Canada is a popular destination for international students across all levels of its education system, with the country ranking fourth in terms of international student enrollment as of 2019, following the United States, United Kingdom, and China.^[1] In as early as 1959, Canada's then-monarch, Queen Elizabeth II, said on Dominion Day (now Canada Day), in reference to cooperation and mutual help, "one instance of this is the number of students from India, and Pakistan, and the West Indies who found places in Canadian universities. This is an admirable plan and I hope that it spreads [...] If any of these students are listening to me, which perhaps they are, I congratulate them on the hard work and enterprise which has sent them here and send them my very good wishes."^[2] The provision of international student education is considered to have non-monetary benefits, such as reducing xenophobia and cultural stereotyping by encouraging diversity, nurturing international goodwill and global civility, fostering intercultural and social connections among faculty and students, and promoting greater engagement in teaching and collaborative research initiatives.^[3]

This article needs to be updated. (April 2024)

According to the International Education Strategy published by the Government of Canada, international students are present in all levels of education, including primary, secondary, trades, and college and post-secondary education, with the largest number of international students enrolled at the post-secondary level.^[4] The number of enrolled students has been increasing steadily in all levels from 2015 to 2018, with the greatest rise in college attendance.^[4][5] The International Education Strategy for the period 2019-2024 includes a commitment to diversify inbound student population and distribute them more evenly across the country rather than concentration them in a few cities.^[5] To attract more international students, Canadian educational institutes are offering English as a second language programs and reserving specific scholarships for interested international students.^[6] In 2016, the International Education Division of Global Affairs Canada launched the EduCanada brand, a collaborative promotional initiative involving the provinces and territories and the Council of Ministers of Education, Canada.^[7]

A survey conducted by the Canadian Bureau for International Education (CBIE) found that 96% of international students endorsed Canada as a study destination, due to its quality education and its reputation as a safe, tolerant and multicultural country that celebrates diversity.^[8] In 2014, Canada aimed to raise the number of international students from around 240,000 to over 450,000 by the year 2022.^[9] The Canadian government agency responsible for immigration shared that as of December, there were over 807,000 individuals holding international study permits in the country, accounting for over 2% the population of the country.^[10] However, CIBC Capital Markets reported that the official count of temporary residents in Canada might be significantly higher than reality. The report finds that the actual number could be off by up to one million.^[11][12]

Some private institutions are revoking their admission offers to international students because they don't have the capacity to accommodate large volumes of international students. They sent out more acceptance letters, thinking that the Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) would manage the numbers.^[13] In 2022, information obtained through the Access to Information Act showed a significant increase in the influence of Indian students. They were pushing Canada to support their individual, economic, and political goals. Indian international student activism with similar aims were highly active on social media.^[14]

Students are able to work off-campus 20 hours a week during the regular school year and engage in full-time employment during scheduled breaks on the strength of their study permit.^[24] After graduating from any educational program, students can stay in Canada by applying for an open work permit lasting three years without any restrictions, known as the Post-Graduation Work Permit (PGWP).^[25] Through it, they naturally qualify for permanent residency. Then, if they wish to become permanent residents, they can do so through the available Permanent Residency Pathways. The Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship plan for 2019-2020 aimed to primarily export Western values and import new ideas by offering educational opportunities to international students. Additionally, it was to position Canada at a competitive advantage in generating profitable economic returns, and to ensure a significant influx of either permanent or rotating tax-paying bodies. However, primarily it was to enable international students to acquire knowledge and skills to help create jobs and drive social changes in their home countries.^[5] In 2022, experts in international student education found that Canada's approach to foreign students has shifted. It's no longer solely about uplifting the world's brightest minds or aiding developing nations. Instead, Canadian higher education has transformed into a business-driven endeavor, characterized by competitive marketing strategies. This shift has ignored the necessity of strengthening the Canadian workforce and its global competency. Both public and private educational institutions are pursuing the lucrative venture of providing international student education. This pursuit has transformed academic programs into products catering to and exploiting the post-study, open-work permit needs of international students rather than aligning with the job requirements of Canadian residents and addressing the country's labor market needs, especially for high-skilled workers. As part of addressing these unsustainable changes and the lack of capacity to accommodate explosive population growth, IRCC announced in 2024 that it would no longer support the eligibility of a post-graduation work permit upon graduation from an institute operating under a curriculum licensing arrangement, among other strategic decisions.^[26][27][28] A curriculum licensing arrangement involves satellite institutes or private colleges offering educational programs under a licensing agreement with public universities and colleges. The Minister responsible for IRCC stated that they are implementing these changes with the aim of mitigating "short-term gains for a lot of long-term pain," and ensuring overall sustainability.^[29]

