| Year |
Champion |
Score |
Runner-up |
Site |
Most valuable player |
|---|
| 1990 |
Fordham |
1–0* |
Lafayette |
Christy Mathewson–Memorial Stadium • Lewisburg, PA |
 Chris Donovan, Fordham |
| 1991 |
Army |
4–0 |
Lehigh |
Dewey Field • Annapolis, MD |
Phillip Shearer, Army |
| 1992 |
Colgate |
1–0* |
Army |
Clinton Field • Annapolis, MD |
Brian Wycall, Colgate |
| 1993 |
Army (2) |
4–2* |
Bucknell |
Metzgar Field • Easton, PA |
Tony Dedmond, Army |
| 1994 |
Lafayette |
1–0 |
Army |
Metzgar Field • Easton, PA |
 Geddes Alexander, Lafayette |
| 1995 |
Lafayette (2) |
3–2* |
Navy |
Fitton Field • Worcester, MA |
Eric Rosenbloom, Lafayette |
| 1996 |
Army (3) |
4–1 |
Navy |
Colgate Varsity Field • Hamilton, NY |
A.J. Florkowski, Army |
| 1997 |
Colgate (2) |
1–0 |
Lehigh |
Colgate Varsity Field • Hamilton, NY |
Jeff Lipman, Colgate |
| 1998 |
Lafayette (3) |
2–0 |
Lehigh |
Metzgar Field • Easton, PA |
Leidy Klotz, Lafayette |
| 1999 |
Lafayette (4) |
1–0* |
Navy |
Fitton Field • Worcester, MA |
Craig Schroeder, Lafayette |
| 2000 |
Lehigh |
1–1†
(5–3 pk) |
Lafayette |
Metzgar Field • Easton, PA |
Dan Perciballi, Lehigh |
| 2001 |
American |
1–1†
(4–3 pk) |
Holy Cross |
Hart Field • Worcester, MA |
Bobby Brennan, American |
| 2002 |
Holy Cross |
0–0†
(10–9 pk) |
Lehigh |
Nickerson Field • Boston, MA |
 Rusty Giudici, Holy Cross |
| 2003 |
Lafayette (5) |
2–0 |
Lehigh |
Bucknell East Field • Lewisburg, PA |
Ralph Rapuano, Lafayette |
| 2004 |
American (2) |
1–0* |
Lehigh |
Reeves Field • Washington, DC |
Garth Juckem, American |
| 2005 |
Lafayette (6) |
1–0 |
American |
Reeves Field • Washington, DC |
Michael Tortora, Lafayette |
| 2006 |
Bucknell |
0–0†
(4–3 pk) |
Lafayette |
Ulrich Sports Complex • Bethlehem, PA |
Joey Kuterbach, Bucknell |
| 2007 |
Colgate (3) |
1–0 |
Lafayette |
Linda Johnson Smith Soccer Stadium • Worcester, MA |
Dan Belke, Colgate |
| 2008 |
Colgate (4) |
2–1 |
Holy Cross |
Colgate Varsity Field • Hamilton, NY |
Alex Weeks, Colgate |
| 2009 |
Bucknell (2) |
1–0 |
American |
Emmitt Field • Lewisburg, PA |
Patrick Selwood, Bucknell |
| 2010 |
Bucknell (3) |
2–0 |
American |
Van Doren Field • Hamilton, NY |
Ross Liberati, Bucknell |
| 2011 |
Colgate (5) |
2–0 |
American |
Reeves Field • Washington, DC |
Steven Miller, Colgate |
| 2012 |
Lafayette (7) |
2–0 |
American |
Reeves Field • Washington, DC |
Nathan McDonald, Lafayette |
| 2013 |
Navy |
2–0 |
Holy Cross |
Glenn Warner Soccer Facility • Annapolis, MD |
Guy Skord, Navy |
| 2014 |
Bucknell (4) |
3–2* |
Boston University |
Nickerson Field • Boston, MA |
/ Sebastiaan Blickman, Bucknell |
| 2015 |
Lehigh (2) |
2–1 |
American |
Beyer-Small '76 Field • Hamilton, NY |
Jamie Luchini, Lehigh |
| 2016 |
Colgate (6) |
0–0†
(5–4 pk) |
American |
Reeves Field • Washington, DC |
Ethan Kutler, Colgate |
| 2017 |
Colgate (7) |
1–0 |
Holy Cross |
Ridley Athletic Complex • Baltimore, MD |
Jared Stroud, Colgate |
| 2018 |
Colgate (8) |
1–0 |
Army |
Ridley Athletic Complex • Baltimore, MD |
Oliver Harris, Colgate |
| 2019 |
Lehigh (3) |
1–0 |
Lafayette |
Ulrich Sports Complex • Bethlehem, PA |
Will Smith, Lehigh |
| 2020–21 |
American (3) |
2–1 |
Lafayette |
Oaks Stadium • Easton, PA |
 David Coly, American |
| 2021 |
Loyola |
2–1 |
American |
Ridley Athletic Complex • Baltimore, MD |
Chase Vosvick, Loyola |
| 2022 |
Navy |
1–0 |
American |
Glenn Warner Soccer Facility • Annapolis, MD |
Zach Wagner, Navy |
| 2023 |
Boston University |
1–0 |
Lafayette |
Nickerson Field • Boston, MA |
 Eitan Rosen, Boston University |
