Naming_(parliamentary_procedure)

Naming (parliamentary procedure)

Naming (parliamentary procedure)

Temporary removal of a disruptive member in Westminster-style parliaments


Naming is a procedure in some Westminster model parliaments that provides for the speaker to temporarily remove a member of parliament who is breaking the rules of conduct of the legislature. Historically, "naming" refers to the speaker's invocation of the process by calling out the actual name of the member, deliberately breaking the convention of calling on members by the name of their constituency.

Processes to name a member are present in the lower houses of the British, Australian, Canadian, and New Zealand parliaments, and the legislatures of some Australian states and Canadian provinces. The implementation of the procedure varies by parliament, but usually requires the speaker to name a member, and then await another member to move that the offending member be disciplined according to the appropriate rules of order.

Process

Speaker's procession in 1884

In the British House of Commons, the Speaker or one of his or her deputies can initiate the process by proposing a vote on the suspension of a member of the House if the speaker believes that the member has broken the rules of conduct of the House. Usually this is only done if the member has already been ordered to leave the House (which automatically leads to suspension for the remainder of that day) and refused to do so, or has committed a serious breach of conduct, and carries a suspension of up to five days and the loss of the member's salary during that period.

The procedure to name members is under Standing Order 44. Members can be suspended for the remainder of the day under Standing Order 43 (previously numbered as Standing Order 42). The Speaker or Deputy Speaker declares "I name", followed by the name of the member; and invites the Leader of the House or their deputy to move the motion that the member be removed, and then puts the question:

The question is that the honourable member be suspended from the services of the House. As many as are of that opinion say 'Aye', of the contrary 'No'.

A division is not normally required since MPs will usually back the speaker's judgement. However, when John McDonnell was named by deputy speaker Alan Haselhurst on 15 January 2009 for disturbing the mace, a division was called because George Galloway and other members declared themselves with the Noes. A vote on the suspension was not held as no MPs were willing to act as tellers for the Noes.[1]

In the Australian House of Representatives, the procedure to name members is under Standing Order 94. Under Standing Order 94a, the Speaker can order the immediate removal of a member for one hour, which is not open to a division. If a member is named under Standing Order 94b, the removal is dependent on a vote. If a member is named, the Speaker declares, "I name", followed by the Electoral Division of the member, and then the Leader of the House moves the question:

That the member for (division) be suspended from the service of the House.

If the vote passes by a simple majority, then the member is required to leave the house for 24 hours, with more severe penalities if the member has been named beforehand in the same calendar year.

In the House of Commons of Canada, the Speaker's authority to remove members is listed under Standing Order 11. A member named by the Speaker is required to leave the House immediately and prohibited from returning for the remainder of the day's sitting. Alternatively, the Speaker may suggest to the House the removal of a member for a specific period of time, which requires a motion to receive a majority vote on the House floor.[2] Although the removal of members was increasingly common through the 20th century, usage of the procedure has since declined, having only been used four times since 2000. The order to remove a member generally requires an act of defiance against the Speaker, as the removal of a member is usually justified by the generic reasoning that the member is "disregarding the authority of the Chair".

The procedure has also been used once in the Massachusetts Senate. On October 27, 1981, Senate President William M. Bulger named Senator Alan Sisitsky after Sisitsky continuously disrupted the Senate proceedings. Sisitsky was then removed from the Senate Chamber by a court officer.[3] The matter was referred to the Senate Ethics Committee, which recommended that Sisitsky be suspended indefinitely until he issued a formal apology to the Senate.[4]

Lists of namings

House of Commons (United Kingdom)

More information Date, Speaker ...

Canada

House of Commons

More information Date, Speaker ...

Senate

More information Date, Speaker ...

Australia

House of Representatives

This list contains instances that a member has been named during Questions without notice in the Australian House of Representatives.

More information Date, Speaker ...

New Zealand

House of Representatives

More information Date, Speaker ...

Legislative Council

More information Date, Speaker ...

Massachusetts General Court

House of Representatives

More information Date, Speaker ...

Senate

More information Date, President ...

