Metropolitan Green Belt


The Metropolitan Green Belt is a statutory green belt around London, England. It comprises parts of Greater London and the six adjoining "home counties",[n 1] parts of two of the three districts of the small county of Bedfordshire and a small area in Copthorne, Sussex.[n 2][1][2] As of 2017/18, Government statistics show the planning designation covered 513,860 hectares (1,269,800 acres) of land.[3]

The Metropolitan Green Belt (outlined in red) among other green belts of England

History


For some years after 1580 Elizabeth I of England banned new building in a three-mile wide belt around the City of London, in an attempt to stop the spread of plague. However, this was not widely enforced, relatively short-lived and it was possible to buy dispensations which reduced the effect.[4]

The concept was also inspired by those elsewhere in Europe, one being inner buffer zones and broad boulevards to separate non-ancient parts. One re-used extensive ramparts more like protective fields to serve old city walls, the Ringstraße, in inner Vienna before 1900 in which numerous parks have been laid out.

The first major proposals for a green belt were put forward from 1890 onward, but the first to garner widespread support was put forward by the London Society (LS) in its Development Plan of Greater London 1919. The LS, alongside the Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE), first lobbied for a belt (initially of up to two miles wide) to prevent urban sprawl, beyond which new development could occur; this was not realised. The great interwar Britain housing boom, from 8 million homes in 1921 to 11.3 million in 1939, saw most of today's Greater London apart from its very edge developed too densely to be conferred any near-contiguous green belt status. The great increase in private motor transport continued into the 1950s. Despite new roads and the London Underground, London traffic congestion and pollution was forecast to become highly problematic unless development could be encouraged outside of a contiguous capital city. A solution emerged from study of the localised preservation of the character of the couronne périurbaine (around-town crown) surrounding Paris, and a movement to expand instead satellite towns and other towns in France. In 1947, Jean-François Gravier successfully advocated to the French government major policies to reduce "regional disparity".[5] Labour's Attlee ministry acted similarly in Britain, first enacting the New Towns Act 1946 and issuing Circulars and Planning Policies for local government councils to implement including accelerating the designation of the Metropolitan Green Belt.

The first policy groundwork to the Metropolitan Green Belt was in Herbert Morrison's 1934 leadership of the London County Council. It was first formally proposed by the Greater London Regional Planning Committee in 1935, "to provide a reserve supply of public open spaces and of recreational areas and to establish a green belt or girdle of open space". The ongoing policy decisions made were approved and entrenched in an advisory Greater London Plan prepared by Patrick Abercrombie in 1944 (which sought a belt of up to six miles, 9.7 km wide). After passage of the Green Belt Act 1938, it took 14 years for the elected local authorities responsible for the area around London to define the area on scaled maps with some precision. Following the establishment of the belt around London, feedback being received, and statements and debates in the House of Commons, other authorities nationwide were similarly encouraged in 1955 by Minister Duncan Sandys to designate a belt of all undeveloped land. As to London it was idealised to extend to land not earmarked for building "7 to 10 miles deep all around the built-up area of Greater London".[6]

New provisions for compensation in the Town and Country Planning Act 1947 allowed local authorities to incorporate green belt proposals in their first development plans. The codification of Green Belt policy and its extension to areas other than London came with Sandys' annexed Circular 42/55 urging the Clerk of the Council of all local planning authorities (impliedly who had not done so already) to establish Green Belts "wherever it is desirable....(a) to check further growth of a large built-up area; (b) to prevent neighbouring towns from merging into one another; or (c) preserve the special character of a town."[7] This decision was made in tandem with the New Towns Act 1946, which accompanied other acts turning to commercial use or low density bomb-stricken parts of Inner London, providing new homes for residents in districts of Outer London which would accept social housing and founding the post-war new towns. Created under the New Towns Act outside of the belt were Basildon, Bracknell, Harlow, Hatfield, Hemel Hempstead, Milton Keynes and Stevenage. Much funding was outlaid in new roads, railway stations and social housing. Contrasting to these new towns such a degree of social housing was still as strongly resisted as possible in upmarket suburbs and most of the existing exurbs well-connected to London in the new Green Belt which almost unwaveringly elected majority-Conservative councils. Such private housing-dominant bastions of the Green Belt being Edgware, Amersham, Staines upon Thames, Surbiton, Sevenoaks and Epping.

In the 1938–1950s period, earmarking of the Green Belt intra-London infill areas continued to be earmarked for housing and those to "round off" the shape of London as official policy. A direct consequence was that when London was redrawn (namely from the 1889 County of London to Greater London) its area in 1965 was made five times greater.[8] This selective and encouraged urbanisation, coupled with the New Towns, ensured authorities did not need to expect a shortage of housing and were centrally lobbied (and in some cases also locally lobbied) to designate land as Green Belt in order to offset congestion and pollution consequent upon their policies of growth.

