River Plate

Carrizo made his debut with River Plate on 29 January 2006 against Tiro Federal, keeping a clean sheet in River's 5–0 thrashing of the Rosario club. He played with River Plate until the last game of the 2008 Clausura, helping the team obtain the national championship.

Lazio

Carrizo was supposed to move to Lazio in the summer (July–August) transfer window of 2007, but the deal fell through over complications regarding Carrizo's eligibility for European citizenship.^[1] He finally registered with the Lega Nazionale Professionisti on 6 June 2008.

On 8 July 2008, Carrizo arrived in Rome and was formally presented to the media and fans as a Lazio player for the first time, stating his ambition of winning the Derby della Capitale against local rivals Roma.

However, Carrizo's lost his place as first-choice goalkeeper during his first season after a 1–4 home defeat to Cagliari on 25 January 2009 when coach Delio Rossi opted to replace him with Uruguayan Fernando Muslera. Throughout his time on the Lazio bench, Carrizo repeatedly voiced his discontent at losing his place, and thus Lazio elected to fine him €20,000.^[2]

Internazionale

On 31 January 2013, in the last day of winter transfer window, Carrizo joined fellow Serie A side Internazionale for a fee of €250,000.^[6][7] In his presentation one week later, Carrizo said that "it is an honour to join Inter", adding "I want to do my bit for the team both on and off the pitch."^[8][7][9] The Argentinian served as a second choice goalkeeper after Luca Castellazzi suffered an injury.^[10] Carrizo made his debut for the club against Bologna in Serie A on 10 March 2013, as Inter suffered a 0–1 home defeat at San Siro.^[11] This was his first and only appearance for 2012–13 season, and Inter finished the Serie A season in a disappointing 9th place. After the season finished, he extended his contract until 2015.^[12]

During the 2013 International Champions Cup, held in United States of America, in the team's final match against Juventus for seventh place, Carrizo made 2 penalty saves and also scored a penalty kick himself, helping the team to win 9–8 on penalties.^[13] Carrizo played his first official appearance for the new season on 20 October 2013 in an away match against Torino, coming on to replace Samir Handanović, who was sent off (Carrizo in fact entered the field by replacing Kovačić), and save a penalty kick against Alessio Cerci in an evidential 3–3 draw at Stadio Olimpico.^[14] Six days later, in a league game against Hellas Verona, Carrizo played his first match as a starter in a 4–2 win over in San Siro.^[15] In December 2013, Carrizo made his first Coppa Italia appearance for Inter, playing full 90 minutes in a 3–2 win over against Trapani.^[16]

Carrizo made a notable performance for Inter in a friendly match against Real Madrid in Berkeley, California on 26 July 2014 in the 2014 International Champions Cup where he made two saves, contributing to Inter's penalty shootout victory over the current European Champions, earning him a Man of the Match award.^{[citation needed]} On 30 June, Inter announced Carrizo had extended his Inter contract until 2017.^[17]

On 2 March 2016, in the returning leg of Coppa Italia's semi-final against Juventus at San Siro, Carrizo started the match and made several vital saves, including one in the 120 minute against Álvaro Morata, helping Inter overturn the 3–0 defeat and equal the aggregate 3–3, which led the match into the penalty shootouts; he did not save any of Juventus' penalties, as Inter lost 3–5 and eventually was eliminated from the competition.^[18][19]

Carrizo made his first competitive appearance of 2016–17 season on 24 November 2016 in the matchday 5 of 2016–17 UEFA Europa League group stage against Hapoel Be'er Sheva, entering as a substitute for Handanović who was sent-off in the 69th minute, conceding two times in an eventual 3–2 away defeat, which confirmed the elimination of Inter from Europa League.^[20] In the final matchday against Sparta Prague, Carrizo made a notable match, saving a Bořek Dočkal penalty, helping Inter to finish the European season with a win.^[21]

On 28 May 2017, Inter announced that Carrizo would leave the club after the season.^[22] On the same day, Carrizo was the starting keeper for the team against Udinese, a match in the last round of 2016–17 Serie A.

Monterrey

On 7 June 2017, CF Monterrey announced the signing of Juan Pablo Carrizo as a free agent.^[23][24]

Club

As of 28 May 2017^[25][26]

International

As of 6 January 2017^[27]