Stillman College

In the spring of 1999, then 5th president of Stillman College Dr. Ernest McNealey, announced the returned of football after a 50-year hiatus. McNealey announced later in the school year that Theophilus Danzy would be head coach. Danzy, eager to assemble a staff, hired Teddy Keaton as first assistant to the head coach\director of football operations, a job he would maintain for two years while completing his degree. In 2001, Keaton was promoted to special teams coordinator/recruiting coordinator/running backs coach. Under Keaton's coaching, Stillman landed its first-ever 1000-yard rusher, and specials team recorded two consecutive NCAA Division II top 20 finishes, 3rd in blocked punts, and 12th in kick returns, averaging 23.5 yards a return.

Odessa Roughnecks

Following successful seasons at Stillman, Keaton switched sides of the football and was hired as director of player personnel/defensive line coach for the Roughnecks of the NIFL. Keaton had immediate impact, with the defense line averaging 3 sacks per game. Coming off success at the defensive line position, Chris Williams then promoted Keaton to defensive coordinator/director of college scouting. With the promotion in 2005, the Roughnecks recorded its best season by posting undefeated regular season 14-0 and 2-1 playoff record. The defensive team was at the top of all defensive categories in the NIFL.

Lakeland Thounderbolts

In 2005, Keaton acquired his first head coaching position with the Thunderbolts of the AIFA League. In his first season, the Thunderbolts finished 13-2 and 2nd in total overall defense in 2005-2006. In his second season with the Thunderbolts, they finished with an overall record of 14-2, the #1 defense, and a league high 55 interception. The Thunderbolts’ success resulted in 6 players being promoted and recruited to the Arena Football League: Terrence Royal, Tampa Bay Storm; Marvin Brown, Tampa Bay Storm; Robert Branch, New York Dragons; Brenden Givan, Nashville Kats; Othesse Wells, Nashville Kats; Larry Kendrick, Philadelphia Soul. Keaton and the Lakeland Thunderbolts finished the season with a Championship. In 2007, Keaton left the Thunderbolts because the ownership shut the program down.

Huntington Heroes

In 2007, Keaton was hired as head coach of the Huntington Heroes in Huntington, West Virginia. His success continued as the Heroes ranked first place in the Eastern Division and posted a 5-1 record. The Heroes ranked at the top of all categories in Offense and Defense for the AIFA. Keaton left the Heroes midway during the season because of management's lack of support to the team.

Webber International

In 2008, Keaton returned to college coaching as offensive coordinator for Webber. The team's offense improved its ranking from an eight-year stint at 80th to 37th in his first season. Under his leadership, players received all Sun Conference honors. Additionally, Webber had its first player to ever be drafted to the NFL, Vincent Anderson to the New York Giants.

Stillman College

On December 4, 2010, McNealey hired Keaton, 4th coach of the Tigers, since its return of football. In his first season as head coach at Stillman, Keaton posted a 7-4 record, which tied for 1st in the Western Division of the Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SIAC), one loss shy of competing for the Conference Championship. This loss came in the last conference game of the season. During the next three seasons, Stillman posted consecutive 6-5 records. The Tigers accomplished many football honors: ranked 4th in the nation in NCAA Division II total defense, developed a 2-time All American Punter Ronnie Partridge^[4] and graduated eleven Academic All Americans. Following the 2016 season and a change in leadership at Stillman, the President eliminated all intercollegiate sports except men and women basketball.

Allen University

On January 8, 2018, Keaton was named as the head football coach at Allen University.^[5]

NIFL/AIFL

College