Permanent secretary


A permanent under-secretary of state, known informally as a permanent secretary, is the most senior civil servant of a ministry in the United Kingdom, charged with running the department on a day-to-day basis. Similar offices, often employing different terms, exist in many other Westminster-style systems and in some other governments. In the United States, the equivalent position is a Deputy Secretary of an executive department, though British permanent secretaries are career civil servants (whereas Deputy Secretaries are political appointees).

Permanent secretaries are the non-political civil service heads (and "accounting officers") or chief executives of government departments, who generally hold their position for a number of years (thus "permanent") at a ministry as distinct from the changing political secretaries of state to whom they report and provide advice.[1]

Permanent secretaries are appointed under a scheme in which the prime minister has the final say in the recruitment process; the PM now chooses directly from a list created by the Civil Service Commissioners, rather than only having a veto over the Commissioners' preferred candidate.[2][3]

Some permanent secretaries do not hold the position of permanent secretary, but still hold that grade. The Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Act 2014 explains that a permanent secretary, for the purposes of section 2 of that Act, is a person serving in government in any of the following positions: Permanent Secretary, Second Permanent Secretary, Cabinet Secretary, Chief Executive of Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs, Chief Medical Officer, Director of Public Prosecutions, First Parliamentary Counsel, Government Chief Scientific Adviser, Head of the Civil Service or Prime Minister's Adviser for Europe and Global Issues.[4]

In the United Kingdom


History

When Lord Grey took office as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom in 1830, John Barrow was especially requested to continue serving as Secretary in his department (the Admiralty), starting the principle that senior civil servants stay in office on change of government and serve in a non-partisan manner. It was during Barrow's occupancy of the post that it was renamed permanent secretary.

Role

The Permanent Secretary, who in some, but not all, Government departments is known formally as the Permanent Under-Secretary of State, is the accounting officer for a department, meaning that they are answerable to parliament for ensuring that the department appropriately spends money granted by parliament. Permanent secretaries are thus frequently called for questioning by the Public Accounts Committee and select committees of the House of Commons. The permanent secretary usually chairs a department's management board which consists of executive members (other civil servants in the department) and non-executive directors. In the 1960s the permanent secretary to Tony Benn when he was Secretary of State for Industry was Peter Carey. After Benn spent government money on worker cooperatives, notably a motorbike company (Meriden Motorcycle Co-operative), Carey went before the Public Accounts Committee and expressed the opinion that his minister's expenditure had been ultra vires.[citation needed] Benn was soon moved to the Department of Energy, while Carey received a knighthood in the following honours list.

Some larger departments also have a second permanent secretary who acts as deputy. In the early 1970s, in a major reorganisation of Whitehall, many smaller ministries were amalgamated into larger departments. Following this reorganisation, virtually all departments had second permanent secretaries for a time, though this is no longer as common.

The most senior civil servant is the Cabinet Secretary, currently Simon Case; he is also the Head of the Home Civil Service. The holder of this office is distinct from other officials of permanent secretary rank within the Cabinet Office. By convention, the Prime Minister is Minister for the Civil Service and as such makes regulations regarding the service and has authority over it. These duties are delegated to the Minister for the Cabinet Office.

Honours

Permanent secretaries are usually created a Knight or Dame Commander of the Order of the Bath after five or more years of service in the grade or on retirement if not already holding the title (although the Permanent Secretary of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office will be created a Knight or Dame Commander of the Order of St Michael and St George instead). The most senior permanent secretaries, such as the Secretary of the Cabinet, may be created a Knight Grand Cross of the Order of the Bath, and even be given a life peerage after retirement. For salary comparison purposes, the permanent secretary is deemed broadly equivalent to a general and to a High Court judge.

Current permanent secretaries

Below is a list of the individuals in the UK government at the grade of permanent secretary.

