1882–1899

1900–1999

Through the first half of the 20th century, Lucy served as a restaurant, business office, cottage, and tavern (the last closed by Prohibition). The building was depicted on many souvenir postcards, often referred to as "The Elephant Hotel of Atlantic City." (The actual hotel was in a nearby building, not inside the elephant.)

By the 1960s, Lucy had fallen into disrepair and was scheduled for demolition. In 1969, Edwin T. Carpenter and a group of Margate citizens formed the Margate Civic Association, which later became the Save Lucy Committee under Josephine Harron and Sylvia Carpenter. They were given a 30-day deadline to move the edifice or pay for its demolition. Various fund-raising events, the most successful a door-to-door canvass by volunteers, raised money.

Over a period of about seven hours on July 20, 1970, Lucy was moved about 100 yards to the west-southwest to a city-owned lot to be completely refurbished. She remained closed to visitors until 1974 when structural repairs and upgrades were complete. The building's original wooden frame was buttressed with new steel and the deteriorated howdah was replaced with a replica. A plug of green glass set into the howdah platform refracts light into Lucy's interior.^[10][7]

In 1976, Lucy was designated a National Historic Landmark during the United States Bicentennial celebration.^[7]

2000–present

Lucy's birthday is commemorated each year on July 20, which includes a fundraising event and celebration of children's games and much fanfare.

In 2006, Lucy was struck by lightning, blackening the tips of the tusks. In October 2012, Hurricane Sandy made landfall near Margate. Lucy remained unscathed, although the surge reached the building's toes and a small booth in the parking lot was blown over.^[10]

On July 23, 2016, Lucy's staff announced the building's fake candidacy for President of the United States at a celebration for her 135th birthday.^[11] In 2016, Lucy had 135,000 visitors at the site, 35,000 of whom took the guided tour.^[7]

On February 27, 2020, Lucy began allowing overnight stays. Lucy was listed on Airbnb for $138 per night on March 17, 18 and 19, 2020. It marked the first time Lucy had been inhabited by humans since it was rented as a home in the early 1900s.^[12][13]

Inspections in 2021 revealed that more than half of Lucy's metal skin had degraded beyond repair and needed to be replaced. Upon receiving a $500,000 grant from the National Park Service in August 2021, the Save Lucy Committee announced a plan to repair Lucy and replace the faulty metal exterior skin. Lucy temporarily closed on September 20, 2021. The project was partially funded by a grant from the Preserve New Jersey Preservation Fund administered by the New Jersey Historic Trust. During restorations, a weatherproof scaffolding was built around Lucy. The original target was for an eight-month project and to reopen Memorial Day 2022.^[14][15] After delays pushed the reopening date back some, Lucy the Elephant fully reopened to the public after 15 months on December 28, 2022. The overall cost of the restoration was $2.4 million; a mixture of inflation and supply chain problems had increased the cost from the initial projections.^[16][17]

On January 5, 2023, the City of Margate approved a plan to create a visitor's center on Lucy's existing site. The proposed 2-story building is to include a retail area, information and displays, meeting spaces, and restrooms. The new structure will be located on the site of the existing gift shop and would be elevated to meet current flood codes.^[18]

Lucy booked a new record high of 42,267 tours in 2023, surpassing the previous record set in 2018. ^[19]

Elephantine Colossus (1885–1896)

The Elephantine Colossus or Elephant Hotel, at Coney Island amusement park in Brooklyn, New York, stood 122 feet (37.2 m) tall, approximately twice the size of Lucy, with seven floors of rooms, and legs 60 feet in circumference. With the exception of the number and relative size of the windows, and the design of the howdah, its exterior was a nearly exact scaled-up replication of Lucy. It held a cigar store in one leg and a diorama in another, hotel rooms within the elephant proper, and an observation area at the top with panoramic sea views. It burned down in 1896.^[20]

Light of Asia (1884–1900)

Light of Asia (dubbed Old Jumbo by locals) opened in Cape May in 1884, and was a slightly smaller version of Lucy. It was not successful and was torn down within 16 years. Lafferty was not directly involved with the construction but granted patent rights to Theodore M. Rieger, a real estate developer like himself, who sought to do for Cape May what Lafferty did with Lucy for Atlantic City^[21] It is unclear whether the Light of Asia matched the quality of the other buildings; the only known surviving photo of Light of Asia appears to have been taken while still under construction with no metal skin and an incomplete head, and with yet another different howdah design.^[22] A video presented to visitors inside Lucy in 2009 includes that same photo with the narration describing it as Cape May's "inferior rendition" of Lucy.^[23]

Prospectus for 1893 World's Columbian Exposition

A prospectus was published in 1892 by Kirby (while Lafferty still owned the patent) for a fourth building, even larger than Elephantine Colossus and with a moving trunk, eyeballs, ears and tail as well as a Calliope in the throat, to be built for the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago.^[24][8] No actual construction was ever attempted.

Movies

• In 1972, Lucy appeared in the movie The King of Marvin Gardens, starring Jack Nicholson and Bruce Dern.
• In 1980, Lucy can be briefly seen in the opening of the Oscar nominated film, Atlantic City, starring Burt Lancaster and Susan Sarandon.
• In 1983, Lucy is shown on a postcard with a picture in the opening credits of the film, National Lampoon's Vacation.^[25]
• An ice cream shop with a living area above shaped like Lucy appears in the 1991 Disney film The Rocketeer, although the film takes place in Southern California.
• The Jardin the Paris Elephant, a real-life large elephant structure inspired by “Elephantine Colossus”, (a larger version of Lucy, built by Lafferty in 1885 on Coney Island), is featured as the location of the boudoir of Nicole Kidman's character in the 2001 film Moulin Rouge!^[26]
• In 2015, Lucy was featured in the opening credits of the film Vacation, similar to the original 1983 film, National Lampoon's Vacation.^[25]

Television

• In 1979, Lucy appeared in the intro to the short-lived CBS drama series Big Shamus, Little Shamus which takes place in Atlantic City.
• In 1986, Lucy appeared on an episode of Mister Rogers' Neighborhood, in which Fred Rogers took a short tour of Lucy.^[27]
• In November 2006, the building was prominently featured in an advertisement for Proformance Insurance.
• In 2006, the History Channel television series Weird U.S. featured Lucy in an episode.^[9]
• In 2009, Lucy was featured in an episode of Life After People, which illustrated how the environment would take over the structure without people to maintain Lucy.
• In a 2011 episode of Boardwalk Empire, Agent Van Alden mentions "a hotel shaped like an elephant" among the local attractions. Lucy is also briefly seen in the second-season episode "Gimcrack & Bunkum".
• On April 2, 2014, Lucy appeared in a clip on an episode of Strange Inheritance, which mainly featured the World's tallest thermometer, another well-known roadside attraction.
• On June 14, 2014, The Travel Channel's Monumental Mysteries featured Lucy the Elephant in an episode.^[28]
• The 2017 movie The Dunning Man shows footage of the effort to preserve the building.
• In 2021, Lucy appeared in an episode of the PBS series Drive By History which described her cultural significance in American history.^[29]

Music

• 2020: A song named "Lucy The Elephant" was written, created and performed by Dan Walsh and Patty Blee.^[30]

Print media

• 2012: Lucy was featured in the book, Stay Close by Harlan Coben (ISBN 1101561173).
• April 18, 2015: Lucy was featured in the Bill Griffith daily comic strip "Zippy the Pinhead".
• July, 2022: 'Big Potato Games' announced that Lucy will be among 49 popular national roadside attractions featured in "Zillionaires: Road Trip USA", its new Monopoly style family board game.^[31]