Football

After going unselected in the 1940 NFL Draft, Turley was signed as an undrafted free agent by the Pittsburgh Steelers.^[17] They had received suggestions to do so from Turley's Scranton coach Tom Davies, as well as from coaches who had opposed him, including Red Edwards (Saint Vincent) and Joe Bach (Niagara).^[17] He was released by the Steelers on September 9.^[18] Turley signed with the Philadelphia Eagles on July 17, 1941, but was released on September 3.^[18] Afterwards, he joined the minor league Wilmington Clippers of the American Association (AA), playing all nine games, five as a starter, while helping them win their only league championship.^[1][19] Wilmington became an independent team in 1942, due to the AA suspending as a result of World War II, and were considered the best pro football team outside of the NFL.^[19][20] Turley appeared in all nine games, eight as a starter, for the 1942 Clippers, contributing to their 8–1 record that included wins of over 28 points in all but the season finale, when they tied the Philadelphia Eagles 21–21.^[21]

Turley sat out the 1943 season as the Clippers also suspended due to the war.^[20][22] He was head coach of the semi-professional Wilmington Arrows during the year.^[23] The NFL held what was described as a "peculiar 'hat trick' drafting scheme" in 1944 in which former American Association players were picked, and Turley ended up being sent to the Washington Redskins.^[24][25][26] He signed with them at the start of July and ended up making the final roster.^[27][28] Turley appeared in a total of seven games on the year, posting eight receptions for 112 yards with one touchdown.^[29] His one score came in a 42–20 win over Card-Pitt and was a 35-yard pass thrown by Sammy Baugh, which would be the longest play of Turley's career.^[29][30]

Turley had his best season in 1945, helping the Redskins reach the NFL Championship Game while totaling 17 catches for 185 yards and one score in 10 games, eight of which he started.^[29][31] He later recalled the championship in an interview with The News Journal's Matt Zabitka:

We played that game [won by the Rams 15–14] in subzero weather. It was 4-below zero. The field was frozen. It was so cold, the bands couldn't play. Their instruments were frozen. And, in those days, they had cameras with oil in them, and they became inoperable. Never forget that one. I played all but 30 seconds of the entire game. That's going both ways, and without all that protective equipment players wear today.^[31]

The Los Angeles Times named Turley Washington's most outstanding end during the 1945 season and reported that for his "quiet, unassuming way," he was one of the most popular members of the team.^[26] End coach Wayne Millner said that "[Turley's] not spectacular, but he's the most reliable end the Redskins have. He's the one guy certain of making the club. I want to see the rest under fire before passing judgement on them."^[32] He played nine games in the 1946 season, four as a starter, and had six catches for 105 yards with no scores.^[29]

Turley was pursued by the Wilmington Clippers (having returned to the AA from their suspension) and a team in the All-America Football Conference (AAFC) in 1947, but ultimately remained with Washington.^[29][33] He played 12 games in the 1947 season, three as a starter, and caught six passes for 95 yards and one touchdown.^[29] He played his final season with Washington in 1948, playing 12 games, four as a starter, and making eight catches for 111 yards.^[29] He additionally scored a touchdown off a 33-yard fumble return.^[29]

Turley left the Redskins in 1949 to accept a position as player-coach with the Wilmington Clippers.^[34][35] He became the fifth head coach in the team's history (preceded by Dutch Slagle, Walt Masters, George Veneroso and Les Dodson).^[34] Bob Hainlen was announced as an assistant coach and the team began the season with an exhibition on September 1.^[36] The Clippers lost their first exhibition to the Hawaiian Warriors, 21–0, before winning their second against the Erie Vets, 21–20.^[37] Wilmington opened the regular season with a 38–0 loss to the Richmond Rebels and then defeated the Jersey City Giants 6–0.^[37] The Clippers lost their third game, against the Paterson Panthers, by a score of 27–0, after which the team president made a stunning and unprecedented move to demote Turley to being an assistant and replace him with Larry Weldon.^[37][38] He quit the team the day afterwards, subsequently joining the Bethlehem Bulldogs in a playing role.^[39] Weldon made his coaching debut against Bethlehem on the day of Turley's signing, and the Bulldogs defeated the Clippers by a score of 22–7.^[40] With Bethlehem, Turley was switched from being an end to a tackle.^[41] He appeared in five games for the Bulldogs, three as a starter, before retiring.^[1] He finished his career with 50 games in the NFL, 19 as a starter, and 45 catches for 608 yards and four total touchdowns, along with 23 games played in minor leagues with Wilmington and Bethlehem.^[1]

Basketball and baseball

Turley also played several seasons of semi-professional basketball and baseball as well as some professional basketball.^[42] In the 1941–42 season, he was a member of both the Pusey & Jones basketball team with several Clippers teammates, as well as St. Nicholas' in the C. Y. O. Basketball League.^[43][44] In 1943, he played baseball for Pusey & Jones.^[45] Turley played basketball in the C. Y. O. League with Sacred Heart at the start of the 1943–44 season, before later joining St. Ann's.^[46] He was named to the league all-star squad.^[47]

In the 1944–45 season, Turley played for St. Ann's and for the professional Wilmington Blue Bombers of the American Basketball League (ABL).^[42][48] With Wilmington, he appeared in two regular season games and one playoff match, totaling one field goal and one free throw for three points in the regular season, while having two points off of a field goal in the playoffs.^[42] In the 1945–46 season, Turley played with a team in Nanticoke, scoring 70 total points on 16 free throws and 27 field goals while playing 17 games.^[42] In 1946–47, he played for a team known as the Washington Redskins, partly made up of players from the football team.^[49] He joined the Sunbury Mercuries in 1947–48.^[50]