Presidential candidates

• Former Governor
  Horatio Seymour
  of New York
• Former Representative George H. Pendleton
  of Ohio
• Senator
  Thomas A. Hendricks
  of Indiana
• Major General
  Winfield Scott Hancock
  of Pennsylvania
• President
  Andrew Johnson
• Former Lt. Governor
  Sanford E. Church
  of New York
• Former Representative Asa Packer
  of Pennsylvania
• Governor
  James E. English
  of Connecticut
• Former Governor
  Joel Parker
  of New Jersey
• Senator
  James Rood Doolittle
  of Wisconsin
• Associate Justice Stephen J. Field
  of California
• Former Representative Francis P. Blair
  of Missouri
• Chief Justice
  Salmon P. Chase
  of Ohio
  (Not Nominated)
• New York City Mayor John T. Hoffman
  of New York

The front-runner in the early balloting was George H. Pendleton, who led on the first 15 ballots, followed in varying order by incumbent president Andrew Johnson, Winfield Scott Hancock, Sanford Church, Asa Packer, Joel Parker, James E. English, James Rood Doolittle, and Thomas A. Hendricks.

Three-fourth of the delegates from southern states gave their support to Johnson.^[6] The unpopular Johnson, having narrowly survived impeachment, won 65 votes on the first ballot; the second-highest number of votes after Pendleton, but less than one-third of the total necessary for nomination, and he thus lost his bid for election as president in his own right. His vote tally rapidly dropped away thereafter, and from the eighth ballot onwards, he would only receive votes from his home state of Tennessee.

Meanwhile, the convention chairman Horatio Seymour, former governor of New York, received 9 votes on the fourth ballot from the state of North Carolina. This unexpected move caused "loud and enthusiastic cheering," but Seymour refused, saying,

I must not be nominated by this Convention, as I could not accept the nomination if tendered. My own inclination prompted me to decline at the outset; my honor compels me to do so now. It is impossible, consistently with my position, to allow my name to be mentioned in this Convention against my protest. The clerk will proceed with the call.^[7]

After numerous indecisive ballots, the names of John T. Hoffman, Francis P. Blair, and Stephen Johnson Field were placed in nomination. This raised the number of names placed into nomination to thirteen. None of these new candidates, however, gained much traction.

For twenty-one ballots, the opposing candidates battled it out: the East battling the West for control, the conservatives battling the radicals. The two leading candidates were determined that the other should not receive the nomination; because of the two-thirds rule of the convention, a compromise candidate was needed. Seymour still hoped it would be Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase, but on the twenty-second ballot, the chairman of the Ohio delegation announced, "at the unanimous request and demand of the delegation I place Horatio Seymour in nomination with twenty-one votes-against his inclination, but no longer against his honor."

Seymour had to wait for the rousing cheers to die down before he could address the delegates and decline.

I have no terms in which to tell of my regret that my name has been brought before this convention. God knows that my life and all that I value most in life I would give for the good of my country, which I believe to be identified with that of the Democratic party...

"Take the nomination, then!" cried someone from the floor.

...but when I said that I could not be a candidate, I meant it! I could not receive the nomination without placing not only myself but the Democratic party in a false position. God bless you for your kindness to me, but your candidate I cannot be.^[7][8]

Seymour left the platform to cool off and rest. No sooner had he left the hall than former representative Clement Vallandigham, a member of the Ohio delegation and one-time ally of Seymour, rose and proclaimed that the delegation would not accept Seymour's refusal, and that he was the only man who could break the deadlock at the convention, much less win the presidency. The chairman of New York's delegation then stood and, while bound by the convention rules not to switch its votes (which it had already cast for Hendricks) until the round of balloting had concluded, made a passionate speech in support of Seymour. The roll call continued, with Seymour only picking up one additional vote (from Tennessee), but the final state, Wisconsin, cast a blank ballot which it then immediately switched to Seymour. This started a stampede with all the remaining states quickly throwing their support behind Seymour, eventually leading to his being nominated unanimously.

In 1868, the States of Arkansas, Alabama, Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, and Louisiana were readmitted to the Union. Nebraska had been admitted to the Union on March 1, 1867. Texas, Mississippi and Virginia had not yet been readmitted to the Union.

Balloting

1st Day of Presidential Balloting / 3rd Day of Convention (July 7, 1868)

• 1st Presidential Ballot
• 2nd Presidential Ballot
• 3rd Presidential Ballot
• 4th Presidential Ballot
• 5th Presidential Ballot
• 6th Presidential Ballot

2nd Day of Presidential Balloting / 4th Day of Convention (July 8, 1868)

• 7th Presidential Ballot
• 8th Presidential Ballot
• 9th Presidential Ballot
• 10th Presidential Ballot
• 11th Presidential Ballot
• 12th Presidential Ballot
• 13th Presidential Ballot
• 14th Presidential Ballot
• 15th Presidential Ballot
• 16th Presidential Ballot
• 17th Presidential Ballot
• 18th Presidential Ballot

3rd Day of Presidential Balloting / 5th Day of Convention (July 9, 1868)

• 19th Presidential Ballot
• 20th Presidential Ballot
• 21st Presidential Ballot
• 22nd
  Presidential Ballot
  (Before Shifts)
• 22nd
  Presidential Ballot
  (After Shifts)

Vice presidential candidates

• Former Representative Francis P. Blair
  of Missouri
• Former Senator Augustus C. Dodge
  of Iowa
  (Withdrawn)
• Major General
  Thomas Ewing, Jr.
  of Kansas
  (Withdrawn)
• Former Representative John A. McClernand
  of Illinois
  (Withdrew -
  Declined Consideration)
• Major General
  William B. Franklin
  of Connecticut
  (Not Nominated)

Exhausted, the delegates unanimously nominated General Francis Preston Blair Jr. for vice-president on the first ballot after the names of Augustus C. Dodge and Thomas Ewing Jr. were withdrawn from consideration. Blair's nomination reflected a desire to balance the ticket east and west as well as north and south.^[9]

Blair had worked hard to acquire the Democratic nomination and accepted second place on the ticket, finding himself in controversy.^[10] Blair had gained attention by an inflammatory letter addressed to Colonel James O. Broadhead, dated a few days before the convention met. In his letter, Blair wrote that the "real and only issue in this contest was the overthrow of Reconstruction, as the radical Republicans had forced it in the South."^[11]

• 1st Vice-Presidential Ballot