Commonweal Trial

From 1892 Nicoll used his platform to take a leading role in supporting the defence of the Walsall anarchists – a group charged with manufacturing explosives. Nicoll published the pamphlet The Walsall Anarchists in which he argued that they had been framed by the French anarchist Auguste Coulon who Nicoll accused of being a paid agent-provocateur working for Inspector William Melville at Special Branch.^[13][14]

In an article in Commonweal in April 1892 Nicoll criticised Justice Henry Hawkins, who had presided over the Walsall anarchist trial, and asked whether Hawkins, the Home Secretary Henry Matthews or Melville were "fit to live". Nicoll and Commonweal's publisher Charles Mowbray were arrested for incitement to murder Matthews, Hawkins and Melville. Nicoll denied he intended to incite murder, stating that the article had been written in "hot blood".^[15][16] The prosecutor in the trial was the Attorney General Sir Richard Webster, while Nicoll chose to defend himself, later publishing his closing speech as a pamphlet.^[17] On 6 May 1892 Nicoll was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment with hard labour.^[18][19] Mowbray was found not guilty on the same charges on the basis that he was not involved in producing the paper at that time.^[15]

Research published in 2004 confirmed Nicoll's accusations that the Walsall anarchists were framed. Coulon had indeed been an agent-provocateur working under the direct orders of Melville.^[20]

Nicoll served his sentence at Chelmsford prison, some of which was spent under medical supervision.^[21][22][23] He later spoke publicly about his experiences in prison and wrote the pamphlet Life in English Prisons.^[24] Upon his release he was met in London by a large welcoming party which resulted in clashes with the police.^[22]

In Nicoll's absence the anarchist tailor H. B. Samuels took over as editor of Commonweal.^[19] However, after Nicoll's release the Commonweal group did not return the editorship of the paper to Nicoll.^[21] Under Samuels's and Frank Kitz's editorship the paper fell into decline and ceased publication.^[19] The experience of prison and his removal from the paper caused Nicoll significant anguish and his mental health declined significantly as he became beset by paranoia.^[21][25]

The trial also demonstrated the level of visible and undercover police surveillance Nicoll and others at the paper were under, with police watching the office, following individuals, studying the paper, and attending talks and meetings – with some of the notes taken being used as evidence in court.^[26]

Later life

Nicoll became more socially isolated. From 1894 until 1897 he edited the Anarchist newspaper while living in Sheffield.^[25] He also began intermittently self-publishing a paper under the name Commonweal from 1896 to 1901.

In 1897 Nicoll authored and self-published the pamphlet The Greenwich Mystery: Letters from the Dead about the death of Martial Bourdin, in which he accused Samuels of being a police spy. The pamphlet is believed to have heavily influenced Joseph Conrad's novel The Secret Agent and Olivia Rossetti Agresti fictionalised memoir A Girl Among the Anarchists (written under the pen name Isabel Meredith).^[27][28]

Nicoll spent the rest of life in poverty, suffering poor mental health, working as a street vendor and selling pamphlets.^[29] He died on 2 March 1919 in St Pancras Hospital, London, and was buried in an unmarked grave in St Pancras and Islington Cemetery.^[25][30]