In the 2010s, there was a shift in immigration policy due to small businesses needing affordable labor, making student visas a step towards permanent residency, currently known as “two-step immigration.”^[30][31] This led to a historic population growth in Canada in 2022, affecting housing due to a lack of housing plans. Stats Canada noted that 58% of this increase was due to temporary residents, including students.^[32] Moreover, a vast majority of these students are not enrolled or trained in fields where Canada needs to meet its labour demands. Currently, multi-year open work permits are granted to international students upon their graduation, regardless of whether their education matches Canada's labor market demands. In 2024, the Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) reported a pronounced trend in which international students are increasingly and alarmingly finding success in claiming asylum. To illustrate the pattern, they cited two noteworthy examples: between 2022 and 2023, the number of asylum claims submitted by students and graduates from Seneca College surged from 300 to 700, while those from Conestoga College increased from 106 to 450. This data further highlights the challenges in higher education provided to international students and their actual capacity to fulfill legitimate labor shortages.^[33] This practice potentially has a more negative impact on their home countries and conflicts with their initial intention of being genuine students seeking quality education in Canada.^[34] In recent years, there has been considerable concern about how well international graduates are faring during their post graduation work permit phase.^[35] Some investigative journalists reveal that most international graduates working on post-graduate work permits aren't successful in achieving upward socioeconomic mobility with their Canadian education in Canada, and are either commandeering low-qualification jobs that previously sustained middle-class Canadian families or are stuck in low-skilled, low-paying jobs.^[36]

Marc Miller, the Immigration Minister, has stated that international students claiming refugee status do so on several difficult-to-deny grounds. Firstly, they argue that the Canadian education system has failed them, leaving them with substandard education that did not equip them with meaningful job skills or prospects aligned with labor market needs. Consequently, they claim that the Canadian education system has deceived them with false promises regarding the value of Canadian education, and they assert that it is tantamount to being swindled out of their investment. Secondly, they assert that the government exploited them by promoting Canada as a destination for investment, signaling that the international student visa program is a pathway to residency, citizenship, and Canadian employment. Both of these factors have led to systemic and socioeconomic persecution that would further destabilize their situation if they were to return to their homeland. The minister further stated that this collective failure serves as the basis for their refugee claim, particularly if their aspirations were dashed by false assurances and inadequate education resulting from governmental and institutional negligence or negligent persecution due to complicity. A refugee specialist with the Kitchener-Waterloo Multicultural Centre, added that furnishing further details such as sexual orientation, difference in political opinion, and the risk of gender or domestic violence, would make their case stronger. It would show how their fear is connected to a reason recognized under the Refugee Convention for why they can't go back home.^[37][38] In March 2024, Marc Miller also announced that the government is returning to the core elements of the liberal government's immigration strategy, supporting the transition of temporary residents into permanent residents through more domestic draws. Reaffirming the government's tacit policy regarding student visa immigration as an unofficially accredited pathway for permanent residency, among its other temporary resident entry pathways.^[39]

