Houston / Tennessee Oilers / Titans (1994–2010)

On November 14, 1994, Pardee was fired, and Fisher was promoted to replace him for the last six games of the season.^[11] The Oilers retained Fisher as head coach, and the Oilers drafted quarterback Steve McNair in the 1995 NFL Draft.^[12] The new coach did not disappoint, leading the team to a 7–9 record in 1995, tied for second place in the division.^[13] The following year, the Oilers added Heisman Trophy winner Eddie George, and they achieved an 8–8 record.^[14] However, an inability to get a new stadium deal in Houston caused owner Bud Adams to relocate the team to Tennessee for the 1997 season.^[15][16]

In the team's first two seasons in Tennessee, the Oilers compiled a record of 16–16.^[17][18] In 1998, the team's home games moved from Memphis to Nashville.^[19]

In the 1999 season, the newly renamed Tennessee Titans finished with a 13–3 regular season record, going all the way to Super Bowl XXXIV, in part due to the Music City Miracle.^[20] In the Super Bowl, the Titans lost to the St. Louis Rams by a score of 23–16; on the game's final play, wide receiver Kevin Dyson was tackled one yard short of the end zone with no time remaining, in what became known as "The Tackle".^[21] The Titans achieved the same record the next year, but were defeated in the AFC playoffs by the Baltimore Ravens, who would go on to win Super Bowl XXXV.^[22]

The 2001 season was a disappointing one for the Titans, as they could only muster a 7–9 showing.^[23] The beginning of the next season proved to be even worse, with the franchise starting off with a 1–4 record. Following one home loss, owner Bud Adams made the comment to reporters that perhaps the Titans "were getting outcoached." This provided a spark the team needed, and they finished the 2002 season with an 11–5 record and made it to the AFC Championship Game.^[24]

The 2003 season saw more success, with yet another trip to the playoffs and McNair tying for the League MVP award (with Peyton Manning).^[25] Again, they lost to the eventual Super Bowl champions, the New England Patriots, but the team's progress did not go unnoticed. The 2004 season, however, was plagued by injuries from the start, and the Titans finished at 5–11.^[26] Following the season, many veteran players (such as Samari Rolle and Derrick Mason) were cut in an effort to comply with the strict salary cap. The relative youth of the team resulted in a disappointing 2005 season as well. Before the 2005 season, Fisher hired Norm Chow out of USC to be his offensive coordinator.^[27]

In 2006, the Titans finished a better-than-expected 8–8.^[27] Quarterback Steve McNair was traded to the Baltimore Ravens and Vince Young was drafted, but began the season as backup to Billy Volek and Kerry Collins. The season began slowly at 0–3 before Volek was replaced by Kerry Collins and, later, Young. The team ultimately started 2–7, but following a 27–26 loss to the Baltimore Ravens and McNair, the Titans erupted to win six straight games under Young, including a 24-point rally to beat the New York Giants.^[28] With this promising record the Titans exercised their right to extend his contract by a year, keeping him as the head coach through the 2007 NFL season.

In 2007, Fisher led the Titans to a 10–6 record and made the AFC playoffs as the #6-seed, but they lost in the opening round to the San Diego Chargers.^[29]

In 2008, Fisher led the Titans to a 10–0 undefeated streak only to be upset by Brett Favre and the New York Jets midway through the 2008 season. The Titans finished 13–3 and secured the #1 seed in the AFC, but lost in the Divisional Round to the Baltimore Ravens.^[30]

In 2009, the Titans lost in overtime to the Pittsburgh Steelers in the season-opening game. The loss began a six-game slide that reached its nadir in a 59–0 slaughter by the New England Patriots.^[31] Collins, at the public recommendation of Titans owner Bud Adams, was benched and replaced by Young;^[32] the Titans responded by winning eight of their next 10 games, highlighted by a dramatic comeback victory over the Arizona Cardinals, a season-ending comeback against the Seattle Seahawks, and a hard-fought overtime win over the Miami Dolphins.^[31] Highlighting this season was the play of running back Chris Johnson; in his second year of professional football (he was drafted 24th in the 2008 NFL Draft), Johnson broke Marshall Faulk's NFL record for total yards from scrimmage with 2,509 and became the sixth back in NFL history to rush over 2,000 yards.^[33]

In 2010, relations between Fisher and Vince Young became increasingly strained. In a home game against the Washington Redskins, Young was removed following an injury to his thumb and subsequently not allowed to re-enter the game.^[34] In disgust, Young began removing his equipment while still on the sidelines, eventually throwing his shoulder pads into the stands. Young walked off of the field as the contest continued and he never appeared in another game for the Titans as he was released at the end of the season.^[35]

Initially, it appeared that Fisher's tenure with the Titans would survive this situation; however, on January 27, 2011, almost four weeks after the end of the 2010 regular season, it was formally announced that Fisher and the Titans had mutually agreed to part ways following a buyout of the one remaining season on Fisher's contract.^[36] At more than 16 full seasons, Fisher had been the longest-tenured NFL head coach with one team among active head coaches.^[37][38]

St. Louis / Los Angeles Rams (2012–2016)

After a season off in 2011, Fisher agreed to become the head coach of the St. Louis Rams on January 13, 2012.^[39]

In Fisher's first season in St. Louis, the team finished with a 7–8–1 record, a five–win improvement from the previous year.^[40]

In 2013, the Rams finished with a 7–9 record.^[41]

During the 2014 season, the Rams went 6–10.^[42] It was the team's worst record under Fisher, and also Fisher's fourth consecutive losing season as a head coach.

During the team's final season in St. Louis in 2015, they finished with a 7–9 record.^[43]

Prior to the 2016 season, Fisher gave a speech on Hard Knocks in which he said that he would not be "7–9 or 8–8 or 9–7, OK? Or 10–6 for that matter. This team's too talented. I'm not going to settle for that. I know what I'm doing." Fisher had previously been ridiculed for often finishing the season 7–9, finishing at that record four times over his 22-year career.^[44] The Rams started the 2016 season 3–1 but lost six of their next seven games leading up to the Rams' announcement, on December 4, that they had signed Fisher to a two-year contract extension through 2018.^[45] However, just over a week later, on December 12, the Rams fired Fisher following a 42–14 loss to the eventual NFC champion Atlanta Falcons in which they were held scoreless until scoring two meaningless touchdowns in the fourth quarter. This loss helped Fisher tie the record with Dan Reeves for the most regular season losses of any NFL Coach of all time.^[1]

Michigan Panthers

On January 27, 2022, it was announced that Fisher would become the head coach and general manager of the Michigan Panthers of the United States Football League, becoming Fisher's first head coaching job in six years.^[46]

On February 3, 2023, Fisher resigned as head coach of the Panthers after one season, citing "personal reasons". He was replaced by former San Francisco 49ers head coach Mike Nolan.^[47] Fisher went 2–8 (.200) in his tenure as Panthers head coach.

NFL

* – Interim head coach

USFL