See also


Notes and references

  1. "Transport Infrastructure". House of Commons Hansard. UK Parliament. 15 January 2009. Vol.486 Pt.14 c.367. Retrieved 2 February 2017.; "MP suspended after mace protest". BBC. 15 January 2009. Retrieved 2 February 2017.; Sparrow, Andrew (15 January 2009). "Labour MP suspended from Commons over Heathrow protest". The Guardian. London, UK. Retrieved 2 February 2017.
  2. House of Commons of Canada. "Chapter 1 Standing Orders - House of Commons". House of Commons of Canada. Parliament of Canada. Retrieved 5 February 2018.
  3. Kenney, Charles (27 October 1981). "Bulger expels Sisitsky from state Senate". The Boston Globe.
  4. Collins, Laurence (3 November 1981). "Sisitsky files suit to regain seat". The Boston Globe.
  5. Conybeare withdrew his comment but it was not heard by the Speaker before he was named.
  6. "Textile Industry - Hansard - UK Parliament". Hansard. 26 March 1952. Retrieved 12 March 2023.
  7. Westminster, Department of the Official Report (Hansard), House of Commons. "House of Commons Hansard Debates for 8 Dec 2005 (pt 4)".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  8. On both occasions of Dennis Skinner having been named, he left before a division was put before the House. After the first occasion Mike Penning requested that the division go ahead, but Michael Martin deemed that Skinner's ejection from the House was sufficient punishment.
  9. Westminster, Department of the Official Report (Hansard), House of Commons. "House of Commons Hansard Debates for 20 Apr 2006 (pt 5)".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  10. "YouTube". YouTube. Archived from the original on 6 July 2009.
  11. "After Recess". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 16 March 1913. col. 6019.
  12. "War Appropriation". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 24 March 1942.
  13. "The Budget". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 4 July 1944.
  14. "Family Allowances". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 31 July 1944.
  15. "After Recess". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 25 May 1956.
  16. "Pension Act". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 10 February 1961.
  17. "Immigration". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 16 March 1962.
  18. "Withdrawal of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 5 October 1962.
  19. "Canadian Broadcasting Corporation". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 19 June 1964.
  20. "Alleged Injustice to Quebeckers Respecting Sales Tax". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 16 May 1978.
  21. "Delay in Answering Order Paper Questions". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 21 March 1979.
  22. "Resolution respecting Constitution Act, 1981". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 23 February 1981.
  23. "Mr. Cossitt - Reply of Mr. Cosgrove alleged misleading". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 3 December 1981.
  24. "Mr. Crosbie - Alleged misleading statement by Mr. Chretien". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 19 May 1982.
  25. "Unparliamentary Remark of Mr. Robinson (Burnaby)". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 16 June 1982.
  26. "Amendments to Statute Law". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 24 March 1983.
  27. "Mr. Broadbent - Statement of Mr. Trudeau during question period". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 20 May 1983.
  28. "Notice of allocation of time to consider report and third reading stages of Bill C-155". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 19 October 1983.
  29. "Western Grain Transportation Act". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 31 October 1983.
  30. "Nuclear Weapons Free Zone Act". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 25 May 1984.
  31. "Youth Unemployment". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 8 June 1984.
  32. "Request for Withdrawal". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 17 December 1984.
  33. "Universality of Social Programs - Senior Citizens". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 19 December 1984.
  34. "Changes to Old Age Security Act". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 22 May 1985.
  35. "Election Campaign Commitment". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 19 June 1985.
  36. "Pensions - Statement by Minister of Finance". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 27 June 1985.
  37. "Use of Government Aircraft". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 11 October 1985.
  38. "Chemical Weapons Inquiry". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 24 February 1986.
  39. "Prime Minister's forthcoming visit to South Korea". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 23 April 1986.
  40. "Challenge '86 Employment Funding for Non-Profit Community Projects". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 21 May 1986.
  41. "Proceedings at Meeting with Business and Union Representatives". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 28 May 1986.
  42. "Alleged racial slur". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 11 June 1986.
  43. "Fisheries". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 24 March 1993.
  44. "1992 Referendum". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 30 September 1994.
  45. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 29 May 1995.
  46. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 2 November 1995.
  47. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 24 April 1996.
  48. "Somalia Inquiry". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 12 February 1997.
  49. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 1 October 1997.
  50. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 1 December 1998.
  51. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 15 February 2000.
  52. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 5 April 2000.