In 2024, the Canadian government altered the allowable working hours for international students. Prior to 2024, students were limited to working 20 hours per week. Following the change, international students may now work more than 20 hours per week in accordance with public policy until the study permit extension expires or until April 30, 2024, whichever comes first, provided their application for an extension was received on or before October 7, 2022, and their application was approved.^[40]

The large number of international students studying in Canada contributes significantly to the Canadian economy. According to Global Affairs Canada, the economic impact can be felt across the entire country. In 2015, expenditures by international students, including tourism associated with visitors to the students, was worth $12.8 billion; in 2016, that figure had increased by 21.2% to $15.5 billion. Long-term international students spent an estimated yearly average of $33,800 in 2015 and $35,100 in 2016. This figure includes expenses associated with education, as well as unrelated discretionary spending, but excludes money spent by visiting family and friends. In 2015, international student education created or supported 140,010 jobs (118,640 full-time equivalent), and in 2016, that increased to approximately 168,860 jobs (143,150 FTE).^[16] By 2022, the Canadian government reported that the annual economic contribution of international students had increased to $22.3 billion, greater than exports of auto parts, lumber or aircraft.^[41]

International student spending in Ontario contributed $5.04 billion to the provincial gross domestic product in 2015; this figure increased to $6.35 billion in 2016. The expenditures of international students supported 62,737 jobs in 2015, and 79,034 jobs in 2016.^[16] British Columbia also experienced an increase in their GDP from $2.39 billion in 2015 up to $2.76 in 2016. Over the same period, jobs supported by foreign enrollment in British Columbia increased from 35,294 to 40,499.^[16]

The economic effects of foreign students studying in Canada can be profound and varied; for example, they must handle all aspects of their education independently and pay higher tuition than students from the United States. When it comes to consumer spending, international students spend their money on a variety of items such as housing, food, transit, rent, and other living ^[42]costs.

The notable growth in international students from India has led to escalated tensions with Canada's large Indian Canadian community, who claim that students are "stealing their jobs" and "causing violence" within the established Indian enclaves of the country.^[43][44]

The active commodification of education for international students in Canada began in the early 2000s, primarily in response to declining domestic enrollment due to demographic changes. Canada aimed to attract a larger share of these financial streams and better compete with other top host countries such as the U.S., the U.K., and Australia for international students. To achieve this, the federal government made several changes to Canada’s immigration rules, effectively making it easier for international students to qualify for permanent residency, particularly by allowing them to stay and work after graduation through open work permits. The expanded prospects for profit and reduced oversight have heightened the economic interests of universities and colleges, resulting in a multitude of ethical issues, including increased collaborations with private institutions. These problems collectively undermine the integrity and quality of the Canadian post-secondary education system. However, the federal government has largely overlooked these concerns because international students both keep the post-secondary institutions financially afloat and offset the labor shortages in low-skilled sectors, with concerns parochially regarded as inconsequential.^[45][46][47]

The shift of Canadian post-secondary institutions from operating as entities serving the public good to adopting a business-oriented model has raised significant ethical concerns and led to widespread instances of misuse. In 2019, the Toronto Star and St. Catharines Standard collaborated to produce an investigative series about international students called "The Price of Admission", which examined industry costs, academic performance, exploitation for profit, and other aspects of the industry.^{[48][49][50][51]} Canadian magazine The Walrus published an investigative piece in 2021 which looked at potential exploitation faced by international students in Canada due to difficulties meeting their financial needs.^[52] A 2019 report by Statistics Canada revealed that approximately 1 in 3 student permit holders residing in Canada are not currently enrolled in schools, raising concerns about potential instances of misuse of temporary residency privileges.^[53] Specific measures to address this issue have been hindered by the lack of comprehensive data on individuals tied to temporary social insurance number.^[54][55][56]