As the outward growth of London was seen to be firmly repressed, residents owning properties further from the built-up area also campaigned for this policy of urban restraint, partly to safeguard their own investments but often invoking the paradigm English thinking running from John Ruskin to at least John Betjeman, a scenic/rustic argument which lays the blame for most social ills upon urban influences and which leads few retired people to live in London. In mid-1971, mindful of the new towns in Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire, the government decided to extend the Metropolitan Green Belt northwards to include almost all of Hertfordshire. The Metropolitan Green Belt now covers parts of 68 different Districts or Boroughs.

Extension and reduction


London's green belt was extended after 1955, in places to a distance of 35 miles out. The belt is subject to minor annual variations, and covers an area approximately three times the size of London.

Extension has taken place to take in large parts of the Surrey Hills, Chiltern Hills and three of the areas known as various Wealds including Epping Forest, as such extension pre-dates certain largely duplicative protections which cover those areas, particularly Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty. Redesignation includes for transport or civil engineering infrastructure, housing and non-agricultural industry, retail and non-green or blue buffer leisure. In general agriculture and open-air leisure uses, including golf courses, and fresh water reservoirs (often used for sailing), can be designated green belt land.

All Local Authorities have the option of limited green belt land release in their Local Plans, according to legally necessary "exceptional circumstances" envisioned by the 1955 Act.[9][10][11][12][13]

Debate and controversy


The London Society heightened debate about the city's green belt in 2014 in its report entitled "Green Sprawl".[14][15][16][17][18] Other organisations, including the Planning Officers Society,[19] echoed with specific calls for a UK Governmental review and proposals to balance land release for with concepts to compensate habitat loss and mitigate pollution, restitutionally (as if never converted).[20][21][22]

The Adam Smith Institute wrote a paper under its core ethos of economic liberalism challenging the goals of nature and environmental protection groups who advocate greater urban density. The paper highlighted the Metropolitan Green Belt had land to build a million typical closer London fringe (low-to-medium) density homes within ten minutes walk (800m) of existing train stations, specifically circa 20,000 hectares (77 sq mi). It gently critiqued 10,000 hectares (39 sq mi) of golf course land.[23][24]

A survey in 2016, by Ipsos Mori, found that many Londoners, particularly those who live in the most affected areas, think the trend towards ever taller, bolder skyscrapers has gone too far. More than 400 buildings of more than 20 floors in 2016 were tentatively proposed by developers in London.[25] Among respondents, six out of ten backed a limit on the height of new skyscrapers, with the same proportion backing restrictions on the number of buildings with more than 50 floors.[25]

Designated area


Green belt land in north Havering

The table lists the areas designated as the Metropolitan Green Belt in 2014. Between 2009 and 2014 there was a reduction of 435 hectares. By 2014 the only Inner London Borough to have had Green Belt, Greenwich, had lost its few acres of green belt designation.[26]

Every borough or equivalent district of the reduced counties of Surrey and Hertfordshire has Green Belt as does Bedfordshire, a county which has never contributed to present definition of London and has just 3 local government units. Four of five districts in Buckinghamshire, 4 of 6 in Berkshire, 9 of 14 in Essex, 7 of 13 in Kent, 18 of the 32 London boroughs, and 1 of the 13 Sussex districts/boroughs/unitary authorities has Green Belt.