  53. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 6 December 2002.
  54. "Naming of Member". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: House of Commons. 30 November 2017.
  55. "Senate votes to suspend Andrew Thompson". CBC News. 13 November 1998. Retrieved 5 February 2018.
  56. MacKinnon, Leslie (5 November 2013). "Senate votes to suspend Brazeau, Duffy, Wallin". CBC News. Retrieved 5 February 2018.
  57. "House Hansard, 14 May 1964". Parliament of Australia.
  58. "House Hansard, 29 March 1966". Parliament of Australia.
  59. "House Hansard, 27 September 1966". Parliament of Australia.
  60. "House Hansard, 28 September 1966". Parliament of Australia.
  61. "House Hansard, 14 October 1966". Parliament of Australia.
  62. "House Hansard, 3 October 1967". Parliament of Australia.
  63. "House Hansard, 28 October 1970". Parliament of Australia.
  64. "House Hansard, 20 April 1971". Parliament of Australia.
  65. "House Hansard, 5 April 1973". Parliament of Australia.
  66. "House Hansard, 5 April 1973". Parliament of Australia.
  67. "House Hansard, 17 September 1974". Parliament of Australia.
  68. "House Hansard, 25 February 1975". Parliament of Australia.
  69. "House Hansard, 5 June 1975". Parliament of Australia.
  70. "House Hansard, 9 October 1975". Parliament of Australia.
  71. "House Hansard, 18 November 1976". Parliament of Australia.
  72. "House Hansard, 23 April 1980". Parliament of Australia.
  73. "House Hansard, 18 September 1980". Parliament of Australia.
  74. "House Hansard, 27 August 1981". Parliament of Australia.
  75. "House Hansard, 6 May 1982". Parliament of Australia.
  76. "House Hansard, 7 September 1982". Parliament of Australia.
  77. "House Hansard, 12 October 1983". Parliament of Australia.
  78. "House Hansard, 16 November 1983". Parliament of Australia.
  79. "House Hansard, 29 May 1984". Parliament of Australia.
  80. "House Hansard, 28 March 1985". Parliament of Australia.
  81. "ParlInfo - QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE : TRADE WITH CHINA". parlinfo.aph.gov.au. Retrieved 15 April 2019.
  82. "ParlInfo - QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE : Privatisation: Policies". parlinfo.aph.gov.au. Retrieved 15 April 2019.
  83. "ParlInfo - Title Unavailable". parlinfo.aph.gov.au. Retrieved 15 April 2019.
  84. "Official Hansard". 18 July 2019. Archived from the original on 18 July 2019. Retrieved 27 September 2019.
  85. "Speaker Bronwyn Bishop has compiled quite a record". NewsComAu. 11 February 2015. Retrieved 27 September 2019.
  86. Medhora, Shalailah (25 March 2015). "Liberal Andrew Laming banned from chamber for pouring oil on hands". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 27 September 2019.
  87. Hansard. Vol. 58. New Zealand Parliament. 1887. p. 379.
  88. Hansard. Vol. 105. New Zealand Parliament. 1898. p. 525.
  89. Hansard. Vol. 115. New Zealand Parliament. 1900. pp. 153–162.
  90. Hansard. Vol. 168. New Zealand Parliament. 1914. pp. 329–338.
  91. Hansard. Vol. 171. New Zealand Parliament. 1914. pp. 754–757.
  92. Hansard. Vol. 171. New Zealand Parliament. 1914. p. 892.
  93. Hansard. Vol. 174. New Zealand Parliament. 1915. pp. 262–267.
  94. Hansard. Vol. 177. New Zealand Parliament. 1916. pp. 168–169.
  95. Hansard. Vol. 192. New Zealand Parliament. 1921. pp. 1013–1014.
  96. Hansard. Vol. 231. New Zealand Parliament. 1932. pp. 534–538.
  97. Hansard. Vol. 298. New Zealand Parliament. 1952. p. 1640.
  98. Hansard. Vol. 317. New Zealand Parliament. 1958. p. 1238.
  99. Hansard. Vol. 466. New Zealand Parliament. 1985. p. 7595.
  100. Hansard. Vol. 475. New Zealand Parliament. 1986. p. 5333.
  101. Hansard. Vol. 469. New Zealand Parliament. 1986. pp. 72–74.
  102. Hansard. Vol. 474. New Zealand Parliament. 1986. p. 4323.
  103. Hansard. Vol. 478. New Zealand Parliament. 1987. p. 7377.
  104. Hansard. Vol. 479. New Zealand Parliament. 1987. p. 8096.
  105. Hansard. Vol. 480. New Zealand Parliament. 1987. p. 9027.
  106. Hansard. Vol. 482. New Zealand Parliament. 1987. pp. 10361–10363.
  107. Hansard. Vol. 520. New Zealand Parliament. 1991. p. 315.
  108. Hansard. Vol. 528. New Zealand Parliament. 1992. p. 436.
  109. Hansard. Vol. 537. New Zealand Parliament. 1993. p. 313.
  110. Hansard. Vol. 542. New Zealand Parliament. 1994. p. 768.
  111. Hansard. Vol. 579. New Zealand Parliament. 1999. p. 1077.
  112. Hansard. Vol. 595. New Zealand Parliament. 2001. p. 890.
  113. Hansard. Vol. 597. New Zealand Parliament. 2001. p. 461.
  114. Hansard. Vol. 599. New Zealand Parliament. 2002. p. 245.
  115. "Volume 608, Week 22 - Thursday, 1 May 2003". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 22 September 2014.
  116. "Volume 608, Week 24 - Wednesday, 14 May 2003 -- Hansard (debates)". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 22 September 2014.
  117. "Volume 609, Week 28 - Tuesday, 24 June 2003 -- Hansard (debates)". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 22 September 2014.
  118. "Volume 609, Week 28 - Thursday, 26 June 2003 -- Hansard (debates)". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 22 September 2014.
  119. "Volume 620, Week 67 - Wednesday, 8 September 2004 -- Hansard (debates)". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 22 September 2014.
  120. "Volume 634, Week 28 - Tuesday, 17 October 2006". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 22 September 2014.
  121. "National MP Nick Smith has been suspended from the House". Stuff. 8 May 2019. Retrieved 8 May 2019.
  122. Hansard. Vol. 119. New Zealand Parliament. 1901. pp. 442–445.
  123. Harris, John G. (10 August 1939). "$22,425,000 in New Taxes Voted". The Boston Daily Globe.
  124. "Rep. Diniz Is 'Named' in House". The Boston Daily Globe. 31 March 1943.
  125. Collins, Laurence (17 November 1981). "Still battling, Sisitsky says he's sorry". The Boston Globe.

Share this article:

This article uses material from the Wikipedia article Naming_(parliamentary_procedure), and is written by contributors. Text is available under a CC BY-SA 4.0 International License; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.