During the first years it participated in friendly games, until joining KOP. Today the club participates in the amateur championships of Nicosia and the agricultural championships of Cyprus.
Participations in the 1st Division
AYMA joined KOP in 1945. In 1947, it participated in the 1st Division, receiving position 4, while in the Cup it reached the semifinals, where it was excluded by AEL. In the next season (1948–49), AYMA took position 6 while for a second consecutive time reached the semifinals for the cup, losing again to AEL. These were her best participations in the 1st division of Cypriot football, in the next participations it finished in the last positions of marking.
The 1949–1950 championship was one of the worst for AYMA, as it finished eighth and last; in the cup it again reached the semifinals, losing to Pezoporikos. The fall continued also during the 1950–1951 period, taking the seventh pre-last position and excluded from the cup in the first round. In 1951–1952 again in the seventh place and exclusion in the first round of the cup, eighth place in 1952–1953 and ninth in 1953–1954. In 1954–1955, it finished eighth, ninth in 1955–1956, and her last presence in the first Division in 1960–1961, terminating 13th and final.
Overall, it had 11 participations and in 176 matches it had 23 victories, 126 defeats and 27 ties. In fact, in the 1953 and 1962 championships it had no victory.