Formation and debut album

Material for Augustines' debut album originated when, with Pela, McCarthy wrote dozens of songs^[7] and Sanderson contributed many demos of his own. The band had close to 40 songs to pick from.^[7] Even though the album was nearly complete, they were unhappy with the results and wanted to re-record the material. "We had to do it twice because it just wasn’t strong," Sanderson said. Throughout the recording (and re-recording) process, the band fought with its record label, its manager and amongst themselves.^[1] Soon after, McCarthy learned his brother James had committed suicide. With all the issues surrounding the band, "Pela was unable to survive the storm," Sanderson said.^[8]

After deciding to part ways with the other two members of Pela, McCarthy and Sanderson eventually decided to finish the album. Having been through a terrible experience with the music labels and industry, "We knew that we wanted to proceed independently, but actually taking that on was a whole other challenge."^[8] With support from the indie music community, specifically John Richards of KEXP,^[1] they were able to finish the record. The album was produced by David Newfeld, who is best known for his work with Broken Social Scene.^[9] Their first performance of the new material, still under the original name Augustines, was for Richards and KEXP at the Cutting Room Studios on October 18, 2010.^[4] They released Rise Ye Sunken Ships independently on June 6, 2011 as a digital-only copy on iTunes.

Prior to the release of their first album, the band announced that Rob Allen had joined the band as the full-time drummer.^[10]

Rise Ye Sunken Ships (2011)

Rise Ye Sunken Ships was released in CD format in North America, Australia, and New Zealand on August 23, 2011. The album was released worldwide on March 5, 2012. The band then began a UK tour in support of the album in October 2011.

The album has been received positively by critics with The Sun and Music Fix naming the first single released in the UK, "Book of James", their single of the week.^[11]

The album covers a lot of very difficult subjects, the most prominent of these subjects are the untimely deaths of McCarthy's mother and brother. Rob Allen, the band's drummer, states that while there is a heavy focus on the painful subjects throughout the album the band also has a deep sense of positivity and hope. "The songs are about topics that happened over a period of time. They have a lot of meaning to us, especially Bill and that won't change, but, if anything, we are living proof that things can get better, opportunities can come your way and that is worth celebrating! We are jovial, energetic people who want to enjoy life and I think that's what you see when we perform."^[12] The band traveled extensively in the British Isles and Europe in support of the album, performing at festivals such as Pukkelpop, Reading & Leeds and large venues such as Shepherd's Bush. In 2014, the band toured the U.S. supporting Frightened Rabbit.

In June 2011, the music video for "Chapel Song" won the title of best music video at the Los Angeles Art-House film festival.^[13]

In March 2012 the band recorded a session at Abbey Road Studios^[14]

The band released the video for the third single to be taken from Rise Ye Sunken Ships, "Juarez", on April 11, 2012.

Augustines (2014)

In late 2013, the band spent several weeks in the studio of producer Peter Katis (Frightened Rabbit, We Were Promised Jetpacks, Jónsi Birgisson) working on their self-titled second album, Augustines. Upon completion of the album (released in early 2014) the band embarked on their first headlining U.S. tour, selling out most shows well in advance. Augustines returned to the UK in early April, and spent a great deal of the summer doing European festivals. After further US dates in the autumn, they returned to Europe. The band finished the year with a triumphant gig in front of 3000 at the London Roundhouse. This was filmed for use in a documentary about the band called Rise.

In August 2015, the band completed a UK/Europe tour and began work on their third album.

This Is Your Life and break up (2016)

Augustines released their third album, This Is Your Life on June 10.

It was announced on September 6 that their upcoming shows later in the year would be their last due to financial constraints.

Augustines played their final show on October 31, 2016 at the O2 Academy in Liverpool. They ended with 'Cruel City', from their second album. The entire show was broadcast via Facebook Live.

Post-Augustines

In 2017, McCarthy released his first solo album, Shelter. Produced by Sanderson, the album featured input from Allen, Pela drummer Tomislav Zovich, and Augustines regular Yannis Panos.

Sanderson also released his own solo project in 2017, Audio Journal Vol. 1: Bringing the Past to Light.

McCarthy is planning to release his second studio album in 2019.