Graphic notation (music)
Graphic notation (or graphic score) is the representation of music through the use of visual symbols outside the realm of traditional music notation. Graphic notation became popular in the 1950s, and can be used either in combination with or instead of traditional music notation. Graphic notation was influenced by contemporary visual art trends in its conception, bringing stylistic components from modern art into music. Composers often rely on graphic notation in experimental music, where standard musical notation can be ineffective. Other uses include pieces where an aleatoric or undetermined effect is desired. One of the earliest pioneers of this technique was Earle Brown, who, along with John Cage, sought to liberate performers from the constraints of notation and make them active participants in the creation of the music.
Graphic notation is characterized by its variability and lack of standardization. According to Baker’s Student Encyclopedia of Music, Vol. 1, “Graphic notation is used to indicate extremely precise (or intentionally imprecise) pitch or to stimulate musical behavior or actions in performance.” Modern graphic notation relies heavily on the imagination and inspiration of each individual performer to interpret the visual content provided by the composer. Because of this relative freedom, the realization of graphically notated pieces usually varies from performance to performance. For example, in notation indication “E" of his piece Concert for Piano and Orchestra, John Cage writes: “Play with hands indicated. Where clefs differ, a note is either bass or treble,” an indeteminacy which is not unusual in Cage's work, and which leaves decision-making up to the performer. Some graphic scores can be defined as action-based, where musical gestures are notated as shapes instead of conventional musical ideas.
The use of graphic notation within a score can vary widely, from the score being made up entirely of graphic notation to graphic notation being a small part of an otherwise largely-traditional score. Some composers include written explanations to aid the performer in interpreting the graphic notation, while other composers opt to leave the interpretation entirely up to the performer. Graphic notation is difficult to characterize with specificity, as the notation system is only limited by the imagination and ability of the composer. Though some composers, like John Cage, formulate graphic notation systems which unify the approach of specific pieces, or several pieces, there is no universal consensus on the parameters of graphic notation and its use.
Though its most popular usage occurred in the mid-twentieth century, the first evidence of graphic notation dates back much earlier. Originally called “eye music,” these graphic scores bear much resemblance to the scores of composers like George Crumb. One of the earliest surviving pieces of eye music is Belle, Bonne, Sage by Baude Cordier, a Renaissance composer. His score, formed in the shape of a heart, was intended to enhance the meaning of the chanson. Characteristic of the Ars subtilior, "experimentations with mensural signs and graphic shapes and colours were often a feature of musical design - for the sake of visual, rather than necessarily audible effect." Another example of eye music from the ars subtilior is Jacob Senleches' La harpe de melodie, where the voices are notated on a stave that appears to be the strings of a harp. Eye music’s popularity died down after the Humanist movement of the mid-16th century, later to be revitalized in the twentieth-century as the use of graphic scores became prominent once again.
The 19th century music educator Pierre Galin developed a method of notating music known as the Galin-Paris-Chevé system, building off of a method created in the 18th century by Jean-Jacques Rousseau. This system used numbers to indicate scale degrees, and used dots either above or below the note to indicate if they were in the lowest octave or the highest. The middle octave, relative to the example, contained no dots. Flats and sharps were notated using backslashes and forward slashes respectively. Prolongations of the note were notated using periods, and silence was notated with the number zero. This method was primarily used to teach sight-singing. The usage of symbols to indicate musical direction have been likened to an early version of graphic notation.
Uses in the twentieth century
Experimental music appeared in the United States and Europe during the 1950s, when many of the once untouchable parameters of traditional music began to be challenged. Aleatoric music, indeterminate music, musique concrète and electronic music shook previously unquestioned concepts, such as musical time or the function of the musician, and dared to add others to musical space in all its dimensions, with all their ontological consequences and burdens. They also changed the roles of the composer, the performer and the public, giving them totally new functions to explore.
In this context, the score, which had to a great extent been considered a mere support for musical writing (with the exception of eye music), began to flirt with the limits of the work and its identity. This marriage produced three paths: the first considered the musical score to be a representation of organized sound; the second conceived it as an extension of sound; and the third viewed it as another type of music, a visual music with its own autonomy, independent of sound. The score took on new meanings and went from being a mere support of sound to being an extension of the work, or even another work altogether, an element that was as important as the sounds and silences it contained, or more. These conceptions required a new language and a new reading of what it is to be musical. They also required a new notation, one that would reflect the changes taking place in the second artistic vanguards, and contain them, granting them a new semantics. In this way, taken with the porousness of experimental music with respect to the plastic arts, notation came to be more and more influenced by a dialogue with painting, installations and performativity. As J.Y. Bosseur mentions in La musique du XXè siècle à la croisé des artes, the score progressed towards representing the management of space, a graphic space that allows us to know the multiple connections enclosed within it.