District (planning authority) Region of England Ceremonial county Area (hectares)
Aylesbury ValeSouth EastBuckinghamshire4,800
Barking and DagenhamLondonGreater London530
BarnetLondonGreater London2,380
BasildonEastEssex6,950
BexleyLondonGreater London1,120
Bracknell ForestSouth EastBerkshire3,840
BrentwoodEastEssex13,700
BromleyLondonGreater London7,730
BroxbourneEastHertfordshire3,310
Castle PointEastEssex2,750
Central BedfordshireEastBedfordshire28,220
ChelmsfordEastEssex12,850
ChilternSouth EastBuckinghamshire17,380
CroydonLondonGreater London2,310
DacorumEastHertfordshire10,690
DartfordSouth EastKent4,110
EalingLondonGreater London310
East HertfordshireEastHertfordshire17,530
ElmbridgeSouth EastSurrey5,620
EnfieldLondonGreater London3,060
Epping ForestEastEssex31,680
Epsom and EwellSouth EastSurrey1,560
GraveshamSouth EastKent7,670
GuildfordSouth EastSurrey24,040
HaringeyLondonGreater London60
HarlowEastEssex640
HarrowLondonGreater London1,090
HaveringLondonGreater London6,010
HertsmereEastHertfordshire8,040
HillingdonLondonGreater London4,970
HounslowLondonGreater London1,230
Kingston upon ThamesLondonGreater London640
LutonEastBedfordshire140
MaidstoneSouth EastKent530
MedwaySouth EastKent1,340
Mid SussexSouth EastWest Sussex20
Mole ValleySouth EastSurrey19,640
NewhamLondonGreater London80
North HertfordshireEastHertfordshire14,250
RedbridgeLondonGreater London2,070
Reigate and BansteadSouth EastSurrey8,890
Richmond upon ThamesLondonGreater London140
RochfordEastEssex12,570
RunnymedeSouth EastSurrey6,140
SevenoaksSouth EastKent34,400
SloughSouth EastBerkshire860
South BucksSouth EastBuckinghamshire12,350
Southend-on-SeaEastEssex610
SpelthorneSouth EastSurrey3,320
St AlbansEastHertfordshire13,140
StevenageEastHertfordshire260
Surrey HeathSouth EastSurrey4,190
SuttonLondonGreater London620
TandridgeSouth EastSurrey23,300
Three RiversEastHertfordshire6,840
ThurrockEastEssex11,920
Tonbridge and MallingSouth EastKent17,060
Tunbridge WellsSouth EastKent7,130
UttlesfordEastEssex3,810
Waltham ForestLondonGreater London840
WatfordEastHertfordshire410
WaverleySouth EastSurrey21,080
Welwyn HatfieldEastHertfordshire10,250
Windsor and MaidenheadSouth EastBerkshire16,480
WokingSouth EastSurrey4,030
WokinghamSouth EastBerkshire2,900
WycombeSouth EastBuckinghamshire15,630
TOTAL514,060

Notes and references


Notes

  1. The six adjoining counties are Berkshire, Buckinghamshire, Essex, Hertfordshire, Kent and Surrey
  2. The adjoining counties fall in the South East and East of England regions which are not units of local government and have certain strategic central governmental uses.

References

  1. "Area of Designated Green Belt Land". London Datastore. Greater London Authority. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  2. "Mid Sussex Local Plan, May 2004"
  3. "Local Planning Authority Green Belt: England 2017/18" (PDF). Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government.
  4. Halliday, Stephen (2004). Underground to Everywhere. Sutton Publishing Limited. p. 118. ISBN 0-7509-3843-9.
  5. Paris et le désert français, 1947
  6. Annex to Circular 42/55 — the Statement to the House of Commons by Rt. Hon. Duncan Sandys, Minister for Planning on 26 April 1955
  7. "Past, The last 80 years". Beyond the Green Belt. The Building Centre. 16 March 2016. Retrieved 15 March 2019.
  8. See the size of the County of London, 74,903 acres (303.12 square km); compare Greater London
  9. National Planning Policy Framework 2018, paragraph 136
  10. R (Hunston Properties Ltd) v SSCLG and St Albans City and District Council [2013] EWCA Civ 1610 (12 December 2013):
  11. Gallagher Homes v Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council [2014] EWHC 1283. (Admin) (30 April 2014)
  12. R(IM Properties) v Lichfield DC and others [2014] EWHC 2440 (Admin) (18 July 2014)
  13. Plan Making Case Law Update published by and for the Local Government Association No. 5 Chambers Planning Advisory Service, Paper 4: Green Belt, November 2014
  14. Manns, J., "Green Sprawl: Our Current Affection for a Preservation Myth?", London Society, London, 2014
  15. "'London's green belt isn't sacrosanct … we need to build homes on". Standard.co.uk. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  16. "Peter Murray: Is London's Green Belt overprotected? - onoffice magazine". Onofficemagazine.com. Archived from the original on 22 February 2019. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  17. "Are they Green *Belts* by Accident?". Spatial-economics.blogspot.co.uk. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  18. "Why we need reform of the green belt in London and the South East - Homes For Britain". Homesforbritain.org.uk. 4 February 2015. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  19. "Planning for a Better Future : Our planning manifesto for the next government" (PDF). Planningofficers.org.uk. 15 March 2015. Archived from the original (PDF) on 17 November 2015. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  20. "The Green Belt: A Place for Londoners?", London First, London, 2015
  21. "Delivering Change: Building Homes Where we Need Them", Centre for Cities, London, 2015
  22. "AECOM" (PDF). Aecom.com. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  23. "Press Release: New paper reveals where London's Green Belt must be built on to curtail housing crisis". Adamsmith.org. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  24. Tom Papworth. "a garden of one's own : Suggestions for development in the metropolitan Green Belt" (PDF). Static1.squarespace.com. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  25. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/aug/27/londoners-back-skyscraper-limit-skyline "Londoners back limit on skyscrapers as fears for capital’s skyline grow" Rob Davies, The Guardian 27 Aug 2016
  26. "Area of designated Green Belt land 1 by local planning authority as at 31 March 2014" (XLSX). Gov.uk. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
  • Outskirts, by John Grindrod