• 1 – G Charlie Hodge
• 2 – D Jacques Laperriere
• 3 – D J. C. Tremblay
• 4 – C Jean Beliveau
• 6 – C Ralph Backstrom
• 8 – LW Dick Duff
• 10 – D Ted Harris
• 11 – RW Claude Larose
• 14 – RW Claude Provost
• 14 – RW Bobby Rousseau
• 16 – C Henri Richard
• 17 – D Jean-Guy Talbot
• 18 – LW Andre Boudrias
• 19 – D Terry Harper
• 20 – LW Dave Balon
• 21 – LW Gilles Tremblay
• 22 – LW John Ferguson
• 24 – C Red Berenson
• 26 – RW Jim Roberts
• 30 – G Gump Worsley

Note: Laperriere and Provost were members of the 1964–65 First All-Star team.

• 7 – LW Bobby Hull (Chicago Black Hawks)
• 8 – C Norm Ullman (Detroit Red Wings)
• 18 – D Pierre Pilote (Chicago Black Hawks)

Second All-Star Team:

• 4 – D Bill Gadsby (Detroit Red Wings)
• 9 – RW Gordie Howe (Detroit Red Wings)
• 22 – LW Frank Mahovlich (Toronto Maple Leafs)

Other players:

• 2 – D Bobby Baun (Toronto Maple Leafs)
• 3 – D Harry Howell (New York Rangers)
• 5 – D Marcel Pronovost (Detroit Red Wings)
• 6 – D Ted Green (Boston Bruins)
• 10 – C Alex Delvecchio (Detroit Red Wings)
• 11 – RW Ron Ellis (Toronto Maple Leafs)
• 12 – LW Vic Hadfield (New York Rangers)
• 14 – D Doug Mohns (Chicago Black Hawks)
• 15 – RW Rod Gilbert (New York Rangers)
• 16 – C Murray Oliver (Boston Bruins)
• 21 – LW Johnny Bucyk (Boston Bruins)
• 23 – RW Eric Nesterenko (Chicago Black Hawks)
• 24 – G Glenn Hall (Chicago Black Hawks)