Graphic notation in its modern form first appeared in the 1950s as an evolution of movement of Indeterminacy as pioneered by John Cage. The technique was originally used by avant-garde musicians and manifested itself as the use of symbols to convey information that could not be rendered with traditional notation such as extended techniques. Graphic scores have, since their conception, evolved into two broadly defined categories, one being the invention of new notation systems used to convey specific musical techniques and the other the use of conceptual notation such as shapes, drawings and other artistic techniques that are meant to evoke improvisation from the performer. Examples of the former include Morton Feldman's Projection 1, which was the result of Feldman drawing abstract shapes on graph paper, and Stockhausen's Prozession. Examples of the latter include Earle Brown's December 1952 and Cardew's Treatise, which was written in response to Cage's 4'33" and which he wrote after having worked as Stockhausen's assistant. The score consists of 193 pages of lines and shapes on a white background. Here the lines represented elements in space and the score was merely a representation of that space at a given instant. In Europe, one of the most notable users was Sylvano Bussotti, whose scores have often been displayed as pieces of visual art by enthusiasts. In 1969, in an effort to promote the movement of abstract notation, John Cage and Allison Knowles published an archive of excerpts of scores by 269 composers with the intention of showing "the many directions in which notation is now going".
Other notable pioneers of graphic notation include composers such as Roman Haubenstock-Ramati, Mauricio Kagel, György Ligeti (Artikulation), Krzysztof Penderecki, Karlheinz Stockhausen, and Iannis Xenakis, Morton Feldman, Constance Cochnower Virtue, and Christian Wolff.
In addition to the more widespread popularity of graphic notation, new technology has expanded its possibilities. In his book "The Digital Score: Musicianship, Creativity, and Innovation," Craig Vear describes how Artificial Intelligence and animation can be used to enhance the graphic score experience. He claims that these technologies are "the logical development of graphic score experiments from the latter part of the twentieth century. An interesting element of these is that they have to move in order for them to be read; without movement, they are unintelligible."
As a notational system
- Time-based pictographic scores such as Waterwalk by John Cage, uses a combination of time marking a pictographic notation as instruction on how and when to perform certain actions.
- Pictographic scores such as Stripsody by Cathy Berberian use only drawings and text, foregoing any sort of time reference. This allows the performer to interpret the piece as they like.
- Line staves showing approximate pitch, with the actual pitches being decided upon performance.
- Altered notation can be seen in George Crumb's work, where he uses traditional notation but presents the music on the page in a graphic or nontraditional manner such as spirals or circles. One example of altered notation is Crumb's Makrokosmos" for Amplified Piano. Crumb's score contained three detailed pages of instructions, with movements including Primeval Sounds, Crucifixus and Spiral Galaxy.
- New specific notation system, that is, a new of specifically and graphically notate musical actions like that of Xenakis' Psappha.
As abstract visual reference
- Time-based abstract representation, can be seen in Hans-Christoph Steiner's score for Solitude in which the music is represented using symbols and illustrations. Note that here, time is still represented horizontally from left to right like in a pitch graph system, and thus implies that the piece has a specific form.
- Time-based abstract notation, such as Rudolf Komorous's Chanson utilizes abstract notation with time indication, or least a direction in which the piece is read and therefore implies a form.
- Free abstract representations, such as Brown's December 1952, where the form, pitch material and instrumentation are left up to the performer.
- Another example is John Cage's Aria, it might look like random squiggles, but each line indicates a different style of singing, notated in wavy lines in ten different colors, and the black squares indicate non specified 'non-musical' sounds.
- Free abstract notation, such as Mark Applebaum's "The Metaphysics of Notation" and where elements of traditional music notation are melded with abstract designs.
- Another example is Tom Phillips' Golden Flower Piece, this piece uses uppercase letters to show notes that should be played in the bass, and lowercase letters played in a higher register. You're allowed to add flats and sharps as you please. And the dots around the notes are supposed to help with how loud to play the note, and how long to hold it for.
Other notable practitioners of graphic notation include:
- Aphex Twin
- Mark Applebaum
- Cathy Berberian
- Luciano Berio
- John Bergamo
- Anthony Braxton
- André Boucourechliev
- Leo Brouwer
- Herbert Brün
- Randolph Coleman
- Toby Driver
- Iancu Dumitrescu
- Brian Eno
- Eric Ewazen
- Morton Feldman
- Jerry Goldsmith
- Michail Goleminov
- Jonny Greenwood
- Barry Guy
- Alfred Harth
- Panayiotis Kokoras
- Andrzej Krzanowski
- Bruno Liberda
- Helmut Lachenmann
- Yuri Landman
- Anestis Logothetis
- Robert Moran
- Luigi Morleo
- Conlon Nancarrow
- Pauline Oliveros
- Roberto Paci Dalò
- Krzysztof Penderecki
- Sylvano Bussotti
- Emanuel Dimas de Melo Pimenta
- Randy Raine-Reusch
- Esposito Luigi
- Bernard Rands
- Roger Reynolds
- Matana Roberts
- Marina Rosenfeld
- Sven-David Sandström
- Leon Schidlowsky
- R. Murray Schafer
- Netty Simons
- Stuart Saunders Smith
- Wadada Leo Smith
- Juan Maria Solare
- Allen Strange
- Michael Vetter
- Jennifer Walshe
- John Zorn
- Pryer, Anthony. "Graphic Notation." The Oxford Companion to Music, edited by Alison Latham. Oxford Music Online. 12 April 2011
- Kojs, Juraj (2011). "Notating Action-Based Music". Leonardo Music Journal. 21: 65–72. doi:10.1162/LMJ_a_00063. ISSN 0961-1215. JSTOR 41416825. S2CID 57570690.