According to a report by The Globe and Mail, there are several issues with student recruitment in India, imposing multiple challenges on international students in Canada.^[57] Lawyer Mario D. Bellissimo provided a legal analysis in an interview with CBC Radio's The Current, highlighting limitations and proposing changes to the international student system.^[58] Many businesses in India send a large number of students to Canada each year, promising them a new life, job opportunities, and a chance at Canadian citizenship. They found that some colleges and universities in Canada lack social infrastructure to support these students adequately. The surge in the student population has led to a shortage of purpose-built rentals in cities like Brampton, resulting in students living in overcrowded and unsafe accommodations. The hidden network of rental market also posed more risks to student safety and well-being.^[59]

It was also found out that students struggle to pay their college fees and are pressurized to maintain the illusion of thriving, leading them to borrow money and face financial pressures. The report highlighted misuse and other issues with recruitment practices and about the challenges faced by international students in Canada, particularly in terms of housing and assimilation.^[60][61] The Vancouver Sun reported open presence of street hawkers in Western Canada offering immigration services to desperate individuals seeking permanent residency. These agents promise visas and Canadian passports for large sums, provide false hopes and misleading information, and misrepresents study visa program as an easy route for chain migration of relatives and permanent residency. This has led to disappointment and wasted resources for clients.^[62]

Shady agreements involving spousal jobs as a pathway to permanent residency have also resulted in an unexpected increase in the number of dependents accompanying international students to Canada, as per the immigration statistics. Alongside scams involving visitor's visas, they run illicit schemes that use provincial immigrant entrepreneur programs.^[63] Some media have reported an increasing problem with international students committing suicide, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic.^[64][65][66]

Some immigration specialists raise concerns that the unrestricted granting of student visas in Canada could lead to a difficult situation similar to that faced by Germany and the United States. Germany had to grant amnesty to millions of temporary workers, and the U.S. is grappling with the fate of undocumented "Dreamers."^[67] Additionally, the increased admittance of international students has contributed to Canada's housing crisis, impacting the poorest and most marginalized communities. Renters, who typically have lower incomes, struggle to find affordable housing and jobs due to competition with foreign students, leading them to forced relocations from their hometowns. Institutions' unregulated pursuit of profits by admitting more foreign students has been widely reported to exacerbate the housing affordability issue.^[68][69][70]

A reported, growing, and unfettered trend is education consultants advising international students to first enter the country to pursue any available one-year educational programs, bypassing potential issues with student visa sanctions and accessibility to educational programs. By doing so, they can subsequently enroll in additional year-long or multi-year-long programs as on-shore international students, typically with education providers who have up-scaled their operations and offer an unregulated number of generic, poor-quality programs. As an on-shore international student, there is less scrutiny in accessing educational programs, and international students will be able to gain multi-year visas and open work rights, allowing students to extend their stay and studies for more years, facilitating their primary intention of staying for longer periods in Canada. Canadian international student education providers are welcoming to this kind of business because there are no checks and balances that disallow them from providing it due to the inefficient system and policies. This trend further raises doubts about the integrity of providing an unregulated number of student visas or extensions of it. Reports in 2024 about the resurgence of jobs-for-sale activities by unscrupulous Canadians seeking to game the inefficient immigration system for unethical profit-making, and the growing and unblocked trend of educational consultants misleading international students graduate visa route as a pathway for remaining permanently in Canada raise the integrity of providing work permits to international students who already have the opportunity to gain Canadian experience relevant to their education as genuine students during co-op placements, in a full-time capacity during their summer breaks, and in a part-time capacity as temporary residents.^[71][72]

Until 2014, international students were able to receive study permits from almost any educational institution, including unaccredited institutions, and only had to show their intention to study while in Canada.^[73] Students could remain in Canada by extending their study permit through a series of studies, until they are able to achieve their full legal status.^[73] According to a 2006 report by Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA), study permits had been exploited by parties linked to organized crime to enable them to enter Canada.^[73] Regulations were changed in 2014 to limit study permits to "designated learning institutions," and students had to show that they were actively pursuing studies.^[74] Incidents of fraudulent student visas still occur, and may be associated with human trafficking.^[75][76][77]