Town hall meeting
Town hall meetings, also referred to as town halls or town hall forums, an expression that originates mainly from North America, are a way for local and national politicians to meet with their constituents either to hear from them on topics of interest or to discuss specific upcoming legislation or regulation. During periods of active political debate, town halls can be a locus for protest and more active debate. The term is unfamiliar in British English where the equivalent is a (political) surgery.
The examples and perspective in this article deal primarily with the United States and do not represent a worldwide view of the subject. (February 2017)
Despite their name, town hall meetings need not take place in a town hall. They are commonly held in a range of venues, including schools, libraries, municipal buildings, and churches. A number of officials have also experimented with digital formats for town halls. Town hall meetings organized by national politicians are often held in a variety of locations distributed across a voting district so that elected representatives can receive feedback from a larger proportion of constituents.
Historically, no specific rules or guidelines have defined a town hall meeting. Any event that allows constituent participation with a politician may be called a town hall, including gatherings in person, group phone calls, or events on Internet platforms such as Facebook or Twitter. Attendees use town halls to voice their opinions and question elected officials, political candidates, and public figures. In contrast to town meetings, a type of direct democratic rule that originated in colonial New England, attendees do not vote on issues during town hall meetings.
In the United States, town halls are a common way for national politicians to connect or reconnect with their constituents during recesses, when they are in their home districts away from Washington, D.C.
Town hall meetings can be traced back to the colonial era of the United States and to the 19th century in Australia. The introduction of television and other new media technologies in the 20th century led to a fresh flourishing of town hall meetings in the United States as well as experimentation with different formats in the United States and other countries, both of which continue to the present day.
Town hall meetings are meant to resemble the New England town meeting that originated in the 17th century. However, participants in town hall meetings do not actually vote or make legally binding decisions as town meeting voters do.
The 1858 debates between Abraham Lincoln and Stephen Douglas in some respects resembled a modern town hall meeting, although the candidates did not take questions from the audience. Not until the twentieth century did presidential candidates commonly campaign in person. Gradually, especially from the 1990s onward, presidential town hall meetings have become nearly as common as stump speeches.
Richard Nixon's 1968 U.S. Presidential campaign staged nine live televised question and answer sessions using a ground-breaking theatre-in-the-round format broadcast with a live studio television audience and local residents directly asking questions of the candidate.[circular reference] The producer of Nixon's "Man in the Arena" live town-hall programs was Roger Ailes, who later went to on start Fox News.[circular reference] Ailes' use of a direct voter-to-candidate question-and-answer format served as the blueprint for subsequent and now ubiquitous town hall candidate formats and even multiple-candidate debates.
Another step in the development of the modern town hall meeting came on March 16, 1977, when President Carter attended a televised town hall meeting in Clinton, Massachusetts, that was "modeled after" a real town meeting but did not include binding votes. Bill Clinton made town hall meetings a part of his presidential campaign.
Interest in town halls fluctuates depending on the level of public interest in the topics being discussed. Controversial or confusing issues that are prominently discussed in the news have led to more town halls being held. Since the 2000s, town halls held by political candidates have announced and enforced rules on crowd behavior and the scope of questions that may be asked.
- 21st century meetings
- Detailed article: List of significant United States town hall meetings
In 2009, Tea Party groups opposed to the proposed health care reform legislation began attending town halls to express their disagreement with the legislation. The large and vocal crowds led some representatives to cancel or scale back their town hall events. Representative Brian Baird canceled his live town hall meetings after receiving death threats, choosing to hold a telephone conference call with his constituents instead.
Town hall meetings by teleconference or online grew in popularity. Obama held some as sitting President, starting in 2011. Federal agencies have held town halls on Twitter since at least 2013. Some politicians have held AMAs on Reddit, which have similar formats.
In 2017, constituents opposed to repeal of that same health care act began attending town halls to express their disagreement with abolishing the legislation. In districts where elected representatives have not scheduled town halls, some constituents have publicly petitioned for meetings. Creative requests for town hall meetings include humorous flyer and sticker campaigns as well as songs. Some constituents have held mock town halls, using a cardboard cutout or empty chair, to stand in for elected representatives who decline to meet with them.
Australian town hall meetings have been held by state politicians since at least the 19th century.
Canadian town halls have been forums for provincial politicians to discuss issues of the day since at least the 20th century. During the 1993 elections, televised town hall meetings were one of a number of initiatives mainstream media adopted to center ordinary citizens at the heart of their campaign coverage. These efforts, which also included panels of voters to offer comment in print and on radio shows, have been collectively praised as an "international best practice."
Town hall meetings, alternately referred to as タウンミーティング (taunmiitingu) and with the English-language phrase "town meeting," have been held in Japan since the late 1970s. In 1979 Shunichi Suzuki, then governor of Tokyo, held a town hall meeting, its name and format inspired by President Carter's 1977 televised town hall. In subsequent years, media conglomerate TBS has organized town hall meetings with both Japanese and foreign politicians. Various governmental agencies have also held town halls, including the Cabinet Office (National Dialogue of the Town Meeting Koizumi Cabinet), Ministry of Foreign Affairs (ODA Town Meeting), and the Ministry of the Environment (Septic Town Meeting), among others. Political parties, such as the LDP, Democratic Party, Komeito, and Japanese Communist Party, also hold town hall meetings.
The format extends beyond governmental administration and political parties. Other examples include the Athlete Town Meeting held by the Japanese Olympic Committee, the JAXA Town Meeting held by the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, and the Intellectual Property Town Meeting held by the Japan Patent Attorneys Association.
