30] Donaghy criticised the media for what he termed the "pandemonium" that was created surrounding Cooper throughout the campaign following a drinking session with Tomás Ó Sé which saw them both removed from the team for a time.^[34] Tadhg Kennelly also had to deny he would rejoin the Sydney Swans in the AFL.^[35] Kerry made one change from the semi-final line-up; Donnacha Walsh was replaced by Tommy Walsh.^[13] Prior to the match, speculation surrounded Kennelly and Walsh over whether they would return to play in Australia if they won their first All-Ireland medals.^[36] Kennelly later signed a two-year contract with Sydney Swans,^[37] as did Walsh; who signed a two-year deal with St Kilda Football Club around 2 months after the All Ireland Final^{[citation needed]}

Referee controversy

Marty Duffy of Sligo was appointed match referee for the final.^[38][39] The decision led to comment from former managers of both counties involved in the final, Mick O'Dwyer who expressed his belief that the choice of referee was based on "politics" and Billy Morgan who thought that Pat McEnaney ought to have been appointed referee instead.^[38][39][40] The GAA officially refused to offer a response to the two men.^[41] Liam and Sam in the Irish Independent compared the "pre-emptive" criticism of the referee to a scenario where the referee were to question the manner in which one of the teams play the sport or express dismay that a better team should have qualified for the final instead.^[42] Radio Kerry analyst and former referee Weeshie Fogarty expressed his dismay at the criticism of Duffy, commenting: "It's bad enough to referee big games in Croke Park and see your name being castigated in the papers and torn asunder the following week. But by God, when it happens before the game, that is a new trend to me".^[43]

Summary

Trophy presentation

Following a pitch invasion by fans after the 2009 All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship Final, the GAA confirmed that the presentation of the Sam Maguire Cup would take place in Croke Park's Hogan Stand.^{[45][46][47][48]} The GAA insisted that it still remained worried about the health and safety of fans and expects an accident to happen "one of these days".^[49] Kerry captain Darren O'Sullivan expressed his indifference about the location: "If they give [the cup] out in the car park around the back, I just want to get my hands on it".^[50] During the presentation, Tadhg Kennelly did his dance which he previously did when he won the AFL Grand Final with the Sydney Swans in 2005.^{[3][4][5][6][51]}

Reaction

Jack O'Connor claimed his team were influenced by the criticism which had come their way—"We were being written off – fellas like Spillane now were almost feeling pity for us. But that is where you get the energy from; you get it from enjoying each other's company and trying to build it up".^[52]

Conor Counihan claimed his team lost because of missed opportunities to score—"'We were definitely at a stage out there where we had opportunities and had we taken them, well it might have been an entirely different story. There's no doubt we could have put more pressure on Kerry at a couple of crucial periods. We didn't take our chances, however, and that's what it all boils down to".^[53]

Tadhg Kennelly confirmed that he was committed to the Kerry team and would not be returning to Sydney Swans for the following season—"My head is truly, truly set on Kerry. And my heart. That’s probably the main thing that has come out here".^[54][55]

Seán Moran in The Irish Times commended Kerry for how they "rattled off" another title, noting the achievement was "all the more admirable for the quality of opposition with which they have had to contend" and that Jack O'Connor, on his decision to return as manager, was "rewarded with the ultimate vindication".^[56]

Homecoming

One of the largest crowds to ever attend an All-Ireland homecoming collected in Rathmore, County Kerry on 21 September 2009 to wait for the team train to arrive.^[57] With "The Best" playing in the background, Aidan O'Mahony and Tom O'Sullivan carried the Sam Maguire Cup to a stage which was erected in the town's train station and Tadhg Kennelly danced yet another jig of celebration as children queued to receive autographs.^[57] Touring the county, a fireworks display was on offer in honour of the team in Killarney and the streets of Tralee were tightly packed with wellwishers.^[57]

Cork departed Dublin at 16:00 on 21 September 2009 en route to Cork's Kent Station via Mallow.^[57] Hundreds of people gathered at South Mall near Parnell Place to welcome the team, amongst them the Irish Minister for Foreign Affairs Micheál Martin and John Buckley, Bishop of Cork and Ross.^[57]

Awards

The nominations for the 2009 GAA All Stars Awards were announced on 25 September 2009. All but three of Kerry's winning team were nominated, with ten of Cork's team also being nominated.^[58] Kerry's Tomas Ó Sé, Declan O'Sullivan and Colm Cooper were also nominated in 2008.^[58] The nominees for Footballer of the Year were Paul Galvin and Tomás Ó Sé of Kerry and Graham Canty of Cork.^[58] Cork's Colm O'Neill was nominated for Young Footballer of the Year alongside Mayo's Aidan O'Shea and eventual winner Donegal's Michael Murphy.^[58]