Men
- 2007 Alando Tucker, Wisconsin
- 2006 Terence Dials, Ohio State
- 2005 Dee Brown, Illinois
- 2004 Devin Harris, Wisconsin
- 2003 Brian Cook, Illinois
- 2002 Jared Jeffries, Indiana
- 2001 Frank Williams, Illinois
- 2000 Morris Peterson, Michigan State
- 1999 Mateen Cleaves, Michigan State
- 1998 Mateen Cleaves, Michigan State
- 1997 Bobby Jackson, Minnesota (vacated)
- 1996 Brian Evans, Indiana
- 1995 Shawn Respert, Michigan State
- 1994 Glenn Robinson, Purdue
- 1993 Calbert Cheaney, Indiana
- 1992 Jim Jackson, Ohio State
- 1991 Jim Jackson, Ohio State
- 1990 Steve Smith, Michigan State
- 1989 Glen Rice, Michigan
- 1988 Gary Grant, Michigan
- 1987 Steve Alford, Indiana
- 1986 Scott Skiles, Michigan State
- 1985 Roy Tarpley, Michigan
- 1984 Jim Rowinski, Purdue
- 1983 Randy Wittman, Indiana
- 1982 Clark Kellogg, Ohio State
- 1981 Ray Tolbert, Indiana
- 1980 Mike Woodson, Indiana
- 1979 Magic Johnson, Michigan State
- 1978 Mychal Thompson, Minnesota
- 1977 Kent Benson, Indiana
- 1976 Scott May, Indiana
- 1975 Scott May, Indiana
- 1974 Campy Russell, Michigan
- 1973 Steve Downing, Indiana
- 1972 Jim Brewer, Minnesota
- 1971 Jim Cleamons, Ohio State
- 1970 Rick Mount, Purdue
- 1969 Rick Mount, Purdue
- 1968 Samuel Williams, Iowa
- 1967 Jim Dawson, Illinois
- 1966 Cazzie Russell, Michigan
- 1965 Cazzie Russell, Michigan
- 1964 Gary Bradds, Ohio State
- 1963 Gary Bradds, Ohio State
- 1962 Jerry Lucas, Ohio State
- 1961 Jerry Lucas, Ohio State
- 1960 Jerry Lucas, Ohio State
- 1959 Johnny Green, Michigan State
- 1958 Archie Dees, Indiana
- 1957 Archie Dees, Indiana
- 1956 Robin Freeman, Ohio State
- 1955 Chuck Mencel, Minnesota
- 1954 Johnny Kerr, Illinois
- 1953 Don Schlundt, Indiana
- 1952 Chuck Darling, Iowa
- 1951 Don Sunderlage, Illinois
- 1950 Don Rehfeldt, Wisconsin
- 1949 Dwight Eddleman, Illinois
- 1948 Murray Wier, Iowa
- 1947 Glen Selbo, Wisconsin
- 1946 Max Morris, Northwestern
|
Women
- 2007 Jessica Davenport, Ohio State
- 2006 Jessica Davenport, Ohio State
- 2005 Jessica Davenport, Ohio State
- 2004 Kelly Mazzante, Penn State
- 2003 Kelly Mazzante, Penn State
- 2002 Lindsay Whalen, Minnesota
- 2001 Katie Douglas, Purdue
- 2000 Helen Darling, Penn State
- 1999 Stephanie White-McCarty, Purdue
- 1998 Tangela Smith, Iowa
- 1997 Jannon Roland, Purdue
- 1996 Katie Smith, Ohio State
- 1995 Stacey Lovelace, Purdue
- 1994 Carol Ann Shudlick, Minnesota
- 1993 Audrey Burcy, Ohio State
- 1992 MaChelle Joseph, Purdue
- 1991 Joy Holmes, Purdue
- 1990 Franthea Price, Iowa
- 1989 Nikita Lowry, Ohio State
- 1988 Michelle Edwards, Iowa
|