In 2012, just before moving to Brighton, Keeler-Schaffeler signed to Critical Heights (sister label of Fire Records), where she released three singles and a self-titled LP. She left the label in 2015, choosing to self-release and work with independent labels. Her second album, With Kindness was released on 7 June 2019 on Tim Burgess's record label O Genesis Recordings.[3]
During the COVID-19 lockdown, Keeler-Schaffeler worked on a project called Lean Logic with Nick Carlisle. They released their first album, The Last Mirage, digitally on 28 May 2021 with O Genesis Recordings.[4]
Keeler-Schaffeler sang on Tim Burgess's solo album I Love the New Sky and featured in the official video of single "The Mall". She was part of his touring band, visiting the US in March 2020, but their tour was curtailed by the COVID-19 pandemic. They toured in the UK during 2021 and 2022. Keeler-Schaffeler sang on Burgess's subsequent album Typical Music, and featured in the official video of "Here Comes the Weekend".
Since 2022, Keeler-Schaffeler has been recording her third solo album with producer Daniel O'Sullivan and engineer Thighpaulsandra. They have also performed as a trio under the name BUNNY.
Keeler-Schaffeler also hosts a monthly music radio show on NTS called Keel Her.[5]