- Taruskin, Richard. "Chapter 2 "Indeterminacy."". Oxford History of Western Music. New York, USA: Oxford University Press. Retrieved April 7, 2018.
- Kuhn, Laura (1999). "Baker's Student Encyclopedia Vol. 1". Alexander Street.
- Stone, Kurt (1980). Music Notation in the Twentieth Century: A Practical Guidebook. W. W. Norton and Company. pp. 103–107.
- Gutkin, David (2012). "Drastic or Plastic?: Threads from Karlheinz Stockhausen's "Musik und Graphik," 1959". Perspectives of New Music. 50 (1–2): 255–305. doi:10.7757/persnewmusi.50.1-2.0255. ISSN 0031-6016. JSTOR 10.7757/persnewmusi.50.1-2.0255.
- Evarts, John. "The New Musical Notation—A Graphic Art?". Muse.
- Taruskin, Richard. "Chapter 2: "Indeterminacy"". Oxford History of Western Music. New York, USA: Oxford University Press. Retrieved April 7, 2018.
- Thurston, Dart (1980). New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians. London: Macmillan.
- Dillon, Emma (2016). "Seen and Not Heard". Il Saggiatore musicale. 23 (1): 5–27. ISSN 1123-8615. JSTOR 90001054.
- Bullen, George W. (1877). "The Galin-Paris-Cheve Method of Teaching Considered as a Basis of Musical Education". Proceedings of the Musical Association. 4: 68–93. doi:10.1093/jrma/4.1.68. ISSN 0958-8442. JSTOR 765284.
- PUJADAS, MAGDA POLO (2018). "Philosophy of Music: Wittgenstein and Cardew". Revista Portuguesa de Filosofia. 74 (4): 1425–1436. doi:10.17990/RPF/2018_74_4_1425. ISSN 0870-5283. JSTOR 26563363.
- Bosseur, Jean-Yves (2002), "Chapitre IX. Entre son et couleur", Peinture et musique, Presses universitaires du Septentrion, pp. 159–177, doi:10.4000/books.septentrion.69603, ISBN 978-2-85939-769-2
- Pryer, Anthony. "Graphic Notation." The Oxford Companion to Music, edited by Alison Latham. Oxford Music Online. 12 Apr. 2011
- Cage, John (1969). Notations. New York, NY: Something Else Press. ISBN 978-0685148648.
- Sauer, Theresa. Notations 21. Mark Batty Publisher. p. 010, 2008.
- Vear, Craig (2019). The Digital Score: Musicianship, Creativity and Innovation (1 ed.). 52 Vanderbilt Avenue, New York, NY 10017: Routledge. doi:10.4324/9780429504495. ISBN 9780429504495.CS1 maint: location (link)
- "Speaking Scores: What's It Like To Be Stripsody?". taikooplace.com. Retrieved 2020-10-02.
- "Graphic music scores - in pictures". The Guardian. 2013-10-04. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2020-10-03.
- Xenakis, I. (1975). Psappha, (p. 1)
- Taruskin, Richard. "Chapter 2 "Indeterminacy."". Oxford History of Western Music. New York, USA: Oxford University Press. Retrieved April 8, 2018.
- "John Cage - Aria - Art and Music". classicfm.com. Retrieved 2020-10-03.
- Heigemeir, Ray. "The Metaphysics of Notation". Stanford Libraries. Retrieved 9 April 2018.
- "Phillips - Golden Flower Piece". Classic FM. Retrieved 2020-10-04.
- R. Murray Schafer at National Arts Centre ArtsAlive web site. Retrieved 2011-11-17.
- Cage, John, and Alison Knowles (1969). Notations. New York: Something Else Press.
- Lieberman, David 2006. Game Enhanced Music Manuscript. In GRAPHITE '06: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Computer Graphics and Interactive Techniques in Australasia and South East Asia, ACM Press, Melbourne, Australia, 245 - 250.
- Sauer, Theresa (2009). Notations 21. New York: Mark Batty Publisher. ISBN 978-0-9795546-4-3
- David Schidlowsky (ed.) (2011) Musikalische Grafik—Graphic Music: León Schidlowsky. Berlin: Wissenschaftlicher Verlag. ISBN 978-3-86573-620-8.
- Pujadas, Megda Polo (2018). Philosophy of Music: Wittgenstein and Cardew. Revista Portuguesa de Filosofia. 74 (4) :1425-1436. ISSN 0870-5283