There have been no specific rules or guidelines for holding a town hall meeting. The format of the meetings can vary. Usually, the person holding the meeting (e.g. member of Congress) makes some opening remarks. Sometimes others (e.g. local leaders) will address the audience, as well. The main part of a town hall meeting tends to occur when the floor is opened up to questions and comments from the audience. Attendees generally present ideas, voice their opinions, ask questions of the public figures, elected officials, or political candidates at the town hall. Sometimes, the town hall meeting is televised or recorded. In recent years, town halls held by political candidates have announced and enforced rules on crowd behavior and the scope of questions that may be asked.
If the turnout is large, and if the objective of the particular town hall meeting is to give as many people as possible an opportunity to speak, then the attendees can be broken down into smaller discussion groups. Each smaller group, in that case, appoints someone to summarize discussion of their group.
Some have explored alternative formats for town hall meetings, such as an "electronic town hall." The Congress Foundation commissioned a report on online town hall meetings, which found they grew in size and importance starting in the mid-2000s.
Despite the name town hall, meetings need not take place in a town hall. They commonly take place in a range of venues, including: schools, libraries, municipal buildings, churches, etc. Generally they are held in a public space and there is no charge to attend. In a given district, town hall meetings that are organized by the district's congressional representative are often held in a variety of places across the district.
Other uses of the term
- Town meeting
- Political surgery
- List of significant United States town hall meetings
- Open cabildo
- "Halfway through: ROP's Reflections on Town Hall Madness". Rural Organizing Project. 2009-08-27. Retrieved 2017-02-18.
- Bryan, Frank M. (2003). Real Democracy: The New England Town Meeting and How It Works. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 978-0-226-07796-3. Retrieved 2012-10-25.
- Roberts, Robert North; Hammond, Scott John (2012). Presidential Campaigns, Slogans, Issues, and Platforms (2d ed.). ABC-CLIO. ISBN 978-0-313-38093-8.
- Williamson, Melanie (2010). How to Run for Political Office and Win. Atlantic Publishing Company. pp. 150–151. ISBN 978-1-60138-408-9.
- "Dorchester Atheneum". Dorchester Atheneum. Retrieved 2017-02-18.
- Quick, John; Australia (1919-01-01). The legislative powers of the commonwealth and the states of Australia, with proposed amendments. Melbourne, Vic. : C. F. Maxwell; [etc., etc.]
- "LegiStorm: Congress Revealed". www.legistorm.com.
- Mansky, Jackie. "The History of the Town Hall Debate". Smithsonian. Retrieved 2017-02-18.
- Maggs, John (2004). "The Format That Saved Clinton". National Journal: 2996.
- "Theatre in the round".
- NixonWhiteHouseTapes (9 July 2011). "Man in the Arena Part 1" – via YouTube.
- "Roger Ailes, Nixon's Television Man » Richard Nixon Foundation". 2017-05-18.
- "Roger Ailes".
- Walsh, Edward. "The Making of a Presidential Trip". Washington Post. Retrieved 2017-09-03.
- Hart, Roderick P.; Sparrow, Bartholomew H. (2001-01-01). Politics, Discourse, and American Society: New Agendas. Rowman & Littlefield. ISBN 978-0-7425-0071-6.
- Kaplan, Thomas (2017-02-13). "Angry Town Hall Meetings on Health Care Law, and Few Answers". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2017-02-18.
- "The Tea Party at the Election" (PDF). Cite journal requires
- "Twitter Town Hall Tips from the VA". DigitalGov. 2015-12-18. Retrieved 2017-02-23.
- "Twitter Chat Guidance for Federal Agencies". DigitalGov. 2013-10-16. Retrieved 2017-02-23.
- "Protesters will hold town hall meeting for Gardner, but he'll be absent". Colorado Springs Gazette. Retrieved 2017-02-21.
- Moran, Jay. "Rally seeks town hall meeting with Collins". Retrieved 2017-02-21.
- "Voters Shame Cowardly Reps with Town Halls Hosted by Cardboard Cut-Outs". Common Dreams. Retrieved 2017-02-21.
- "'Missing' Stickers Placed on Milk Cartons After Lawmaker Dodges Town Halls". www.mediaite.com. Retrieved 2017-02-21.
- Indivisible Martin (2017-02-18), Dear Brian Mast – from the People of Martin County, retrieved 2017-02-21
- "Constituents host 'Texas Town Hall without Ted Cruz'". Houston Chronicle. Retrieved 2017-02-21.
- TEGNA. "Cory Gardner's Cory Gardner-less town hall". KUSA. Retrieved 2017-02-21.
- Forest, Pierre-Gerlier; Marchildon, Gregory P.; Mclntosh, Tom, eds. (2004-01-01). Changing Health Care in Canada: The Romanow Papers, Volume 2. University of Toronto Press. doi:10.3138/9781442672833. ISBN 978-0-8020-8618-1. JSTOR 10.3138/9781442672833.
- Ward, Ian (1995). "Bringing the voters back in: A Canadian model for Australia?". Australian Studies of Journalism. 4: 29–49.
- "New England Town Hall Meetings".
- Etzioni, Amitai (1972). "Minerva: An electronic town hall". Policy Sciences. 3 (4): 457–474. doi:10.1007/BF01405348. S2CID 154572096.
- Online Town Hall Meetings – Exploring Democracy in the 21st Century. Congress Foundation.
- Example: It's Time for A Town Hall Meeting, All Business.