Permanent secretaries in the UK government
DepartmentIndividualPosition
Ministerial departments
Cabinet Office Simon Case[5] Cabinet Secretary and Head of the Home Civil Service
Alex Chisholm[6] Cabinet Office Permanent Secretary and Chief Operating Officer of the Civil Service
Elizabeth Gardiner, CB, QC[7] First Parliamentary Counsel
Sir Simon Gass, KCMG, CVO[8] Chair, Joint Intelligence Committee
Sir Stephen Lovegrove National Security Adviser
Sue Gray Second Permanent Secretary (Union and Constitution)
Vacant Government Chief Digital Officer
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Sarah Munby Permanent Secretary
Sir Patrick Vallance[9] Government Chief Scientific Adviser
Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Sarah Healey, CB[10] Permanent Secretary
Department for Education Susan Acland-Hood[11] Permanent Secretary
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Tamara Finkelstein, CB[12] Permanent Secretary
Department for International Trade James Bowler CB Permanent Secretary
Crawford Falconer[13] Second Permanent Secretary and Chief Trade Negotiation Adviser
Department for Transport Bernadette Kelly, CB[14] Permanent Secretary
Department for Work and Pensions Peter Schofield, CB[15] Permanent Secretary
Department of Health and Social Care Sir Chris Wormald, KCB[16] Permanent Secretary
Shona Dunn Second Permanent Secretary
Chris Whitty, CB[17] Chief Medical Officer for England
Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office Sir Philip Barton KCMG OBE Permanent Secretary and Head of Her Majesty's Diplomatic Service
Lindsay Croisdale-Appleby CMG Ambassador to the European Union
Dame Karen Pierce, DCMG[18] Ambassador to the United States
Home Office Matthew Rycroft, CBE[19] Permanent Secretary
Tricia Hayes Second Permanent Secretary
HM Treasury Sir Tom Scholar, KCB[20] Permanent Secretary
Charles Roxburgh[21] Second Permanent Secretary
Martin Clarke[22] Government Actuary
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government Jeremy Pocklington[23] Permanent Secretary
Ministry of Defence David Williams Permanent Secretary
Sir Simon Bollom, KBE, CB[24] Chief Executive, Defence Equipment and Support (DE&S)
Ministry of Justice Antonia Romeo Permanent Secretary and Clerk of the Crown in Chancery
Jo Farrar[25] Second Permanent Secretary
Northern Ireland Office Madeleine Alessandri Permanent Secretary
Non-ministerial departments and non-departmental public bodies
Crown Prosecution Service Max Hill, QC[26] Director of Public Prosecutions
Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) Jeremy Fleming[27] Director of the Government Communications Headquarters
Government Legal Department Susanna McGibbon[28] Her Majesty's Procurator General, Treasury Solicitor and Head of the Government Legal Service
HM Revenue and Customs Jim Harra, CB[29] First Permanent Secretary and Chief Executive
Angela MacDonald Deputy Chief Executive and Second Permanent Secretary, Tax Assurance Commissioner
National Crime Agency Dame Lynne Owens, DCB, CBE, QPM[30] Director-General of the National Crime Agency
UK Health Security Agency Dr Jenny Harries OBE Chief Executive, UK Health Security Agency
Office for Standards in Education, Children's Services and Skills Amanda Spielman[31] Her Majesty's Chief Inspector
Secret Intelligence Service (MI6) Richard Moore, CMG[32] Chief of the Secret Intelligence Service
Security Service (MI5) Ken McCallum[33] Director General of the Security Service
UK Statistics Authority Professor Sir Ian Diamond[34] National Statistician
Devolved governments
Northern Ireland ExecutiveVacant Permanent Secretary and Head of the Northern Ireland Civil Service
Scottish Government Leslie Evans[35] Permanent Secretary
Welsh Government Dame Shan Morgan, DCMG[36] Permanent Secretary

In the Commonwealth


In some countries of the Commonwealth of Nations, the popular term for the equivalent position is now “principal secretary”.[citation needed]

Australia

In Australia, the position is called the "department secretary", “secretary of the department”, or “director-general of the department” in some states and territories.

Canada

In Canada, the senior civil service position is a "deputy minister", who within a government ministry or department is outranked only by a Minister of the Crown. Federally, deputy ministers are appointed by the Prime Minister on the advice of the Secretary to the Cabinet (the Head of Canada's civil service). They are considered to hold equal rank with Parliamentary Secretaries or Assistants – legislators appointed to assist Ministers in their duties – and are entitled to several privileges, including the use of diplomatic passports.

India

In India, the equivalent position is called 'secretary to the Government of India' and is the highest-ranking permanent civil servant in a department. With the exception of departments within the Ministry of External Affairs, which are headed by Indian Foreign Service officers, all Secretaries to the Government of India are drawn from cadres of the Indian Administrative Service.

These officers directly report to Ministers of the Union within their respective ministry, and oversee all day-to-day operations of their departments. Within the civil service, they are outranked only by the Cabinet Secretary of India or the Principal Secretary to the Prime Minister of India when the latter is granted the rank of Cabinet Secretary (as has been the case under Prime Minister Narendra Modi). A new exception to this rule is the Chief of the Defence Staff, who serves as ex-officio Secretary of the Department of Military Affairs within the Ministry of Defence but outranks all Secretaries to the Government of India in the Indian order of precedence.

