Mexican immigrant experience varies by skin tone
Mexican immigrants with darker skin tones report more discrimination from US-born whites, a study in two cities finds.
Jan. 24, 2023 • 7 min • Source
Skin tone shapes the experiences of Mexican immigrants in Atlanta and Philadelphia, research finds.
While racism is often a focus of concern in the United States, skin tone—separate but related to race—plays a lesser known but important role in discrimination, according to the findings.
The study finds that Mexican immigrants with darker skin tones perceived greater racial discrimination and more frequent discrimination specifically from US-born whites than did Mexican immigrants with lighter skin tones. Those same people with darker skin tones also reported more negative responses to that discrimination, such as pulling inward and struggling internally.
The research, published in Social Psychology Quarterly , also shows that darker skin tone is nearly as strong of a predictor of such increased inner struggle as lack of documentation status.
“Skin tone is uniquely related to how Mexican immigrants are understanding their interactions with and treatment by US-born whites, even after controlling for a range of other demographic and immigration-specific factors,” says study leader Helen B. Marrow, an associate professor of sociology at Tufts University.
Colorism is distinct from racism in that it describes mistreatment based on skin tone rather than ethnic or racial category. For example, two people may both be of the same ethnicity or race, but one may perceive more frequent discrimination due to a darker skin tone .
Ellis Monk, an associate professor of sociology at Harvard University who was not involved in the research, says the new study is an “important extension” of burgeoning research on skin tone and discrimination.
“Trying to get more understanding around how people deal with discrimination is really important,” he says. He adds that “when people feel themselves to be disrespected, it has negative physiological responses for the person that can actually lead them to be physically ill over time.”
The study surveyed 500 foreign-born Mexican immigrants living in 10 counties of metropolitan Atlanta and Philadelphia, and asked participants to identify their own skin tone on a scale of one to seven, with one being “very light,” seven being “very dark,” and four being “medium.” While such measurements are subjective, Marrow says that could be an advantage. “It captures something about how people understand themselves,” she says.
Next, participants described the discrimination they’d experienced in their city since moving there, including questions about how often, where, and by whom they’d been treated well or poorly. The survey also asked participants to identify their typical responses to poor treatment, which could range from defending themselves to reporting the treatment to ignoring the discrimination altogether.
Not only were darker-skinned Mexican participants more likely to perceive discrimination from US-born whites relative to lighter-skinned respondents, but skin tone was a stronger predictor of this outcome than participants’ self-described ethnic or racial identity. The predictive results were similar in both metro areas, even as respondents in Atlanta reported higher levels of discrimination.
Participants with darker skin tones were also more likely to report responding to discrimination by struggling internally but not outwardly saying anything.
According to Marrow, this response to colorism might raise health concerns, which warrants further study.
Both metro areas included in the study are considered “new immigrant destinations” for Mexicans, or areas of the country that began to see an influx of Mexican immigration only after the 1980s. Marrow says sociologists don’t yet know as much about the role skin tone plays in the lived experiences of Mexicans in these new immigrant gateways, while much more research has been done on skin tone among Chicanos and Mexican Americans living in Texas and the Southwest.
One possible factor contributing to the results, according to Marrow, is that the racialization of Latinos living in new immigrant destinations has intensified over the past two decades, especially in the US South, where Atlanta is located. This means that Mexican immigrants’ place within local racial hierarchies has become more strongly racialized than scholars typically documented before 2000, likely affecting their perceptions of their interactions with the US-born.
Marrow says the research, conducted with colleagues at Indiana University and the University of Massachusetts Amherst, is one of the first to examine immigrants’ perceptions of discrimination in new destinations using measures of race/ethnicity and skin tone together in the same study, and to do so with a large, representative sample.
“The big implication of this is that social scientists should pay more attention to skin tone variation within our studies of race-based discrimination,” she says.
Source: Grace van Deelen for Tufts University
Share this article: