British Empire Medal

In 1967, Eist, then a sergeant based in Cheshunt, was awarded the British Empire Medal for bravery in single-handedly disarming an armed suspect.^[5] On 14 February that year, The London Gazette reported that following a series of reported robberies, the suspect's car was spotted, with Eist being one of a number of officers called in to provide backup. A man with a rifle was observed in the property's basement, subsequently escaping into the back garden, where he proceeded to sit on a wall and threaten to shoot the officers if they approached.

Eist recognised the man as an escaped prisoner who, according to the Gazette, was known for being criminal. The man jumped into an adjacent garden, continuing to threaten the policemen, who in return threw flowerpots at him. Cornered at the end of the garden, the man pointed his rifle at each of the officers and threatened to fire if they approached; despite this, both Eist and a colleague tackled the man and disarmed him. The rifle was found to be loaded with three .22-calibre bullets with a fourth in the breech.^[6]

Involvement in the investigation into the assassination of Martin Luther King

In May 1968, following his assassination of Martin Luther King, James Earl Ray fled to London. On 8 June Ray was arrested at London Heathrow Airport attempting to leave for Brussels on a false Canadian passport.^[16] Ray was placed in the personal custody of Eist,^[15] first being held at Canon Row Police Station and then in Wandsworth Prison. Eist spent the first nine hours of Ray's custody with him in Canon Row, and whenever Ray was taken to the Old Bailey, they were handcuffed together.^[17] Eist later recalled how, "initially, [Ray] didn't want to say anything to anybody", merely glaring at Eist. Eist thought that, probably because of their constant contact, Ray "began to look on me as somebody he could talk to". Eist helped Ray acclimatise to the British prison service, for example, by arranging for him to receive cutlery—which had initially been withheld in his custody for fear of suicide—and bringing him magazines. Ray's later biographer, Gerald Posner, believes that, on account of these niceties, "slowly the two developed a rapport, rare for Ray with anyone". Eist later recalled that, even so, Ray would not respond to specific questions, preferring to talk in generalities.^[18] When Eist told Ray that the death of King had made little impact in Britain, Ray's response, said Eist, was "you haven't seen anything yet".^[19]

Throughout Ray's subsequent extradition, trial and sentencing, US authorities were unaware of Eist's involvement with Ray. Eist had discussed it with various colleagues and companions over the years, but it was not until 1976 he met a USAF officer then resident in London; Eist mentioned his association with Ray, and the officer advised him to contact the FBI. By then, there was a new investigation into the association planned by Congress.^[20]

Informants and accusations of corruption

Eist made liberal use of informants within the criminal community. Among his informers, he counted men such as Roy Garner, who was later convicted of smuggling cocaine,^[11] and became both a supergrass^{[note 4]} and a millionaire.^[29] Eist tried to avoid making appearances in court wherever possible but would ensure that reward payments always included his informant's 10%. He often attended to it personally, although Kirby describes it as "questionable if the fee in its entirety was handed over to the snout".^[30] However, his reluctance to attend court was viewed dimly by several colleagues. Morton reports an ex-Flying Squad officer as telling him that Eist:^[31]

Was no scriptwriter. He hadn't the intelligence, nor would he go to court on a job. He had no bottle. The only time he went he had a bad time ... Instead he'd get a job, stick it up [to his colleagues] and make sure he wasn't there.^[31]

Eist has been described as either "the most corrupt or the best informed" Scotland Yard detective of his generation, argues the investigative journalist Martin Fido, noting how Eist "reputedly offered a sliding tariff of payments".^{[note 5]} These payments would be in return for him dropping or otherwise failing investigations (although drawing the line, says Fido, at murder and rape).^[34] Journalist Paul Lashmar has described Eist as "by reputation the most corrupt Yard officer of the 1950s to mid-1970s which was no small achievement in such a packed field".^[35] Writer James Morton interviewed a Detetective Sergeant who told him that, notwithstanding that he had a second-to-none knowledge of the criminal scene and its players, Eist would have been unable to "get information without going some way towards them. There is no villain in London who will not give you information if you go about it the right way".^{[36][note 6]} A former colleague of Eist's described Eist's strategy being to effectively self-fund his informers, stating that "if he got £200 from a villain for giving him bail, Eist would give £195 to cultivate an informant".^[38]