Hong Kong

In Hong Kong, heads of policy bureaux, secretaries, were filled by civil servants until their titles were changed to permanent secretaries in 2002, when political appointees filled the positions of secretaries under the second Tung Chee Hwa government. Since August 2005, the Office of the Chief Executive also has a permanent secretary. His ranking is, however, lower than most other permanent secretaries according to the pay scale.

Malaysia

In Malaysia, a permanent secretary refers to the administrative head of a ministry in the states of Sabah and Sarawak. The administrative head of a federal ministry is called "secretary general".

Mauritius

On the island state of Mauritius, which is a former British colony, there are a number of Permanent Secretaries who report to the Secretary to Cabinet and H​ead of the Civil Service. In the Prime Minister's Office there are 2 Permanent Secretaries, assisted by 3 Deputy Permanent Secretaries as well as 4 Assistant Permanent Secretaries.[37] There are at least 147 Assistant Permanent Secretaries, 86 Deputy Permanent Secretaries and 37 Permanent Secretaries in the various Ministries of the Government of Mauritius.[38][39]

New Zealand

In New Zealand, the civil service head of a ministry is ordinarily entitled “chief executive”, though there are still some positions which still carry the title of secretary (Secretary of Education, Secretary of Justice, Secretary of Transport). In some cases (such as the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service, Ministry for Primary Industries, Department of Conservation, Ministry of Health) the title is “director-general”. Organisations with enforcement powers, such as the Inland Revenue Department and the New Zealand Police, are headed by commissioners. The New Zealand Customs Service is headed by the Comptroller of Customs. Civil service heads are officially employed by the State Services Commission, further separating them from the politicians who hold ministerial positions.

Pakistan

In Pakistan, the equivalent position is called Federal Secretary and is the highest ranking permanent civil servant in a federal ministry.

Singapore

In Singapore, permanent secretaries have to retire after a 10-year term even if they are younger than the official retirement age of 62. This was introduced in 2000 as part of the Public Service Leadership scheme, to provide opportunities for younger officers from the Administrative Service — the elite arm of the Civil Service — to rise up the ranks.

Sri Lanka

In Sri Lanka, a Secretary to the Ministry (also known as Ministry Secretary or simply Secretary) is the administrative head of a ministry and is appointed by the President of Sri Lanka. The post of Permanent secretary was created under the The Ceylon (Constitution and Independence) Orders in Council 1947 when Ceylon gained self-rule from Britain in 1948. Permanent secretaries were commonly appointed from the Ceylon Civil Service, with a few exceptions such as the permanent secretary to the ministry of justice which would be an officer of the judicial service. Anandatissa de Alwis was the first person from the private sector to be appointed as permanent secretary. The Sri Lankan Constitution of 1972, changed the title to secretary to the ministry. Traditionally if the appointee is a serving member a public service, he or she would leave the service for the duration they would hold the appointment. In the recent past it has been common for ministry secretaries to be appointed from outside the public service, with some on political grounds at the discretion of the president on the advice of the minister in charge.[40] Major General Sanjeewa Munasinghe became the first serving military officer from the regular force to be appointed a ministry secretary in 2020.[41]

Outside the Commonwealth


Germany

In Germany, the equivalent office is called Staatssekretär (state secretary). It is not to be confused with the "parliamentary state secretary", who serves as deputy to a minister, often with a more specialised field of responsibilities. The parliamentary state secretary is always a political position, and not part of the civil service.

Italy

In Italy, the highest civil service official in a ministry or department is either a segretario generale (secretary-general) or a direttore generale (director-general), while the position of sottosegretario di stato (under-secretary of state) is a political one and ranks below the ministro segretario di stato (minister-secretary of state, the head of a ministry or department) or the vice ministro (deputy-minister), both political posts as well.

Japan

The Japanese equivalents are the administrative vice-ministers.

In the Republic of Ireland, the position of "secretary-general" of a department is almost identical to that of a permanent secretary in the British civil service, with the exception that since the introduction in the mid-1990s of the Strategic Management Initiative, the post is no longer permanent, but carries a seven-year time limit. This coincided with the introduction of the change of title from the previous title of “secretary”. Irish government departments may also have a “second secretary”, which is equivalent to the Second Permanent Secretary grade in the British civil service. See also Civil service of the Republic of Ireland.

