Impeachment

After Wrisley Brown investigated charges that Judge Archbald bought coal lands at cheap prices for his personal benefit from railroads and real estate interests involved in litigation before his federal court, and also took a European trip in 1910 paid for by those frequent litigants, the House Judiciary Committee recommended to the United States House of Representatives that he be impeached. The railroads alleged to be shaken down included the Erie Railroad, Lehigh Valley Railroad and the Reading Railroad.^[3][4]

The United States House of Representatives voted to send 13 articles of impeachment against Archbald to the U.S. Senate, by a vote of 223 to 1 on July 13, 1912; only Scranton's U.S. Congressman, John R. Farr, who sat on the Committee, voted in Archbald's favor. Articles I, II, III and VI alleged that Archbald had entered into agreements with litigants at a substantial benefit to himself, Article IV alleged a wrongful communication with litigants, Articles V, VII, VIII, IX and X alleged that he had improperly solicited and accepted gifts from litigants, Article XI alleged he had improperly solicited and accepted gifts from attorneys, Article XII alleged he allowed corrupt practices during jury selection and Article XIII alleged a general charge of bringing the judiciary into disrepute.

On July 16, 1912, the Senate began Archbald's trial. Judge Archbald took the witness stand in his own defense on January 6, 1913, claiming that the gifts and favorable deals were the result of longstanding friendships, and his wife also testified for the defense. The Senate convicted him of five of the 13 articles on January 13, 1913.

The exact voting division on each article is as follows:

Archbald was convicted on Articles I, III, IV, V and XIII and was accordingly removed from office (Article II gained a majority of votes, but not the two-thirds necessary under the U.S. Constitution to convict), and the Senate subsequently voted, by 39 to 35, to order that Archbald be forever disqualified from holding any office under the United States. Pennsylvania's two Republican Senators, Boies Penrose of Philadelphia, and George T. Oliver of Pittsburgh, had voted against impeachment and lifetime disqualification.^[4]

Despite the outcome, Archbald continued to declare his innocence. "I have always known that I have done no wrong and the vote of no one makes it otherwise," he said before leaving for Scranton with his family. "Judge Archbald came as near being an ideal common pleas judge as one can hope to find," one judicial colleague said upon his death. Lawyers eulogized him as a "discriminating practitioner" whose influence "made a deeper impression than any other judge in the history" of Lackawanna County.^[4]