Likewise, crime journalist Duncan Campbell suggests that Eist was "one of the most active bent officers" of the period.^[39] Kirby also suggests that "Eist's probity was also questionable", and describes occasions on which individuals were arrested for crimes that his informers had committed.^[8] Reg Dudley – a North London "career criminal"^[39] who was wrongfully convicted of double murder in 1977 – was a fence during the 1960s and had, he wrote, a "close relationship" with Eist, whom he calls "bent". Dudley asserts that "for a few grand channelled through [Dudley], Alec would do what he could to make evidence 'disappear'".^[40] Kirby asserts that Eist was close enough to Dudley and other villains of the day to socialise with. He notes a contemporary of Eist's at Holloway saying that an "obvious...surveillance photo" existed of various London gangsters on a cruise ship, where "skulking in the shadows one could see the unmistakable features of Alec Eist".^[14] Eist has also been alleged to have had links to the perpetrators of the Baker Street robbery, obstructed some of the prosecutions, and later been paid off^[35] with jewellery from the robbery's proceeds.^[41]

Accusations of corruption also bogged down Eist's appearance before the HSCA. His evidence was questioned by Ray's defence attorney Mark Lane. Lane told the committee that Eist had been "dismissed in disgrace" from Scotland Yard, and cited charges of corruption, perjury and robbery: "if you knew of this man's background, you have done a disservice to the American people by raising the charges" he argued, and considered that accepting Eist's evidence at face value amounted to "perhaps the most outrageous thing this committee has ever done".

After the hearing, Lane told journalists that, although he only knew what he did from a British lawyer to whom he had spoken on the phone, the lawyer believed Eist "was possibly the most corrupt man in the modern history of Scotland Yard".^[15] Eist rejected Lane's assertions, describing them as "absolutely untrue".^[42] Contemporaneous news reports describe the House Committee as being divided on whether to accept Eist's evidence.^[25]

So far as I am concerned I cannot understand how a so-called qualified lawyer could come out with such a statement without at least checking the facts. Even in American law there must be some recourse to action. What he said is absolutely untrue and I am suffering because of it.^[42]

— Alec Eist, 19 August 1978, The Washington Post

Eist said, "I live in a very small village and this is crucifying me". He suggested that Lane's allegations were a defence strategy to shift culpability for King's assassination onto the FBI, who, Eist said, "could not have acted more honourably to get that man brought to justice" and that "absolutely no way" had they been involved.^[42]

However, although Lane accused Eist of having stood trial for bribery and having been suspected of involvement in jewel robberies across England, Eist was only ever charged on one count involving a false alibi and perverting the course of justice. This charge had been dropped as the name of the arresting officer had been mistaken as Eist,^[43] and the judge – instructing the jury to bring in a verdict of not guilty – said "I have come to the conclusion that there is no evidence to link him with any of the counts in which his name appears".^[42] He was released immediately and the British government paid for his defence.^[43]

Decorations

Over the course of Eist's 28-year career, he was awarded somewhere between 13^[3][47] and 28 commendations,^{[42][note 9]} one of which was for his work on the Baker Street case.^[47] In 2002, three of Eist's medals – the BEM, his War Medal 1939–1945 and the Police Exemplary Service Medal – were auctioned in London. Estimated at between £300 and £400, they sold for £1200, (now £2077).^[3]

Posthumous allegations

Allegations of corruption continued to emerge after Eist's death. In a May 1982 investigation by The Observer, the paper cited the 1970s gangster Joe Cannon as having "significant evidence" against Eist, who Cannon also accused of personally robbing him of £200 in cash.^[54] Freddie Foreman later suggested that Eist "used to invite villains to his promotion parties" in hotels such as the Dorchester, where Eist would warn the attendees of any approaching police attention that he was aware of, Foreman claimed.^[32] Criminals involved in such high-profile raids as the 1980 silver bullion heist also made allegations against Eist. One, Michael Gervaise, made the "startling allegation" to a court in 1982 Eist was one of several high-ranking police officers bribed and who had "actively participated in robberies as part of [Gervais'] gang".^[55] Freddie Foreman, recalling how Eist persuaded Foreman and his gang against carrying out an armed robbery, said in his view Eist could^[12]

Make a right pest of himself when he was drunk. But he was as much a crook as any of us and quite capable of doing anything. It was much easier to hold your hand out for a few bob than to have a shoot-out, and he was a pragmatist. He had his ear to the ground and knew who was who on the London scene. Often he worked undercover and posed as a crook. He was a right rascal, but you could live with him. At the same time, he also nicked a lot of people. He’d nick you as quick as look at you if it was safe to do so. But he was very good with us. If anyone was in trouble he’d work a bit of bail and try and help us in court.^[12]

Conversely, Pettifor and Sommerland cite one of their sources as arguing that "Eist was a complete scoundrel but in those days you wouldn’t last in the CID if you wasn’t crooked, they had no straight runners around there".^[47] They also reported that on one occasion Eist auctioned procceds^[47] from the 1975 robbery of the Bank of America, Mayfair,^[56] in the basement of Paddington Green Police Station.^[47]