Pro-Palestinian demonstrations

The neutrality of this section is disputed. (June 2017)

The Operation Protective Edge created a lot of emotions in France, in particular within the French population of Arab descent. This social composition of the pro-Palestinian is both put forward by radical-left and post-colonial groups^[4] and by right-wing medias,^[5] and most of the events occurred in low-income and high-immigration neighbourhoods. However, after having given an unusually direct support to Israel,^[6] the French government took a hard stance and forbid almost every pro-Palestinian demonstration. The interdictions begun around 14 July, mostly presented as technical and due to the overlap with the festivities of the national holiday,^[7] but not everywhere.^[8] Then the justifications put forward for later interdictions quickly became^[9] the clashes between pro-Palestinian and pro-Israel activists, which begun as soon as 13 July.^[10][11] This led to many illegal demonstrations during this month, in a context of tensions. In particular those of Barbès^[12][13] and Sarcelles.^[14] Those demonstrations have often been described as antisemitic, and many comments pointed out the presence of Islamic or ethnic ("communautaristes") orientations^[15][16] inside those demonstrations, although they have mostly been organised by the radical left and the far-left (in particular the NPA^[17]). Some incorrect news was broadcast and corrected afterwards,^[18] while we have oral reports of antisemitic sentences which are hard to check (such as the rumour of a "Mort aux Juifs !", "Death to the Jews!") but a few pictures from the Dieudonné sphere can be found.^[19] In parallel, the pro-Israel counter-demonstration in Sarcelles was forbidden as well, since groups such as Jewish Defense League have already participated in several violent confrontations with pro-Palestinian demonstrators in the previous days.^[20]

Claims of rising of antisemitism

France has the third largest community of Jews after Israel and the U.S. and antisemitism in France has increased significantly in recent years with one monitoring group claiming that it has increased 700% since the 1990s.^[21] Since the beginning of the 21st century, antisemitism in France has found new sources of recruitment from certain leftist groups and in the identification of a significant proportion of the Muslim immigrant population with the Palestinian cause on the one hand and with radical Islamism on the other.^[22][23][24] By early 2014 the number of French Jews immigrating to Israel had overtaken the number of American Jews and at the same time 70% of French Jews were concerned about insults or harassment and 60% about physical aggression because of their Jewishness, both figures being much higher than the European average.^[25]

A kosher grocery store was set ablaze, for which the perpetrator was convicted of arson.^[26]

Government response

Prime Minister of France Manuel Valls condemned the attack as antisemitic. He said of the attack, "What's happened in Sarcelles is intolerable: attacking a synagogue or a kosher grocery, is quite simply anti-Semitism, racism."^[27]

Minister of the Interior Bernard Cazeneuve said that the violence prompted the ban, not that the ban prompted the violence.^[27]

Three men, aged 21 and 28, were jailed for between six and ten months for their part in the riot. A fourth man received a suspended sentence, and a minor received a fine. Three other men received suspended sentences for their part in a riot in Paris on the same day. None of the convictions in Sarcelles were for 'anti-Semitism'. Instead they were for minor public order offences. The term 'riot' was never used by police or prosecutors.^[28]