See also


References


  1. Cooper, C.A. Politics and the permanency of permanent secretaries: testing the vitality of the Westminster administrative tradition, 1949–2014. British Politics (2019). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-019-00113-8
  2. "New Permanent Secretary for the Department for Communities and Local Government". Department for Communities and Local Government. 8 January 2015. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  3. "Lying in wait: who will be the permanent secretaries meeting the new ministers in 2015?". Institute for Government. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  4. Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Act 2014 Section 2(6); Schedule 1 Section 11(1).
  5. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/simon-case-appointed-as-cabinet-secretary-and-head-of-the-civil-service [bare URL]
  6. "New Permanent Secretary at the Cabinet Office and Chief Operating Officer for the Civil Service". GOV.UK. Retrieved 2020-04-21.
  7. "First Parliamentary Counsel appointed: Elizabeth Gardiner". GOV.UK. 2015-11-20. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  8. "Joint Intelligence Committee Chair appointed: Sir Simon Gass". GOV.UK. 2019-06-18. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  9. "Appointment of Dr Patrick Vallance as government Chief Scientific Adviser". UK Government. 8 November 2017. Retrieved 7 September 2018.
  10. "Appointment of new Permanent Secretary at DCMS". GOV.UK. 2019-03-11. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  11. "Susan Acland-Hood made Acting Permanent Secretary at the Department for Education". gov.uk. HM Government. Retrieved 1 September 2020.
  12. "Appointment of new Permanent Secretary at Defra". GOV.UK. 2019-06-19. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  13. "DIT appoints Crawford Falconer as new Chief Trade Negotiation Adviser". GOV.UK. 2017-06-16. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  14. "New Permanent Secretary at the Department for Transport". GOV.UK. 2017-04-18. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  15. "Appointment of Peter Schofield as Permanent Secretary at the Department for Work and Pensions". GOV.UK. 2018-01-12. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  16. "New Permanent Secretary for the Department of Health". GOV.UK. 2016-01-15. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  17. "New chief medical officer appointed". GOV.UK. 2019-06-07. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  18. "Karen Pierce DCMG". GOV.UK. 2017-01-04. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  19. "Matthew Rycroft CBE appointed Permanent Secretary at the Home Office". GOV.UK. Retrieved 2020-04-21.
  20. "New Permanent Secretary to the Treasury announced". GOV.UK. 2016-03-11. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  21. "New Second Permanent Secretary to the Treasury appointed". GOV.UK. 2016-07-04. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  22. "Martin Clarke announced as new Government Actuary". GOV.UK. 2014-03-05. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  23. "Latest civil service & public affairs moves — April 6 | Civil Service World". www.civilserviceworld.com. Retrieved 2020-04-21.
  24. "Sir Simon Bollom appointed Chief Executive of Defence Equipment and Support". GOV.UK. 2018-04-27. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  25. "Appointment of Jo Farrar as Second Permanent Secretary at the Ministry of Justice". GOV.UK. Retrieved 2021-03-16.
  26. "Max Hill QC joins the CPS as Director of Public Prosecutions". GOV.UK. 2018-11-01. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  27. "Foreign Secretary appoints new GCHQ Director". GOV.UK. 2017-03-20. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  28. "Susanna McGibbon appointed as Treasury Solicitor, HM Procurator General and Permanent Secretary, Government Legal Department". GOV.UK. 2021-02-18. Retrieved 2021-03-10.
  29. "Jim Harra takes top job at HMRC | Accountancy Daily". www.accountancydaily.co. Retrieved 2020-02-03.
  30. "Director General (NCA): Lynne Owens CBE QPM MA - National Crime Agency". nationalcrimeagency.gov.uk.
  31. "Letter from Nicky Morgan: appointment of Amanda Spielman as HMCI". GOV.UK. 2016-07-07. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  32. "Appointment of the new Chief of the Secret Intelligence Service (MI6)". GOV.UK. 2014-10-03. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  33. MI5.GOV.UK. 2020-03-30 https://www.mi5.gov.uk/news/new-director-general-of-mi5-appointed. Retrieved 2020-06-29. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  34. "About the national statistician". statisticsauthority.gov.uk. Retrieved 2020-06-16.
  35. Johnson, Simon (2015-05-21). "Nicola Sturgeon selects new Scottish civil service chief". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  36. "New top Welsh civil servant is named". BBC News. 2016-11-09. Retrieved 2019-06-24.
  37. "Key Staff of PMO". Government of Mauritius. Retrieved 2021-07-24.
  38. "Administrative Cadre Staff List". Government of Mauritius. Retrieved 2021-07-23.
  39. "List of Permanent Secretaries" (PDF). Government of Mauritius. Retrieved 2020-09-01.
  40. De Silva, Leelananda. "The Machinery of Administration Under Parliamentary Government". Island. Retrieved 2 October 2019.
  41. Secretaries to the Ministries