1982–1989

1990–1999

2000–2009

2010 team

See footnotes^[5][6][7]

• Coach of the Year: Lance Pogue (South Panola High School, Batesville, Mississippi)^[5]
• Super 25's Top Team: South Panola High School, Batesville, Mississippi^[8]
• Final Super 25 Team Rankings^[9]
• Regional Rankings (top 10 in each region: East, South, Midwest, West)^[10]

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2011 team

See footnotes^[11]

• Coach of the Year: Bob Beatty (Trinity High School, Louisville, Kentucky)
• Super 25's Top Team: Don Bosco Preparatory High School, Ramsey, New Jersey^[12]

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2012 team

See footnotes^[13]

• Coach of the Year: J. T. Curtis (John Curtis Christian High School, River Ridge, Louisiana)
• Super 25's Top Team: John Curtis Christian High School, River Ridge, Louisiana^[14]

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ and ^‡‡ denotes high school juniors and sophomores, respectively

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2013 team

See footnotes^[15]

• Coach of the Year: Al Fracassa (Brother Rice High School, Bloomfield Hills, Michigan)
• Super 25's Top Team: Booker T. Washington High School, Miami, Florida^[16]

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2014 team

See footnotes^[17][18]

• Coach of the Year: Tony Sanchez (Bishop Gorman High School, Las Vegas, Nevada)
• Super 25's Top Team: Bishop Gorman High School, Las Vegas, Nevada^[19]

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2015 team

See footnotes^[20][21]

• Coach of the Year: Matt Logan (Centennial High School, Corona, California)
• Super 25's Top Team: Bishop Gorman High School, Las Vegas, Nevada^[19]

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2016 team

See footnotes^[22]

• Coach of the Year: Kevin Kelley (Pulaski Academy, Little Rock, Arkansas)

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2017 team

See footnotes^[23][24]

• Coach of the Year: Bruce Rollinson (Mater Dei High School, Santa Ana, California)

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2018 team

See footnotes^[25][26]

• Coach of the Year: Randy Trivers (Gonzaga College High School, Washington, D.C.)

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense

2019 team

See footnotes^[27][28]

^{[29] [30]}

• Coach of the Year: Reginald Samples (Duncanville High School, Duncanville, Texas)

Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ^‡ denotes high school juniors

First Team Offense

First Team Defense

Second Team Offense

Second Team Defense